The Perfect Ending

Chapter 50: The Courtroom

The courtroom in Lisbon's Tribunal da Comarca was smaller than Ellie had pictured, more like a lecture hall with better lighting. She sat between Marta and Duarte on a hard wooden bench, her hands folded in her lap, the translated statement in front of her that she'd spent three weeks rehearsing and two hours this morning deciding to throw away.

Bastos sat forty feet away, wearing a gray suit that fit him well. He did not look at her. He looked at the judge, at his lawyer, at the ceiling fan turning slowly overhead. As if she were furniture.

The prosecutor called her name. Ellie stood, walked to the witness box, and placed her hand on the book she'd been told to place it on. The translation of the oath came out flat, bureaucratic. She understood it anyway.

"Ms. Chen," the prosecutor said, a woman in her forties named Ferreira with gray-streaked hair and a voice like gravel. "You found a receipt among your belongings that had been planted there?"

"Sim. Yes."

"And it was forged."

"Yes. It was a fake receipt for repairs to the apartment, for two thousand three hundred euros. I never paid that. I never received a bill for it."

Ferreira held up the evidence bag. The receipt inside was small against the plastic. "This document, which was found in the pocket of a jacket you had not worn since you arrived in Lisbon, was planted by the defendant's agent? Or by the defendant himself?"

"Objection," Bastos's lawyer said, standing. "Speculation."

The judge, a woman in her sixties with reading glasses perched on her nose, waved her hand. "Let her answer about what she knows, not what she concludes."

Ellie took a breath. "What I know is this. I had not opened that pocket since March. I opened it in September, and the receipt was there. The day before, the defendant had been in my apartment. He had a key. He always had a key."

"Did you consent to him entering?"

"Objection—"

"Overruled. Answer."

"No." The word came out louder than she meant it. "I never gave him permission to enter my home. He let himself in because he thought I was gone, or because he thought I wouldn't notice. He was wrong on both counts."

A ripple of movement in the gallery. Somewhere behind her, Duarte exhaled.

Ferreira shuffled her papers. "Ms. Chen, the defense has indicated it intends to challenge your credibility. You posted a video online that misrepresented your living situation in Lisbon. You sublet an apartment without the landlord's permission. You sent money to an account controlled by the defendant. These are facts, are they not?"

Marta had warned her about this. All of it was coming, and the only way through was through.

"They are facts," Ellie said.

"So why should the court believe your account of the receipt?"

Ellie looked at the judge. The judge looked back, expressionless. In the gallery, she could feel Duarte willing her toward something, though she couldn't say what.

"Because I'm not going to lie to you about the rest," Ellie said. "I made a video that wasn't true. I told people I was living in Lisbon as a digital nomad, and I made it look like I had a plan, and I didn't. I sublet an apartment I wasn't supposed to sublet because I was broke and embarrassed and I didn't want anyone to know. I sent the defendant money because he threatened me, and I was scared, and I paid him even though I knew it might be wrong. None of that is true anymore, or it's true and I'm not hiding it. So when I tell you the receipt is forged, I'm not asking you to trust a stranger. I'm asking you to trust someone who just told you everything she did wrong."

The prosecutor said nothing for a moment. The judge's pen stopped moving.

"Thank you, Ms. Chen," Ferreira said quietly. "Nothing further."

Bastos's lawyer stood. He was younger than Bastos, sharp-featured, and he smiled at Ellie the way people smile when they think they've found a crack.

"Ms. Chen. You said you were broke and embarrassed. But you also had enough money to rent an apartment in a sea-view building. That doesn't sound broke to me."

"I had savings. I spent them. There's a difference between having money and being broke, and I was the second thing by the time he was done with me."

"Or the first thing, and you're exaggerating for sympathy."

"I'm not asking for sympathy."

"You're asking the court to believe a woman who admits to lying on the internet, to an illegal sublet, and to paying a man she now claims extorted her."

"I'm asking the court to believe a woman who stopped lying. Those are different."

The lawyer's smile thinned. He asked a few more questions—about dates, about the video's view count, about whether she'd ever met Bastos's associates—and Ellie answered them all without looking away. When he sat down, the judge made a small note.

Duarte's turn came next.

He stood in the witness box with the same stillness Ellie had seen in him the first night they met, when he'd been holding a camera and pretending not to be surprised by her. He wore his good jacket. He answered Ferreira's questions in Portuguese, and the interpreter relayed them to Ellie in a steady murmur.

Yes, he had seen Tiago, the courier, enter the building on the day he disappeared. Yes, he had spoken to Tiago twice that week, about the notebook. Yes, he had been the one to find the tile—the forged tile—in Ellie's apartment, and it matched the tile from the building the courier had been carrying packages to, the same building where the defendant kept an office under a different name.

"Mr. Almeida," Ferreira said. "Do you have any knowledge of what happened to Tiago Oliveira after that day?"

Duarte's jaw worked. "No. I don't know if he's alive. I don't know if he left the country. I don't know if someone hurt him. I know I didn't see him again, and I know he was afraid of the man sitting over there." He nodded toward Bastos without looking at him. "That's all I know. I wish it were more."

The prosecutor asked one more question, about the notebook. Duarte said the notebook was with the police, in evidence, and he had never read what was inside it. The judge's pen moved again, slower this time.

Bastos's lawyer did not cross-examine Duarte for long. There was nothing in his testimony to attack; he'd said only what he'd seen and admitted the rest.

The judge called a recess at noon. When they resumed, the prosecutor gave her closing argument, the defense gave theirs, and then they waited.

Ellie sat in the bench with her hands around Duarte's, both of them sweating in the September heat. Marta had gone out to make a call. The gallery had thinned to a few reporters and one elderly woman Ellie didn't recognize, who had been watching Bastos the whole time with a stillness that felt familiar.

The judge returned at four-fifteen.

She read her findings in a voice without ornament. The forgeries, the keys, the pattern of foreign tenants, the wallet, the drop address, the stolen deposits found in the defendant's possession at the airport. She found the defendant guilty on all counts: fraud, extortion, illegal entry, and—Ellie's breath caught—the attempted intimidation of a witness, which the prosecution had added at the last minute after Marta's firm submitted Soraia's forwarded messages.

The sentence came down: seven years. The judge added restitution to the victims, to be determined at a separate hearing, and a restraining order. Bastos's lawyer asked for bail pending appeal and was refused.

Ellie didn't hear any of it after the word "guilty." She heard Duarte's breath go out beside her, felt his hand tighten on hers. She heard someone in the gallery—the elderly woman—start to cry quietly, and she understood, without being told, that the woman was someone's mother, someone who had also lost money, or a child, or both.

When it was over, they stood in the corridor outside the courtroom, the three of them, not speaking. Marta came back from her phone call with a folder under her arm.

"Restitution hearing in six weeks," she said. "He'll appeal, probably, but the conviction stands while he appeals. He's not going anywhere."

Ellie nodded. She felt oddly hollow, the way she had after finishing a game she'd spent years writing—the satisfaction dulled by the sudden absence of the thing that had been driving her. Tiago was still missing. The notebook was still in evidence. Bastos was going to prison, and none of that was fixed.

Marta cleared her throat. "There's something else. Soraia called the office while we were in the courtroom. She wants to meet. Tomorrow."

Duarte looked at Ellie. "She's been ignoring you for three weeks."

"She's not ignoring me anymore," Marta said. "She says she has something she needs to say in person. Something about the platform's settlement offer." She paused. "And about who sent the money."

Ellie felt the floor tilt under her.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 50: The Courtroom · The Perfect Ending · Lumen Reads