The messenger had barely cleared the canal bridge before Michele shut the workshop door and bolted it.
Lorenzo was already in the back room, on his knees at the foot of the bed.
“Now,” he said. “Before I lose my nerve.”
The chest was chestnut wood, iron-bound, no bigger than a case for ledger books. Michele had walked past it a hundred times without seeing it; it had sat so long under the bed frame it read as part of the furniture. Lorenzo drew out a key on a cord from around his neck, where it had been the whole time, under his shirt against his skin.
“You wear the key,” Michele said.
“I wear the key.” Lorenzo fitted it to the lock. His hands were steady. His voice was not. “I told myself I would open this the day I had somewhere to put what is inside. Or someone. I did not believe I would ever have either.”
The lock turned. The lid came up.
Michele expected papers to smell of mildew. These smelled of cedar and old ink, the same as any scribe’s desk. On top lay a folded letter with a broken wax seal, a bird with its wings out. Under it, more letters, tied in a ribbon gone the color of weak tea. And beneath the letters, small, in a twist of linen, a locket.
Lorenzo lifted out the letters first and set them on the floor between them, careful, like a man laying down a child.
“Alessandro wrote to me the whole time,” he said. “Seven months. These are not all of them; the Signoria kept the rest. These are the ones he smuggled out through a boy who carried fruit to the prison kitchen. Seven.” He touched the ribbon. “I have read them so many times I can say them with my eyes closed. That is a thing I am not proud of.”
“Read one to me.”
Lorenzo shook his head, then stopped, then unfolded the topmost letter. His eyes moved down it the way a man walks a road he has walked until it is inside him.
“He asks whether the olives came in that year.” Lorenzo’s mouth twisted. “That is the whole letter. The olives, and a line about a girl in his quarter he thought was pretty, and did I remember the winter we ate chestnuts off the brazier in Santa Croce, and would I send him a drawing, anything, a cat, a shoe. He was in a cell in Rome under sentence of death.” He laid the page down. “Alessandro. My brother.”
Michele said nothing. There was nothing to say that would not have been an interruption.
“He was not clever about people,” Lorenzo went on. “I was. That is why the Signoria used me and hanged him and not the other way.” He looked up at last, and his eyes were dry, which was worse than if they had not been. “The letter I was forging when they took him. I was finishing the last of the Renzi correspondence — the proofs that would have cleared his name and condemned Ulivieri with the same stroke. I had it in my hand. I could have run it to the gate that night, and I did not, because I was afraid, and I told myself there would be tomorrow.” He pressed his palms flat on the floorboards. “There was no tomorrow. There was Ulivieri at my door instead.”
“You have told me this,” Michele said quietly.
“I have not told you the rest.”
Lorenzo took the locket from the linen and opened it. Inside: a painted likeness no larger than a thumbnail, a young man with soft eyes and a jaw that had not finished becoming a man’s — Alessandro, surely, though the painter had flattered him. And on the other side, the miniature turned face to face with it, the two halves of a hinged clasp, a second portrait.
Michele leaned in. His breath caught.
It was himself. Not painted long ago. Painted from life, and recently — the same dark hair he wore now, the same stubborn line between his brows that Bianca had teased him about while she sat. He did not own such a portrait. He had never sat for it.
“You painted it,” Michele said. “From the work. You copied yourself out of my paintings.”
“I painted it the second month in Vicenza,” Lorenzo said. “From memory, and from watching you sleep. I hate it, but it is the truest thing I have ever done.” He closed the locket on the two faces, buttoned in the dark together. “When they hang me, that is what they will find on the cord, and it will be proof of nothing except what it is.”
The word hung between them.
“Say it,” Michele said.
Lorenzo’s jaw worked. “I am afraid you will go.”
“I have not gone.”
“Everyone I have loved, the world takes,” Lorenzo said. “I put good coin in a man’s hand and he was hanged. I kept my brother in a chest under a bed so that no one could ever take him from me again, and I thought if I never said the words, then nothing could be aimed at you through me. That is the whole of it.” He raised the locket so the candle caught the tiny hinge. “The chest was not grief, Michele. Grief is what I told myself it was. It was grief, and it was this, and I could not carry one without the other, so I buried both under the floor and wore the key against my skin and told nobody.”
Michele reached across and closed his hand over Lorenzo’s on the locket, the two of them holding it between their palms like something warm that might still live.
“Then we dig it up,” Michele said. “All of it. Tonight.”
“There is no time. Ulivieri’s secretary will—”
“Tonight,” Michele said again, and drew him forward until their foreheads touched, and the words came small and steady into the space between them. “You have had my work hanging round your neck for three months. Do you think I did not know? I painted you the same way. I just did not know the name of it until now.”
Lorenzo made a sound, half a laugh, half something breaking. “Michele of Cremona, cousin,” he whispered. “You are the worst liar I have ever loved.”
And there in the lamplight, kneeling among his brother’s letters with the key still round his neck, he kissed him.