The Painted Lie

Chapter 62: The Portrait

The final sitting was the ninth, and Bianca di Neri arrived at the workshop with the patience of a woman who had already decided she liked the man painting her.

"You've changed something," she said, settling onto the stool by the window. She did not look at the easel; she had learned not to, at Michele's request. "The light. You moved the screen."

"Half an hour earlier than yesterday," Michele said, mixing a pale ochre on his palette. "The sun comes through the upper panes clean until the ninth bell. Then it yellows, and I lose the color in your throat."

"My throat is important?"

"Everything is important," he said, and she laughed, and he caught it — the small crease at the left side of her mouth, the way her chin lifted. He had it already, but he kept the brush moving anyway, because the sitting was nearly over and there was a stubborn softness in her cheek he had chased for a week and still did not wholly own.

Behind them, Lorenzo worked at the table with the ledgers, though there was little enough to enter. His pen scratched. Through the open shutters came the canal, a barge hauling stone, the cry of a man selling roasted chestnuts at the corner of the bridge. Venice made its noise regardless of who was painting in it.

"You'll want the pearls again," Bianca said, reaching up.

"No. Leave them off." Michele stepped closer. "Your father paid for a portrait of his daughter, not his daughter's jewelry. The pearls fight your skin."

Bianca's hands dropped. She looked at him squarely then, and he saw that she understood something he had not said aloud — that he was painting her, not a merchant's display. A flush moved up from her collar and he could not paint it fast enough; he mixed and laid a thin glazing stroke across the ridge of her cheekbone and knew, in the small pocket of silence after, that he had caught her at last.

"Almost," he murmured.

"Almost what?"

"Almost done."

The sitting ended at the eleventh bell. Bianca rose, drew her shawl, and stood a moment at the door looking back at the covered easel.

"My father will inspect it Thursday morning," she said. "He dines at the Spanish embassy that evening and wishes to show it to someone there. A secretary, he said. Or an attaché."

Lorenzo's pen stopped. One beat, two. Then it resumed, steady, and Michele — who had learned the shape of Lorenzo's silences well enough to hear the second one — said, "Then Thursday morning it will be ready."

When the door closed, Lorenzo did not put down the pen. "A secretary at the Spanish embassy."

"He may mean anyone."

"He means Ulivieri." Lorenzo set the pen in the groove of the inkstand, slow, deliberate. "Bartolomeo's wife is Spanish. He has dealings with the embassy over the Levant trade. He's mentioned it three times this month and every time it's the same man who advises him on silk duties." He looked up. "I've been listening for the name and never heard it said plainly. Now I hear it said plainly."

Michele wiped his brush. "Then we finish the painting tomorrow and he carries it to the embassy with our bird-and-circle on the back of the panel."

"We varnish it and sign the panel with a mark he can cover."

"He'll want a name to speak."

"Let him speak the name we gave him," Lorenzo said. "It's an honest name. Let the forger look at it and see only a painter from Cremona."

The last day was a day of varnish and nerves.

Michele worked alone in the morning, in silence, which was how the ending of a painting wanted to be done. The face was finished; what remained was the neck, the near shoulder, the fall of the dark green gown, and the small dark plane of the window behind her head where the light balanced. He worked without thought, in that deep water that opens past the second hour, where the hand is wiser than the man.

At noon Lorenzo came back with bread, olives, and a flask that turned out to hold orvieto rather than water.

"Expensive," Michele said.

"From the commission money. Which is nearly ours." Lorenzo set the flask down. "Four hundred and ten soldi left after rent and pigments. Enough to eat through winter if we're careful. Enough to leave if we have to."

Michele did not answer that. He dipped the tip of his brush and touched the very edge of the shadow where Bianca's jaw met the collar of her gown, and the whole head settled as though a weight had shifted inside it.

"Done," he said.

Lorenzo came around the easel and stood beside him, close, and they looked at her.

It was better than anything Michele had painted in Florence. He knew that immediately and without vanity, the way one knows the taste of wine. The girl looked out of the panel with a mild and living steadiness, her lips just parted, her eyes not quite meeting the viewer but turned a fraction toward the light. It was not pretty. It was true.

"She looks like she's about to speak," Lorenzo said.

"She's about to be let go," Michele said. "That's what a long sitting looks like." He was aware of Lorenzo's arm near his own, not touching. He leaned away first, because if he did not, he would not.

They carried the panel to the courtyard to dry. The varnish had a faint smell of juniper.

The Neapolitan collector who shared the floor below them came up the stairs that evening to complain about the smell, and stayed forty minutes instead, standing in front of the portrait with his hat in his hands. In the morning, two more came — a broker from Rialto, and the wife of a glassmaker, who stood in the doorway with her servant and asked, twice, whether the painter was free after Easter. By noon Michele had taken three names, a deposit of six florins, and Lorenzo had begun, quietly, to keep a list.

The merchant came Thursday at the third bell, and stood in front of the panel for a long time without speaking, which is the only reaction that matters.

"It has her," he said at last.

"It has what she is," Michele said.

Bartolomeo di Neri paid the forty florins in full, in gold, and added ten over — "for the speed, and because I am not a fool" — and had the panel carried to a boat himself, walking behind it along the fondamenta with the bearing of a man escorting a relic.

That evening they shut the workshop early and lit the small lamp and set out the orvieto and a fish bought hot from the stall under the arch.

"Drink," Lorenzo said, and filled both cups to the brim, and they drank together like men who had survived a sickness.

They talked about practical things first, because Lorenzo could not resist: rent, the lease on the studio, whether to buy another easel, the price of lapis now that the Genoese had raised the duty. Then, when the flask was half empty, they talked about nothing, and the nothing was good.

"I want the small room at the back whitewashed," Michele said. "I'll work there in the summer. There's a north window."

"Whitewash is nine soldi. I'll do it myself." Lorenzo turned his cup slowly on the table. "There's more money than whitewash, though. Do you know what we could do with two hundred florins?"

"Run farther."

"Or not run at all." He looked up. "There are boys in this city who have no one. The foundling wheels are full. The guilds apprentice them out for the labor and half of them die of it. I saw one at the Rialto last week, eight years old, hauling rope for a bargeman who beat him across the back for watching the pigeons."

Michele was silent.

"I know what you're going to say."

"I wasn't going to say anything."

"All right." Lorenzo picked a fish bone out of his plate and set it carefully aside. "Say it now."

Michele set down the cup. "I was going to say — the last person you took into your life on purpose, you gave him a name and a pen and he was hanged in Rome." He said it gently, but he said it. "And I don't say it to hurt you. I say it because you will look at the boy and see Alessandro, and the boy will not be Alessandro, and you will have to love whoever he actually is, and that is a different thing to promise."

Lorenzo looked at the lamp for a long moment.

"That is exactly what I was afraid you'd say," he said. "And it's true, and I don't know how to promise otherwise. But I'll say this. If I ever again love someone for what I need them to be, I'd rather they leave me." He picked up his cup. "You didn't."

"No. I didn't."

They were quiet, and then Lorenzo said, in a different voice, "There's a chest under my bed."

"I know. You sleep on the left side of it."

"It's locked." He turned the cup again. "It's been locked since Florence. There are things in it I haven't looked at since before we left, and now that the forty florins are ours and the portrait is out of the house and walking around this city on somebody else's wall, I think it's time to look." He lifted his eyes. "Tomorrow. I want you there. I'll open it in front of you."

Michele nodded slowly. Then, because the orvieto had loosened something in him, he said, "Not tonight?"

"Not tonight," Lorenzo said. "Tonight I'd only be drunk enough to be brave and sober enough to regret it."

He reached across the table and laid two fingers on the back of Michele's hand — not holding it, just resting there, one breath long — and took them back, and picked up the flask to pour.

The lamp guttered. Somewhere below on the canal, late rowers called to one another over the water, going home.

In the morning, while Michele ground pigment at the window, a boy in livery knocked at the workshop door and asked the painter's name. Lorenzo gave it: *Michele of Cremona, the mark of the bird in the circle.*

The boy said the secretary of the Spanish embassy wished to commission a small devotional panel, privately, and would come himself within the week to discuss it — and that he had taken the liberty, since the merchant di Neri had spoken so warmly, of inquiring after the painter's history in Cremona and found the parish register to match.

Lorenzo thanked him and closed the door and stood with his hand flat against it.

"Cremona matches," he said. "Someone made Cremona match. Not me."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 62: The Portrait · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads