The Painted Lie

Chapter 60: The New Beginning

The workshop sat above a rope-maker's shed in the crooked lane that ran behind the Frari, and the rent was cheap for one reason only: the floor sloped, the roof leaked over the northeast corner, and the previous tenant had died there in February without anyone noticing until the smell came through the boards.

Michele stood in the middle of it with his hands on his hips and counted what they had.

"One window," he said.

"One window," Lorenzo agreed, from the doorway.

"It faces a wall."

"It faces a wall."

"The light comes in sideways for perhaps two hours a day."

"Three, in summer." Lorenzo stepped in and turned a slow circle, his boots loud on the bare boards. He was still thin, still moved like a man protecting a wound, but he had walked the whole way up the stairs without stopping to breathe, and Michele had noticed, and had said nothing, because Lorenzo would have noticed him noticing.

"The light is the whole thing," Michele said. "A painter without light is a man with a brush and a grudge."

"Then we paint in the morning and lie to clients in the afternoon. You're good at the first. I'm better at the second." Lorenzo went to the window and worked the shutter, which stuck, then gave, slamming open against the wall. Grey lagoon light fell across a floor of warped planks and a fireplace with a bird's nest in the flue. "There. Light."

"It's the colour of dishwater."

"It's Venetian," Lorenzo said. "You'll learn to like it, or you'll starve."

That was the argument, in the end, and it was not really about light. They had spent three days in the lodging house by the Frari, paying by the night, and on the third morning the woman who kept it had come up the stairs and stood in the doorway with her arms folded and looked at them for a long time without saying anything, and then said only, "How long."

They had no answer. They had no money. The grey horse was a week behind them in a farm outside Vicenza and the man who owned the farm had been promised payment in a currency that did not exist. Michele had done two portraits in the Veneto for coin that was already gone — a wool merchant's wife who had wanted her nose corrected, a priest who had wanted his corrected in the other direction — and he had begun, without ever saying it aloud, to sign them with names that were not his own.

Venice wanted a man to be someone. Any someone. Venice did not care which.

They climbed the stairs on a Tuesday and paid the rope-maker's widow two months in advance with the last of what Lorenzo had sewn into his coat seam in Florence, which had survived the fortress, the flight, and the fever, and which Michele suspected he had been saving for exactly this: not for escape, but for the moment escape stopped being possible.

"We stay," Lorenzo said, when the widow had gone down and the coins were on the table.

Michele looked at the coins. Then at the window. Then at Lorenzo, who was standing very straight, as if the decision had cost him something he did not intend to show.

"We stay," Michele said. "What about your contacts? The printer in the Merceria, the glassmaker—"

"No."

"They could help us. Papers, a name—"

"And they could hand us to whoever in this city is holding a folded paper with our description folded inside it." Lorenzo shook his head. "You saw the soldiers on the road. Someone knew we were coming. Everyone who knows that is a door we don't knock on."

"So we're alone."

"We're alone with two months of rent and a hole in the roof." Lorenzo almost smiled. It was still strange on him, that expression, like a coat cut for a larger man. "It's more than we've had since Florence."

They worked. There was no other word for what the first weeks were. Michele scraped the walls down to plaster and whitewashed them; Lorenzo found a carpenter in San Polo who sold them boards for a price that suggested the boards had been stolen twice, and they laid a floor over the worst of the slope. Michele built an easel out of the old shutter, and a grinding stone for colours sat in the corner where the table would go, and the smell of linseed and crushed lapis gradually replaced the smell of the dead man.

The lapis was a problem. Blue was money. Blue was always money.

"Ultramarine," Michele said one evening, holding the last of a small twist of powder up to the window. "This is the end of it. Two more portraits and I'll be painting with soot and hope."

"Then paint with soot and hope," Lorenzo said from the table, where he had set up a ledger he'd bought from the same carpenter, ruled into columns with a straight-edge and a steady hand. He had spent two days writing down everything they owed and everything they were owed, and the second column was almost empty. "The Florentine merchants here don't buy ultramarine. They buy a likeness that makes them look like their fathers. Cheaper to produce and the same price."

"I'm not a counterfeiter."

"No." Lorenzo looked up, pen still. "You're a forger who's found honest work. There's a difference and I'm aware of it."

Michele set down the twist of powder, came over, and read the ledger upside down. He could not make out the numbers very well, but he could make out the line at the bottom, and the line at the bottom was short and angry.

"The woman by the Frari," he said. "She'll pay for a portrait of her son."

"She'll pay a third of what it's worth and tell her friends you did it for love. That's not a business, that's a charity with extra steps."

"Then find me a better one."

"I intend to." Lorenzo turned a page and began again, his letters small and exact. "There's a broker in Rialto who handles English wool. He was pointed out to me at the market; he dresses like a man who wants a wall that says something about him. That's your painting. And there's a German with a house on the Grand Canal who's been buying paintings he doesn't understand because the men he does business with do understand them." He glanced up. "You paint. I'll sell. That's the arrangement."

"And if they ask where we came from?"

"Then I'll tell them the truth in the parts that don't matter. A workshop in Florence. A patron who died. A city that stopped loving us." Lorenzo's pen moved again. "They'll believe it because most of it's true. That's how you survive in Venice — you give them a true story with the dangerous rooms bricked up."

Michele stood behind him for a while without speaking. The light through the window was going the colour of dishwater again, and somewhere below, the rope-maker's widow was calling her cat, and beyond the wall a bell was ringing in the Frari, and he thought — with a clarity that surprised him — that he had expected to feel like a fugitive in this room, and did not.

He felt like a man in a workshop.

"Say it," Lorenzo said, without turning.

"Say what?"

"You've been holding the same breath since we paid the widow. Say it."

Michele went back to the easel and touched the shutter-wood with two fingers. "I want to paint Alessandro," he said.

The pen stopped. Lorenzo did not move for a moment, and then he set the pen down carefully, as if it might spill, and folded his hands on the ledger.

"Now."

"Now. You told me his face in the hayloft. I've been carrying it—" Michele turned. "I promised you. In the chapel. It was a promise I made to a dying man, and you didn't die, so now it's a promise to a living one. I want to paint him while I still remember your voice saying it."

Lorenzo looked at the window, at the wall it faced, at the grey light coming in sideways. "It isn't a portrait," he said finally. "It's a confession."

"Then it's one I'll keep in this room. No name on the back. No one will know whose face it is but us." Michele spread his hands. "But I'll know. And you'll know. And this wall — " he gestured at the whitewashed plaster, " — this is a wall in Venice, and they can't come through it. Not for a panel. They'd have to come for the whole workshop."

Lorenzo was quiet a long moment. Then he picked the pen back up and squared the ledger.

"Ground it tomorrow," he said. "We'll need the good gesso, not the cheap. If you're going to paint a dead man, he at least deserves plaster that won't crack." He made a note in the margin, small and deliberate. "Put it in the column with the rest of what we owe."

Michele laughed, once, surprised. "You're keeping accounts on a memorial."

"I'm keeping accounts on everything," Lorenzo said. "It's what I have instead of a sword."

Below, the cat yowled. In the lane, someone was arguing about a barrel, and a boat knocked against the moorings on the canal beyond, and the bell in the Frari sounded the hour. And then, from the street, came a knock — not on their door but on the rope-maker's below it, three brisk raps and a voice calling up through the stairwell in careful Italian, wanting to know whether the painter had arrived, and whether he was taking commissions.

Lorenzo's pen stopped again. He looked at Michele.

"Say the word," he said, "and I'll find out who in this city already knows where we live."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 60: The New Beginning · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads