The Painted Lie

Chapter 5: The Forger's Dilemma

The knock came at the third bell, when the studio was still gray with dawn and Michele had not yet decided whether he would paint at all that day.

He opened the door with a brush still in his hand. Lorenzo stood on the step, unshaven, a plain cloak thrown over his silk. No servant, no escort. He looked like a man who had not slept, which was how Michele himself had looked in the small cracked mirror for three nights running.

"Walk with me," Lorenzo said.

"Where."

"Away from the house."

They went down through the olive terraces behind the villa, where the dew lay heavy and the town below was only a smear of rooftops in the mist. Lorenzo said nothing until they were well out of sight of the windows. Then he stopped at a stone wall and put both hands flat on it, as though he needed the support.

"You have been watching me," he said.

"Yes."

"And asking questions I forbade you to ask."

"Yes."

Lorenzo turned. In the gray light his face was not the polished thing it was indoors. There was fear in it, badly hidden. "Good," he said. "I chose you because you wouldn't stop."

Michele said nothing. He had learned, in a week at this villa, that silence pulled words out of men faster than questions.

"There is no Camilla Strozzi," Lorenzo said.

The mist moved below them. Somewhere a bell rang for prime.

"Or rather," Lorenzo went on, "there is no wedding. There is a contract, a dowry, a bride on the road from Rome - all of it paper. All of it noise, so that no one listens to the quieter sounds. Do you understand what I am telling you?"

"You are telling me I have been painting a lie for a month."

"I am telling you that you have been painting a wall. The lie is the wall. What matters is what stands behind it."

Michele set his jaw. He thought of the altered miniature, the raised brow, the softened mouth - all that careful work to make a real face remember-able as someone else. He thought of his folded sketch hidden in the satchel's lining. "Then why the portrait at all? If there is no bride, why pay a painter a fortune to make one?"

"Because I needed a man in this house who could draw a face accurately and keep his mouth shut, and I could not hire such a man openly without every clerk in Florence asking why." Lorenzo smiled without warmth. "The portrait is the invitation. You are the purpose."

Michele laughed once, short. "You could have said so. You could have written me a letter."

"Letters are opened."

"Then you could have told me to my face on the first morning, when I was sitting in your study with your coin on the table."

"And you would have walked out that door and told the first tavern you passed." Lorenzo shook his head. "No. I had to see whether you would dig. A man who digs is a man who can be trusted with a hole. A man who takes the money and asks nothing is a man who sells what he knows the moment it is worth more."

"So this whole month has been a test."

"Part of it."

"And the hooded men in your garden? The scholars? The passage south of the Arno?"

Lorenzo's expression did not change. "You heard all that."

"I hear better than I paint."

"Then hear the rest." Lorenzo pushed off the wall and began walking again, slower, down toward a stand of cypress. Michele followed. "There are men in this city - good men, learned men - whom the Signoria has decided are inconvenient. Some of them studied in Padua and came home with ideas about how a republic should be governed. Some of them translated books the Church would rather left untranslated. Last winter three of them were taken in the night. Two recanted. One did not, and he is not in Florence anymore, and no one speaks his name."

"And the others?"

"Nine of them, at present, are living quietly in this city with false names and borrowed trades, waiting." Lorenzo stopped beneath the cypresses. "They cannot leave openly. The gates are watched, the roads are watched, and a scholar with a Greek book under his arm and callus on his fingers from a pen is not difficult to notice. So we give them papers. Not the papers of Florence - those are checked against the rolls. Papers of other cities. Passes, letters of introduction, safe-conducts. And every paper needs a face, because a man with a face that does not match his name is a dead man at the first checkpoint."

Michele's mouth had gone dry. "You want me to forge."

"I want you to paint. Or draw. Ink portraits, small, quick, carried inside the folded papers. You have done them before - every painter has, for merchants who want a likeness to send ahead."

"That is not the same as making a man into someone else."

"No," Lorenzo said. "It is better paid."

It should have been a simple thing to refuse. He was a painter, not a conspirator; he had a mother in Santa Croce who expected him to be respectable, and a satchel with a sketch in its lining that could ruin him if the wrong hands found it. He should have said no, taken his advance, gone home, and painted ceilings for the friars.

But he was looking at Lorenzo's hands. The diplomat's hands, which had done nothing all month but rest on the arms of chairs and turn the pages of contracts, were trembling very slightly at his sides. The man was afraid. Not of the Signoria, not of the road - afraid that Michele would say no.

"Why me," Michele said. "There are a dozen painters in Florence who could do this and be glad of the work."

"Because a dozen painters would take my coin and their neighbors' coin too. Because I watched you notice that the miniature was altered, and I watched you go quiet instead of crowing about it. Because you asked the maid questions and then stopped, and then asked better ones." Lorenzo met his eyes. "And because the last man who did this work for me was found in the Arno in April, and I am not yet so tired of myself that I will let another fool take his place without first knowing what he is."

The mist was burning off. Michele could see the town now, the dome, the thin smoke of morning fires. He thought of the dead man, whoever he had been, face down in brown water. He thought of the portrait that did not need to exist, the bride who did not need to arrive, the whole furnished lie he had been living in for a month.

He thought, too - and this was the thought he did not say aloud - of the way Lorenzo had stood in the lamplight the first night, holding the door, and the way his gaze had rested a half-beat too long when Michele bent over his work. He had noticed it and dismissed it. Now, standing in the cold under the cypresses with the man's fear laid bare, he found he could not dismiss it so easily.

"I will need to know the things you can't tell," Michele said.

"You will know what you need to know. No more. That is not distrust - it is how these things are done. If you are caught, you cannot give up what you never learned."

"And if I am caught anyway?"

Lorenzo's mouth tightened. "Then you will be a young painter who overstepped, and I will be a diplomat who was much too trusting, and the papers will have been prepared in another city by a hand no one can find. That is the arrangement."

Michele was quiet a long moment.

"I'll do it," he said. "Not for the coin."

"No?"

"For the men in the borrowed trades. And because I would like to know what your predecessor looked like, so that I can paint a better face onto the page than he ended with in the river."

Lorenzo did not flinch. But something passed over his face - relief, or grief, or both. "His name was Tommaso," he said. "You have his easel. The one with the chipped foot."

Michele had noticed the chipped foot on the first day and said nothing.

"Then I have already been working in a dead man's studio," he said.

"Yes."

"Very well." He turned back toward the villa. "When do I begin?"

"Tomorrow." Lorenzo fell into step beside him. "There is a scholar waiting on the other side of the river under the name of a wool merchant. His real name is Giovanni da Ravenna, and he has been three weeks in a room with the shutters closed, and tomorrow he will sit for you. He does not know what he looks like anymore. You will have to tell him."

"Tell him what?"

"Who he is going to be next." Lorenzo paused at the top of the terrace. "Draw him younger, if you can. A man's vanity is the easiest thing to hide a lie inside."

Michele stopped.

"If he sits for me," he said slowly, "he will see my face as well as I see his."

"He will."

"And the papers that come of it will carry my hand. Anyone who takes one of your scholars at a checkpoint will have a portrait by Michele di Bartolo to match against every other paper in the city."

"Yes," Lorenzo said. "That is the risk. It is also why no one will believe it. A forger with a signature is a fool, and a fool could not do this work. You will be invisible precisely because you are traceable."

Michele looked at him. The diplomat's hands had stopped trembling. Whatever he had needed from that walk, he had gotten it.

"And if it comes to it," Michele said, "and they take me at a checkpoint with your scholar and his false paper - do I know enough to save him?"

"No," Lorenzo said. "You know enough to save the others."

He walked on toward the villa, and Michele stood on the terrace a moment alone, looking down at the town. Somewhere across the river a man named Giovanni da Ravenna was sitting in the dark behind closed shutters, waiting to become someone. And tomorrow Michele would draw him a face, and sign it with a skill that was meant to condemn him, and begin to carry, in his own hand, the weight of every man he made.

He followed Lorenzo down. Halfway to the door, he remembered the sketch inside his satchel - the true face of the woman who did not exist - and understood that whatever Lorenzo had told him this morning, the lie of Camilla Strozzi had not yet been explained at all.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 5: The Forger's Dilemma · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads