The next morning, Michele set his palette down and did not pick it up again.
He had tried. He had ground the lapis, mixed the ochre, laid out the brushes in their row like soldiers awaiting orders. But his hand would not move to the panel. All morning he had stared at Giovanni's unfinished face—half a stranger, half a man—and thought of the checkpoint officer Lorenzo had named, and the boy who had whispered at the door, and the courier whose small painted features he now could not unsee.
He needed to know who was watching this house.
So he stopped painting and began watching back.
The studio opened onto the inner courtyard through a tall window he could leave ajar, and from the deep shadow beside the easel he could see most of the passage that ran between the kitchens and the garden steps. He set a spare canvas at an angle to block the light from his corner, pulled a stool into the dark, and waited.
He did not have to wait long.
Pietro came through twice before noon. The first time he carried a basket of lemons toward the kitchen, head down, quick as any servant with work to do. The second time he had no basket at all. He walked the passage slowly, paused at the garden door, looked out at the cypresses for the length of a full breath, then looked—briefly, but not by accident—toward the studio window.
Michele kept still. He had learned, in the long hours of painting, how to go unnoticed; the model forgets the painter, and the watcher forgets the watched. Pietro's gaze slid over the darkened glass and found nothing.
But it had come looking.
The third time was in the afternoon, and the third time was the worst, because Michele was no longer alone.
Lorenzo had come to sit with him while he worked—or failed to work. He had brought a letter he did not read, holding it folded between two fingers while he watched Michele sharpen a stick of charcoal he had no intention of using. They had not spoken of the kiss. They had spoken of everything else, in the careful way of two men walking around a hole in the floor.
"You haven't touched the panel," Lorenzo said.
"I'm thinking."
"You're brooding. There's a difference, and it shows on your face."
Before Michele could answer, a shadow crossed the passage outside. Pietro, passing the window. He slowed. He did not stop, but he slowed, and his head turned just enough that the light caught the flat of his cheek.
Michele watched it happen and felt cold all over.
When the footsteps faded, he set down the charcoal. "How long has Pietro served in this house?"
Lorenzo looked up from the letter. "Since spring. My steward hired him. Why?"
"He passes this window four times a day. He carries nothing three of those times."
"He's a servant. Servants walk."
"He slows when he passes. He looks in."
Lorenzo's face did not change, but something behind it closed like a door. "Michele."
"Don't." Michele stood, brushing charcoal dust from his hands. "Don't do that. Don't put on the face you wear for ambassadors and tell me I've imagined it."
Lorenzo set the letter down. For a moment the mask held—and then, to Michele's surprise, it slipped. Not into anger. Into something wearier.
"Pietro is a servant," he said quietly. "That is all he is. If he looks in the window, he looks the way any man looks at a room with a light in it. And if I begin suspecting my own household on the strength of a turned head, I will have no household left, and no one to serve the wedding supper but my cousin and the cat."
"You know he could be bought."
"Anyone can be bought. I can be bought. I am being bought, at present, by a banker who thinks I don't notice the price rising." Lorenzo's mouth curved without warmth. "That doesn't mean I turn on a boy who mops my floors."
"And if he's the one who tells Cosimo the scholars move on Friday?"
"Then it won't matter whether I was rude to him on Tuesday."
Michele turned away. Arguing with Lorenzo was like pushing on a wall with a cushion; nothing broke and nothing gave. He picked up a rag and wiped his fingers, slowly, because his hands wanted something to do.
"You think I'm frightened of shadows," he said.
"I think you're frightened," Lorenzo said. "That's different. I'd prefer you frightened to careless."
Michele turned back, and found Lorenzo watching him with an expression he could not name—the same one from the night he had pulled away, half hunger, half grief. It lasted a heartbeat, and then Lorenzo stood and gathered the letter.
"I have a caller at four," he said. "Cosimo's factor. He wants to discuss the terms of my debt, which means he wants to remind me what terms are." He paused at the door. "If Pietro looks in the window while I'm gone, don't paint him. It would only encourage him."
"Lorenzo."
"Yes?"
"If I'm right about him—if I find proof—will you send him out?"
Lorenzo was silent for a moment. Then: "If you find proof, I'll do a great deal more than send him out." And he left.
Michele did not paint that afternoon either. Instead he assembled a small, sad arsenal: a stub of charcoal, a sheet of paper, and a position at the far end of the passage where a linen chest gave him cover and the light from the garden door fell full on any man crossing.
He watched the courtyard for two hours.
Pietro crossed five times. Twice with linens. Once with a tray, though the kitchen had served nothing. Once empty-handed, walking the long way around the fountain for no reason that a servant with duties would choose. And once—this was the one Michele wrote down—he stopped at the garden door, stood in the doorway for a long count of twenty, and looked toward the south.
South. Toward the river. Toward the Arno gate.
Michele wrote it all on his sheet in a small neat hand, the way he sketched: line by line, only what he saw, nothing he guessed. But as the light failed and he folded the paper into his sleeve, he found he did not need to guess. A servant who carries nothing, walks the long way, and stares south when he thinks no one is watching is not a servant looking at a light in a window.
He was a man keeping watch on a road.
And there was a road south, and the scholars were going to walk it on Friday.
Michele found Lorenzo in the study after the factor had gone. Lorenzo looked wrung out, gray about the mouth, one hand flat on a ledger as if holding the columns still.
"I have something," Michele said.
He laid the sheet on the desk and stepped back while Lorenzo read it. He watched the gray mouth tighten, line by line, until Lorenzo set the paper down and closed his eyes.
"You followed him."
"I watched him. There's a difference, and it shows on his face."
Lorenzo almost smiled. Almost. "Twenty paces, at the garden door, facing south."
"He wasn't praying."
"No." Lorenzo opened his eyes and looked at the paper as if it were a wound he could not stop touching. "He's been in my house since spring. He's served wine to the man who's ruining me and he's never once been in the room when I said a word that mattered—or so I believed."
"You believe it still, or you'd have called for him."
"I believe it enough to be careful." Lorenzo folded the paper, precisely, and tucked it inside his doublet. "I'll watch him. But if you're right—and I think you may be—then whoever buys him knows we're moving. Which means he knows when."
"And where."
"Yes." Lorenzo looked at him a long moment. "Go and finish Giovanni's portrait, Michele. Don't watch the passage tonight; let him think he's safe."
"And if he leaves the house?"
"Then I'll follow him myself."
Michele nodded and turned to go—and stopped at the threshold, because the courtyard door opened below, and through the window he caught a glimpse of a figure crossing toward the gate: Pietro, cloak over his arm, walking quickly, alone.
It was barely dusk. The scholars did not move until Friday. But Pietro was going out into the evening with his cloak over his arm and nothing in his hands, and he was heading south.
Michele looked back at Lorenzo. Lorenzo had seen it too. He was already reaching for his own cloak, and his face had gone the color of the paper in his hand.