The Painted Lie

Chapter 8: The Kiss

Michele worked by the light of a single oil lamp, the wick turned low to save oil. Giovanni da Ravenna's false portrait sat on the easel before him — a merchant of no particular family, a man who had never existed, whose papers would carry him through the southern gate and onto a ship and into a life. Michele had painted the eyes three times. Each time they came out wrong. Too direct. Too much of the real Giovanni, who had sat in this chair two days ago and confessed, in a voice worn thin by weeks of hiding, that he wanted his real face remembered.

"Still awake."

Michele did not turn. He knew the footsteps by now — the particular weight of them on the studio floorboard that creaked, the way Lorenzo always paused in the doorway before entering, as though asking permission he never quite voiced.

"I'm redoing the eyes," Michele said. "They're wrong."

Lorenzo came to stand behind him, close enough that Michele felt the warmth of him through his shirt. "They look like eyes to me."

"They look like a man who's afraid. He can't look afraid at the gate."

"He is afraid."

"Then I have to paint him unafraid." Michele dipped his brush and tried again, and again the result was a stranger. He set the brush down with more force than he intended. "I'm no good tonight."

Lorenzo was quiet a moment. Then he pulled the second stool close and sat, elbows on his knees, and looked at the portrait with the same grave attention he gave everything. Up close, in the low light, the lines around his eyes showed more clearly. He had been sleeping badly — Michele had heard him pacing the corridor past midnight, twice, three times.

"When I was a boy," Lorenzo said, "my father made me learn to draw. Not to be an artist. To be a gentleman. So I would know what I was looking at — a wall, a fortification, a face across a table. He said a man who cannot draw cannot lie properly, because he cannot see what the other man believes."

"And can you?"

"Barely. A horse that looks like a dog." Lorenzo's mouth moved in something that was almost a smile. "I could never do what you do. I look at a face and see a face. You look at a face and see what it is hiding."

Michele turned on his stool to face him. They were very close now, knees nearly touching. "What am I hiding?"

The question hung there. Lorenzo did not answer it. His gaze dropped, took in the brush in Michele's hand, the paint beneath his fingernails, the smear of umber on his cuff.

"You should let me send you away," Lorenzo said. "After Friday. I can arrange passage — north, to Bologna, a letter to a workshop there. You'd work. You'd be safe."

"No."

"Don't be a fool — "

"I've heard this." Michele's voice came out steadier than he felt. "You refused my money because it would put my name in Cosimo's ledgers. Fine. But you don't get to save me and then send me off like a finished commission. If I'm in this, I'm in it."

"You're not in it. You're a painter who was hired to paint a wedding portrait."

"I'm a painter who forges identity papers for men who would be killed without them. Say it plainly, at least."

Lorenzo's jaw tightened. For a moment Michele thought he would rise and leave, as he always did when the talk came too near the bone. Instead he stayed, and something in his posture gave way — the careful diplomat's carriage loosening at last, shoulders dropping, hands going still on his knees.

"I have not slept in nine days," Lorenzo said. Very quietly. "Not since Giovanni came. Every time I close my eyes I see the gate, and a man walking through it, and a hand on his shoulder. And it is always the wrong man. Always someone I sent."

"You're not sending them to die. You're getting them out."

"One of them does not come back, and it will have been me. That is arithmetic, Michele. Not sentiment."

Michele reached out — he did not decide to, his hand simply moved — and closed it over Lorenzo's wrist. Lorenzo flinched as though burned, but he did not pull away; he looked down at Michele's paint-stained fingers on his sleeve and let out a breath that seemed to come from somewhere very deep.

"You're shaking," Michele said.

"I know."

"Then stop carrying it alone for one hour. It's not a strategy. It's just — " He searched for the word. "An hour."

Lorenzo laughed — a short, cracked sound, nothing like his usual composure. "You sound like him, you know. My brother-in-law. When we were young, before — " He stopped.

"The man in the miniature."

"Yes." Lorenzo's eyes were on Michele's hand now, still resting on his wrist. "Matteo. He married my sister. He was the cleverest man I knew, and the kindest, and now he rides for Cosimo and reports what he sees in this house. He sat in that chair. That one. He drank my wine and asked after my mother's health, and he counted the letters on my desk."

"And you still love him."

"I still remember him." Lorenzo's voice was barely audible. "That is not the same thing. But it is not nothing, either."

The lamp guttered. Michele did not move to trim it. In the darkening room, the false face on the easel receded into shadow, and there was only the two of them and the small circle of light and the sound of Lorenzo's breathing, unsteady now, close.

"He knows what the wedding is for," Michele said. "You told me that. If he knows — "

"He suspects. There is a difference. If he knew, the scholars would already be dead and I would already be in Cosimo's cellar. He is waiting. Watching. Deciding whether to sell me." Lorenzo finally looked up. His eyes were very dark in the lamplight, and fixed on Michele's face with an intensity that made the room feel smaller. "That is what I have been doing these nine nights. Deciding what I will do when he decides."

Michele should have asked another question. There were a hundred of them. He would remember that later — that he let the moment go by, that he chose instead to lift his hand from Lorenzo's wrist and let it rest, lightly, against the side of his face, where the jaw was tense and the skin was warm and the evening's stubble had begun to show.

Lorenzo went very still.

"You don't have to decide tonight," Michele said.

"I know."

"Then — "

He never finished the sentence. Lorenzo leaned in and kissed him.

It was not a gentle kiss. It was the kiss of a man who had been holding something back for a long time and had lost the argument with himself; hard, and brief, and with Lorenzo's hand suddenly gripping the back of Michele's neck as though he might otherwise be swept away. Michele's brush clattered off the stool and neither of them noticed. For a moment there was only warmth and salt and the taste of the cheap wine they had drunk at supper, and Michele's heart going like a drum in his chest, and the astonishing fact of it — that it was really happening, that Lorenzo's mouth was on his, that the careful distance of weeks had collapsed into an inch of space.

Then Lorenzo pulled back.

He stood so fast the stool toppled. He was breathing hard, one hand pressed over his mouth as though to hold the kiss in or shut it out, and his face in the lamplight was not the face of a man who had given in to something he wanted. It was afraid.

"That was a mistake," he said.

Michele sat frozen on his stool, lips still warm. "Lorenzo — "

"No." The word came out sharp. Lorenzo stepped back toward the door, and his composure was reassembling itself visibly, piece by piece, like a wall being rebuilt after a breach. "You work for me. I have hired you to do a job, and if you are caught with me — do you understand what that means? You are already useful to them. A painter with access to this house. If they can say you are my — " He stopped. He would not say the word. "It is not only me at risk. It is the gate. It is Giovanni. It is every man who goes through on Friday."

"You're the one who kissed me."

"I know." Lorenzo's hand was on the door. "And I am telling you it will not happen again. Finish the eyes. Friday is four days away."

He left. Michele heard his footsteps down the corridor and up the stairs, and then the creak of a floorboard overhead, and then nothing.

He sat alone for a long while in the failing light, one hand still raised where it had touched Lorenzo's face. Then he looked at the portrait on the easel, at the three pairs of painted eyes he had discarded, and understood suddenly what had been wrong with all of them. He had been trying to paint a man unafraid. That was impossible. Every man walking through that gate would be afraid. What he needed to paint was a man with something to lose — a man grateful enough to risk any fear.

He picked up the brush. His hand was still trembling, and he did not care.

The letter arrived before dawn, slid under the studio door with the soft scrape of paper on stone. There was no seal. There was no name. Four words in a hand Michele did not recognize, small and even and unhurried:

They know. Move him now.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 8: The Kiss · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads