The Painted Lie

Chapter 6: The First Portrait

Michele had never forged anything before. He had copied—every apprentice in Florence copied, filling books with other men's hands and signatures until the master made them stop—but copying to deceive was different, and he felt the difference in his stomach like a swallowed coin.

Henrietta's husband Ferro, the steward with the thick neck and no questions, had brought him a boy's tunic, a cheap wool cap, a tarnished medallion, and a piece of paper listing details of a life that did not exist. "He comes at the third hour," Ferro said. "You'll have two sessions. Three if the light is bad, but Lorenzo wants him moving by Friday."

"Moving where?"

Ferro's face closed. "You will be paid at the end."

The man who came at the third hour was not old, though he moved like someone older. He entered the studio sideways, as if the door frame might bite, and stood with his cap held against his chest in both hands, crushing it slowly. He was perhaps forty. His hands were a scholar's hands—ink-stained at the fingertips, soft where the brush held them—but there was a fresh scrape across one knuckle, and the knuckle was swollen.

"Giovanni," he said. "Giovanni da Ravenna."

"Sit, maestro."

Giovanni sat, and then stood back up, and then sat again, as if remembering something he hadn't finished thinking. "They told me—they say you make the picture in two days. That is very quick."

"It's a small portrait." Michele set the board on the easel, cracked along one edge, the wood golden with years of hands. Tommaso's easel. He had stopped thinking about that, or told himself he had. "Head and shoulders. Enough for a gate."

"For a gate," Giovanni repeated, and laughed, a short dry sound with nothing in it.

Michele began the underpainting. He didn't need the description—he had spent the morning memorizing it: a silk merchant of Perugia, name of Marco di Bartolo, born in '71, travels with samples, holds no office, is of no interest to anyone. The entire purpose of the man on the board was to hold no interest. That was the craft of it, Michele understood now. Not a beautiful face. A forgettable one.

But the face in front of him was not forgettable, and Michele couldn't decide whether that made it easier or harder. The brow was high and pale with a scar through one eyebrow. The nose had been broken once, long ago, and set badly. The eyes were the problem. They looked at Michele the way a man looks at a boat when he cannot swim.

"Look at my left ear," Michele said. "Not at me. At the ear."

Giovanni looked, or tried to. Every few breaths his gaze drifted back. "You have done this many times."

"No."

"Ah." Giovanni's mouth twitched. "Then we are both novices."

Michele set the first shadow under the brow. "Who told you what to do? At the gate, I mean."

"Young Lorenzo. He gave me a card with the words written on it, and the answers, and the name of the inn where I should stop." Giovanni's voice dropped, though there was no one in the corridor. "He said to answer questions plainly. He said—ah, but that's the trouble. He said if they search my bag—"

"Don't."

"I know. I know. But I think of it at night. My bag. If they open my bag, everything is finished. I have two books in it that do not exist anymore, and the letters—"

"Then don't carry the letters."

"I cannot burn them." Giovanni's hand went to his chest, then stopped, as if he had caught himself doing something he was not supposed to do in front of a stranger. "You think I'm a fool."

"I think you should sit still for the mouth," Michele said, "or the picture will come out with your lips moving, and a face that talks on a portrait is a face a guard remembers."

Giovanni laughed again, and this time a little of the real man came through the dry sound, and Michele caught it and put it into the turn of the cheek.

He worked. The light was good. It was a strange happiness, actually—the old happiness, the reason he had picked up a brush at nine years old, the reason his father had beaten him for drawing chickens in the flour when he should have been turning the millstone. A face going down onto a board under his hand. That part had not changed. It would never change. It was only the lie beneath it that was new.

"Maestro," Giovanni said, after a long while.

"Michele."

"Michele. When you finish—when this face is done—will you keep the other one? My own? I mean, will there be some drawing of me, somewhere, that is truly me?"

Michele's hand paused. "Do you want there to be?"

"I don't know. I think—" Giovanni looked at him, finally, properly, the man and not the ear. "In Ravenna there was a panel in the Cathedral with my father's name on it, because he paid for the candles. That is the only thing of us left there. He sold the shop. There is no one to remember the shape of my face." He picked at the swollen knuckle. "I would like to know that somewhere on this earth, the shape of my face is drawn by someone who knows it is mine."

Michele said nothing. He turned the board slightly, to catch the light.

At the end of the session, when Giovanni had gone with Ferro down the corridor—Michele could hear the steward's flat voice, "this way, maestro, this way"—Michele sat alone in the studio with the wet board and did not clean his brushes. It was a poor likeness of Marco di Bartolo, the silk merchant of Perugia. It was an excellent likeness of the scar through the man's brow. He had put it in. He had put it in because that was what the face did, and he could not make his hand tell a different story. Tomorrow he would paint over it. Tomorrow he would make Marco di Bartolo's brow smooth and dull and anonymous, and put nothing in it, and that would be the whole duty of the portrait: to be forgotten by everyone who ever looked at it.

He thought of the miniature. Camilla Strozzi's eyes: the courier's eyes, alive and watching him from the locked room of Lorenzo's desk. He thought of the little stack of paper in his satchel's lining, the true face and the false face from the miniature, side by side, and the two books inside Giovanni's bag, and the letters he could not burn.

The door opened without a knock.

Michele's fist closed around the brush, absurdly, as if a brush were something to be armed with. It was Lorenzo. He had dirt on his sleeve, and he smelled faintly of the stables and rain. He looked at the board first. He always looked at the board first, before he looked at any man.

"Good," he said. "Very like."

"He doesn't look like that."

"He doesn't need to look like that. He needs to look like Marco di Bartolo, and you have made him so." Lorenzo came around the easel, and stopped a half-step behind Michele, close enough that Michele could feel the cool coming off his wet coat. "What did he say to you?"

Michele thought of the letters, the two books, the scar, the father's name in the Cathedral. "That he is afraid."

"He should be. Let it do its work." Lorenzo's finger tapped the corner of the board. "The checkpoint at the southern gate has changed its officer, Michele. The new man is one of Cosimo's men, and Cosimo's men do not forget a face. If this portrait fails, the man who carries it does not simply turn back and try another road." His voice was even, and that evenness was worse than shouting. "So I ask you, plainly—do you know enough to make a scholar pass?"

"I know what he looks like."

"That is not an answer."

Michele set down the brush, though the paint was drying on it, and turned to face him. For a moment they were standing chest to chest, less than a hand's width apart, and Michele could see the tired lines under Lorenzo's eyes, in a face that was too young to have earned them.

"I'll know enough by Friday," Michele said, "if you tell me one thing, and tell me truly. The courier you ride to the south gate. The one in the miniature. Is he the one who reports to Cosimo, or is he the one who is going to be caught?"

Lorenzo's eyes changed. It was a small change—a narrowing, a breath held—and in it Michele saw, clearly, for the first time since the first morning, that he had found the right thread, and that it was going to cost him something to pull.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 6: The First Portrait · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads