The Painted Lie

Chapter 48: Aftermath of Debt

The study smelled of burnt wax and cold ash. Michele stood with his back to the window, watching Lorenzo read the banker's letter a second time. Cosimo had left it on the desk between them like a card played in a game neither of them had agreed to join, and then he had walked out into the rain without another word, his man holding the umbrella, leaving the three paintings stacked against the wall where Michele had set them.

Lorenzo put the letter down.

"Four days," he said. "The ninth is the ship. The fourth day is the senator."

"The fourth day is Cosimo's fourth day. He counts from today." Michele picked up the letter and read it again though he already knew every stroke of it. Cosimo's hand was small and precise, the hand of a man who had never once written a word he did not intend. *The favor is simple. A portrait of Senator Palmieri, seated, the letter on the desk before him. The letter to be legible. The letter to be the letter you have seen in my keeping. A painter who can do this will find his debt gone and his patrons quiet. A painter who cannot will find the debt called at once, and the warrant that travels with him will be the least of his troubles.*

Legible. That was the knifepoint hidden in the soft word.

"He wants the letter painted," Michele said. "Not hidden in shadow. Not folded. Painted so that anyone who looks at the portrait can read what the senator wrote and to whom."

"To Cosimo's rival," Lorenzo said. "The one whose name is in the archive. Palmieri sold him the grain contracts, and Cosimo has been waiting for a way to hold it over him. A portrait hanging in a public room would do it. Everyone who passes would see."

"Everyone but Palmieri's friends would see. Which is the point." Michele set the letter down and looked at the stack of his paintings leaning against the wall—the two small landscapes, the study of the contessa's garden he had made in a single afternoon, the little head of a boy he had done from memory in the hollow above Sesto. All of it was surety now. Cosimo's man had taken them from the room before Cosimo left, and Cosimo had not asked. He had simply gestured, and the man had lifted them, and the leaving had been a fact.

Lorenzo said, "You told him no."

"I told him I would not paint a lie into a man's face."

"And he said—"

"That I would only be painting what I saw."

Lorenzo laughed, one short breath with no humor in it. He was sitting on the edge of the bed, his bandaged shoulder still stiff, his good hand resting flat on his knee. The physician had changed the dressing that morning and said the wound was closing clean, but Lorenzo moved like a man who had decided his body belonged to someone else. "What you see," he said. "You would see a letter on the desk. You would paint it. Where is the lie?"

"The lie is that I would choose the letter. The lie is in the choosing. Palmieri is a fool and a traitor and I do not care what happens to him, but if I paint that letter I am not painting a portrait, I am painting a sentence. Cosimo will hang it where it will be read, and someone will read it, and Palmieri will hang or worse, and I will have done it with a brush because I needed four hundred and twenty florins."

"You did need them."

"The debt is not the question. The question is what I am willing to be." Michele crossed the room and sat down on the floor with his back against the bed frame, close enough that his shoulder touched Lorenzo's knee. "I spent a year painting for men who wanted their wives prettier and their noses smaller. I told myself it was work. I told myself I would paint truly when I had the freedom to. This is the same bargain with a sharper edge on it. If I take it, I am the kind of painter who takes it."

Lorenzo was quiet. Then he said, "You are also the kind of painter who is alive. Which the dead generally are not."

"That is Guardi's argument and it is a good one and I do not want to hear it from you."

"You will hear it from me." Lorenzo's voice was low. "I am the man who went to the Certosa alone in his head, Michele. I know what it is to trade a life for an idea. I did it and it cost me nothing because they caught me before I could pay. But the trade is still in me. When I look at you I see a man who would rather be right than be here in the morning."

"I would rather be here in the morning with you. That is not the same as being right."

Lorenzo looked at him then, and for a moment the distance that had been sitting in his face since the villa cracked and showed something underneath it, tired and unguarded. He put his good hand on Michele's head, not quite stroking, just holding it there, the way a man holds a thing he is afraid of dropping.

"Gone," Lorenzo said. "We would have to go before Cosimo returns. The paintings stay. He keeps them as surety against nothing, because we will not be here."

"He will know we ran."

"He will know we chose something else. He is a banker. He will write it in a ledger and move on to the next man who needs him." Lorenzo took his hand away. "I told you once that you were not made for this. I was wrong. You are made for it and it is eating you. But I would rather watch it eat you in France than in a cell under the bell tower."

Michele stood up. "Then we go. Not the ninth—the ninth is the ship. We go to the Certosa first."

Lorenzo's jaw tightened. "The plan was to use the cellarer. That plan needed four days at least, and a portrait of a monk who may not even be at the Certosa anymore. Guardi's word is the only thread we have and Guardi's word has been wrong before."

"Guardi's word is all we have. And Alessandro has been moved. We cannot wait for a better door to open. If we take the ship on the ninth, we take it without him."

"And if we go to the Certosa and are caught, we are both hanged on the road and Alessandro hangs after us, and there is no France, and there is no painting, and there is nothing at all."

"Then we are caught, and we are caught together, which is more than you offered me when you packed your satchel."

Lorenzo did not answer. The rain had stopped; through the window the sky over the ridge had gone the color of a nail. Somewhere below in the house a door opened and closed, and a servant's voice said something in the corridor, muffled, and then it was quiet again.

Michele went to the corner where his satchel stood open. He had already put in the chalks and the brush-roll and the two clean panels. He had kept out the little head of the boy, the one he had made in the hollow, because he wanted it with him, not in Cosimo's hands. He slid it in now, between the panels, and turned.

"You should rest tonight," he said. "We leave before light."

"Where."

"South by the wall, then the old road toward Prato. Guardi said he would meet us where he met us before, at the quarry below the Certosa, if we came within the week. That is three days of walking if we push."

"Three days if nothing happens."

"Nothing has happened so far." Michele said it lightly, and Lorenzo gave him a look that was not quite a smile but had the shape of one, and that was enough—more than he had gotten in days.

Michele pulled the satchel closed and set it by the door. He took off his doublet and lay down on the narrow bed, and after a moment he felt the mattress dip as Lorenzo lay down beside him, careful of the shoulder. They did not speak. The candle burned down. Outside, a night bird called once from the ridge and then did not call again.

In the morning, before the servants were up, they went out through the kitchen door with the satchel and the two panels wrapped in cloth, and walked down through the gate and onto the road that led away from Fiesole, away from the contessa's table and Cosimo's letter and the ship that would be waiting on the ninth for passengers who would not come. Lorenzo walked slowly, favoring the shoulder. Michele carried the satchel. At the bend of the road they stopped and looked back once at the villa standing gray against the gray hill, and then they went on, south, toward the quarry and whatever was waiting for them there.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 48: Aftermath of Debt · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads