The boy who sold eels by the Rialto bridge tugged Michele's sleeve and pointed down a narrow calle that stank of wet rope and old cabbage. "Third door. The one with the green shutters. He don't come out much."
Michele paid him with a copper and pressed the coin into his palm so it would not be seen. Lorenzo hung back at the mouth of the alley, hat low, watching both ends of the street the way he had watched every street since Vicenza. His right hand rested against his coat, where a knife he could no longer grip steadily lay useless.
They had entered Venice three days before, crossing on a fishing boat at Mestre after abandoning the road, and had spent the nights in a cell-like room above a printer's shop in the Merceria while Lorenzo's contact sent cautious word ahead. The printer had asked no names. That was the mercy of Venice, and also its danger: no names meant no protection.
The door with the green shutters opened before Michele could knock.
Maestro Paolo stood in the doorway with a clay cup in his hand, thinner than he had been, grey streaking the black of his beard, his left arm held stiff against his chest. He looked at Michele for a long moment without speaking. Then his face broke, and he dropped the cup.
"You," he said. "You. I had heard you were dead. Twice."
"They were mistaken twice," Michele said, and then Paolo's good arm was around him and they were both speaking at once, words tumbling over each other in the dark little entryway, Paolo repeating his name like a prayer answered and Michele holding his old master's shoulders and feeling through the thin wool how much of the man had been taken by the cells.
Lorenzo came in last and shut the door.
The room was one long chamber with a brick floor and a window that gave onto a courtyard of pigeon-netting and hanging rags. There was a table, a pallet, three easels stacked in a corner, and a smell of linseed oil under the smell of damp. On one easel, a small panel stood half-finished: a woman's hand holding a lemon, painted with a delicacy that made Michele's throat hurt.
"You are working," Michele said.
"I am working on a lemon," Paolo said. "It has taken me four months. When I was your age I did a ceiling in six weeks." He poured wine with his right hand only, the left hanging. "Sit. Both of you. Tell me what the Signoria has done to you, and then I will tell you what they have done to me, and we will see who has been robbed more."
They sat. Lorenzo told it plainly, in the voice he used for reports—the arrest, the barges, the fortress, the faked drawing, the goat door, the road north. Paolo listened without interrupting, his cup forgotten on the table. When Lorenzo finished, Paolo looked at Michele.
"You went into Sarzanello with a lie and a charcoal sketch."
"I went in with a portrait that was never finished."
"That is what I taught you," Paolo said, "and I never meant it like that." But he was almost smiling. He refilled the cups. "The truth is out, Michele. Sarzanello's commander is finished; the notary's record of Lorenzo's transfer and the date of the execution was copied by a clerk who had a conscience and a brother in Lucca." He leaned forward. "And the letters. The intercepted letters tying Florence's Signoria to the Rome hanging. They are in circulation now. Not printed—printed is death—but hand-copied, thirty, forty copies, moving between courts. The Doge's secretary has one. The English ambassador has one. The Florentine Signoria is denying it publicly and burning copies privately, which is the surest confession a government can make."
Lorenzo's face did not move. "And Alessandro's name is in those copies."
"It is."
Michele saw Lorenzo's good hand make a small movement in his lap, the fingers trying to close and failing.
"Good," Lorenzo said quietly.
Paolo watched him for a moment, then turned to Michele with an impatience that was entirely his old self. "Now. The scholar. You were hired to forge a portrait, and behind the portrait there was a list of names. The names of men the Signoria wanted moved, watched, or removed. Was there a scholar on that list? A man called Cesare Renzi?"
Michele's blood went cold to the wrists. He had spent six months painting a wedding portrait of a diplomat's wife while pretending he could not read the papers left open on the desk beneath it. One of those papers had held a column of names. He had never been certain of the seventh.
"Renzi," he said. "Seventh name. I was never sure of the ink. I only—"
"Good," Paolo said. "Because Renzi is alive."
The word sat in the room.
"I saw a notice of his death," Lorenzo said slowly. "Posted in Florence. The fourth of the month."
"The fourth of the month they wanted him dead. He was in Mantua in a cardinal's household, cataloguing Greek manuscripts, and a friend of mine—" Paolo's mouth twisted. "A friend of mine who owed me a debt carried him a warning by way of a laundry woman and a papal courier. He wrote me a letter from Mantua in January. He is alive, Lorenzo. The man you were accused of killing with your forged letters is breathing in a scriptorium and complaining about the price of vellum."
Lorenzo stood up. He walked to the window and stood with his back to them, and Michele watched his shoulders rise and fall, once, twice.
"Say it again," Lorenzo said.
"Renzi lives. He writes to me. He blames me for hiring you and the Signoria for everything else."
Lorenzo turned around. His eyes were bright in the way that meant he had not wept and would not. "You are telling me that the death I have carried for three years is a rumor painted to look like a fact."
"I am telling you," Paolo said, "that you were not a murderer. You were useful, and then you were inconvenient. There is a difference, and the difference is that a murderer can be forgiven."
Michele looked from one man to the other. He understood, suddenly, what Paolo was doing—not merely delivering news, but giving Lorenzo back the thing the fortress had taken, which was not his hand.
"I promised him I would paint Alessandro," Michele said, to no one in particular. "From your description."
"If he is alive," Lorenzo said.
That stopped the room.
Paolo set his cup down with a click. "Alessandro? The copyist? No. He is dead. That one is true." He said it gently, which was worse than saying it plainly. "The hanging in Rome was real. I have seen the record with my own eyes. But Cesare Renzi—" He crossed to the stacked easels and lifted the top one aside, and beneath it, on the floor, was a wooden box of the kind used for carrying pigments. He opened it and drew out a folded paper, softening at the creases. "Renzi copied this in Mantua. He copied it because a friend asked him what he thought of a forgery attributed to him. Read the bottom."
Michele took the paper. It was a letter in Latin, in a hand copied so carefully it seemed printed, and at the bottom Renzi had written three lines in Greek. Paolo translated without waiting.
"What is forged is the name at the bottom. The name belongs to a dead man. I have never signed anything in my life but a list of books, and that, only when I owed the bookseller money. Tell the painter he may stop running, if he wants to. But tell him also that whoever forged my name did it from Florence, in the Signoria's own scriptorium, and the same hand forged a letter to Rome four days before the copyist was taken."
Michele read the lines again in Greek, slowly, sounding them out. He knew enough to be sure Paolo had not softened them.
Lorenzo came and took the letter from his hands and read it too, and when he got to the last line he laughed, once, with no humor in it at all.
"The same hand," he said. "The Signoria's scriptorium. Every letter in the case against Alessandro was copied by a man inside the Signoria. I signed them. I did not write them."
The room was quiet. Outside, someone was beating a carpet over a balcony and the pigeons were going up in a grey commotion.
Then Paolo said the thing that changed the shape of everything.
"The clerk who copied them is named Ulivieri. He was promoted in February and he is here. In Venice. He is lodging with the Spanish embassy and calling himself a secretary."