The Painted Lie

Chapter 47: The Debt Repaid

The servant announced him at the door of the small salon where Lorenzo sat with his leg propped on a stool, and Michele, seated at the table with his sketchbook, looked up at the name as though it had been spoken in a language he did not know.

"Cosimo di Bartolo," the man said, entering without waiting to be shown in. He was broad and grey and dressed in plain wool that cost more than most men's houses. He carried a leather satchel under one arm and did not remove his hat. "You are Lorenzo Malaspina."

"I am."

"You owe me four hundred and twenty florins." Cosimo set the satchel on the table and opened it, drawing out a folded sheet and smoothing it flat. "Signed in Lucca, witnessed, with interest at seven percent, and now three months overdue. I do not usually come to the debtor. But I was told you were here, and I happened to be passing through Fiesole, and so." He shrugged. "Here I am."

Lorenzo said nothing. His face had gone the color of the plaster behind him, and his hand, resting on the arm of the chair, had tightened until the knuckles stood out.

"You cannot pay," Cosimo said. It was not a question.

"No."

"Then I take what you have, or I take you. The warrant is a separate matter—I know about it, everyone knows about it, and I tell you plainly I have no wish to be seen hanging a man Cardinal Borgia wants hanged. It would be untidy." He looked around the room, at the contessa's furniture, at the window, at the two of them. "But I will not be made a fool of. Four hundred florins is not nothing."

"It is my debt," Lorenzo said. "Not hers, not his."

"I don't care whose it is. I care whose it can be."

Michele had stood without thinking. He heard his own voice before he had decided to use it.

"Take the paintings."

Both men turned.

"What paintings?" Cosimo said.

Michele crossed to the corner where the satchel of his work had been set down two days ago and opened it. He drew out the folded sheets one by one and laid them on the table in front of the banker: the Fiesole hillside at dusk, the hollow above Sesto where the bandits had scattered their horse, Lorenzo asleep in the loft with the lamp low, the Certosa's cloister with the bell tower behind it, the study for the cellarer's portrait—the cellarer himself, vain, with his chin lifted and his mouth pursed in the small self-satisfied way he had practiced for the mirror.

Cosimo did not speak for a long moment. He turned the sheets over slowly, one after another, and then again, and then he held the study of the cellarer up toward the window and looked at it the way a man looks at a coin he suspects of being soft.

"Who is he?"

"The cellarer at the Certosa," Michele said. "I made it two years ago. He liked it."

"He would." Cosimo set the sheet down. "And this—" he touched the loft drawing, the curve of Lorenzo's shoulder in the lamplight, "—this is good. Better than good."

"I have more."

"No. You have these." Cosimo's voice had changed. It had lost its flatness and taken on an edge of interest that made Michele uneasy. "Listen to me. On the open market, in Florence, with a name behind them, these are worth—" He considered. "Two hundred. Perhaps two fifty if the right man saw them before the Cardinal's men did. Not four hundred."

"Then take them and I will paint more."

"I don't want more paintings." Cosimo folded the sheets and put them back in the satchel, which he closed. Then he sat down, uninvited, in the chair across from Lorenzo, and rested his hands on his knees. "I want a favor. One favor. And the debt is forgiven—all of it, principal and interest, and I will hold these as surety and say nothing about them to anyone."

Lorenzo's eyes narrowed. "What favor?"

"A portrait."

Michele laughed once, without meaning to, and stopped when no one else did.

"Not a portrait like these," Cosimo said. "A portrait with a lie in it. There is a senator in Florence—his name I will keep for now—who has made an enemy of certain friends of mine. I want a likeness of him, in his own dress, in his own house, that shows him doing something he did not do and that he cannot deny. A letter half-hidden on his desk. A ring he does not wear. A seal on a document. Something small. Something that no one would question in a painting, because a painter would not invent it."

"You want me to forge evidence," Michele said. "In paint. Against a man I have never met, whose name you will not tell me, so that you may blackmail him."

"I want a favor," Cosimo said. "You may call it what you like after."

Lorenzo was looking at Michele. Michele could feel the weight of it, and he did not look back. He was thinking of the blankness of Cosimo's voice when he had said the warrant was a separate matter—the way the man had folded four hundred florins into the word *untidy*, and the way he had looked at the loft drawing, at Lorenzo's shoulder in the lamplight, and known exactly what it was worth.

"No," Michele said.

Cosimo raised his eyebrows.

"No. I will paint your senator's enemy in his own dress, in his own house, if you bring me to him—I will paint him truly, and you may do what you like with the truth of a face. But I will not paint a lie into it. A letter he did not write is not a fault of the brush. It is a lie, and it would be a lie in my hand, and I would have to sign it, or they would ask who painted it, and I would not be able to say it was not me."

"You signed these," Cosimo said, tapping the satchel.

"Those are true."

Cosimo stood. For a moment Michele thought the man would take the satchel and go, and the debt would stand, and they would be in the street by nightfall with Borgia's men on the road and no four hundred florins and no ship and no way back. He felt Lorenzo tense beside him, and he did not move.

Then Cosimo said, "There is a senator named Palmieri. He keeps a house on the Via de' Bardi. On the fourth day from now, in the afternoon, he is at home alone with his ledgers, and the light through his study window is very good—I have looked at it. If you come and paint him truly, and the truth happens to include a letter on his desk, then you have painted what you saw. You will not have lied. And I will consider my four hundred florins well spent." He picked up the satchel and held it out toward Michele, who did not take it. "Keep them for now. As a sign of good faith."

"Four days from now we will be gone," Michele said.

"Then you will not be." Cosimo put the satchel back on the table. "You will be here, or I will find you, and the debt will be four hundred and twenty florins, and the warrant will still stand, and I will be considerably less patient." He put his hat on straight and walked to the door. There he stopped, without turning. "I do not care whether you call it a lie, painter. I care that the letter is on the desk when I come to look."

He left. The door closed behind him. In the silence, Lorenzo let out a long breath, and Michele sat down slowly in the chair Cosimo had vacated and looked at the satchel on the table—his own drawings inside it, which a man he did not trust would now keep, or not keep, or hold over him, depending on what happened on the fourth day.

"We are leaving," Lorenzo said. "Tonight. The coast road to Livorno."

"No," Michele said. "We are going to the Certosa. Tonight, on the coast road, with four days already half gone and a fever in your leg?" He shook his head. "The favor buys us the fourth day. We take the Certosa first, then Livorno, and we pray the ship still waits."

Lorenzo looked at the closed door, and then at Michele, and something in his face had closed again, the way it had closed in the loft above the sea. "You refused a man who could hang us," he said. "For a senator you have never met."

"I refused to lie in paint."

"You refused to lie in paint to a banker, with Borgia's warrant over your head, to save four hundred florins we do not have." Lorenzo's voice was quiet. "I have never met anyone like you."

"Then stop planning to die for me," Michele said, "and start planning to live."

He pulled the map out of the satchel and spread it on the table, and set the Contessa's schedule beside it, and began to draw the line from Fiesole to the Certosa to Livorno, and did not see Lorenzo's face as he did it—which was a mercy, because he would not have understood it.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.