The Proof of the Pudding

Chapter 56: The Seal Denied

The corridor outside the chambers smelled of floor wax and old paper, the particular scent of a French courthouse at nine in the morning, and Mathilde had been standing in it for forty minutes with her back against the wall and her hands folded so tightly that her knuckles had gone pale.

Blanchard came through the double doors at the far end without hurrying. That was the thing about him — Mathilde had known him eleven years, since the lease on her first kitchen, and she had never once seen him hurry. He carried a single sheet of paper in his left hand, and she watched his face the whole length of the corridor and could read nothing in it, which she decided meant nothing at all.

Gabriel had stopped pacing. He stood three meters away with his arms crossed, and she felt rather than saw him go still.

"Well?" Mathilde said.

Blanchard stopped in front of them and looked at the paper as if he had not already read it. "Denied."

Gabriel exhaled, a short, hard sound. "Denied."

"The sealing motion, yes. Denied in its entirety." Blanchard turned the page toward them, though neither of them could have read it upside down at that distance. "The court found no basis for confidential commercial treatment of public procurement records. Fauré Holdings argued trade secret exposure. The court noted that a cold-chain logistics manifest for a publicly tendered contract is not a trade secret, and observed — this is the useful part — that the moving party had failed to identify any specific competitive harm, and that the timing of the motion, filed four days before a scheduled auction connected to the same corporate group, warranted scrutiny."

Mathilde read the last clause twice off the page when he finally handed it to her. *Warranted scrutiny.* Four words, and they were the first four words in six weeks that had gone their way.

"So they release it," she said.

"They release it. The manifest, both dates, the full stop log and the driver's hours, to the court and to any party who filed for access. That includes your demand under the cross-collateral file." Blanchard allowed himself the smallest adjustment of his glasses. "They have five business days to comply. Which means, given the auction is Monday, that they will either comply Thursday or they will file something else to stall. I would bet on the something else. But we have the order."

Gabriel took the paper from Mathilde's hand and read it himself, slowly, the way he read everything. She watched him read. There was a crease between his eyebrows that she had spent fifty days learning, and the crease was there now, but underneath it his mouth had gone slack with something that was not quite relief and not quite disbelief.

"I bought a building on a rumor and it took six weeks to prove I bought a building," he said quietly. "And this takes four days."

"That is what courts do when you catch the right clerk," Blanchard said. "I'll file the access request before noon. Maître Fauré will have it by one. Expect a call."

"She won't call me," Gabriel said. "She never calls me. She lets other people do it."

Blanchard inclined his head, collected his briefcase from where he had set it against the wall, and walked back the way he had come, and then it was just the two of them in the corridor with the wax smell and the low fluorescent hum and the paper still in Gabriel's hand.

Mathilde realized she had been holding her breath and let it go. Her ribs ached. She had slept four hours in two days and eaten standing up for a week and she was suddenly, absurdly, aware of how close she was standing to him — close enough that she could smell coffee and the ironed cotton of his shirt and something else underneath, the flour that got into the weave of the apron he never bothered to change out of before coming to court.

"I should call Manon," she said, and did not move.

"Blanchard will call her people."

"I should call her anyway."

"Mathilde."

She looked up. He was looking at her with an expression she could not name and did not want to name, and then he shifted the paper to his left hand and reached over and took hers.

That was all. He took her right hand off the fold of her coat and held it, palm to palm, his thumb flat against the back of her knuckles, and for about four seconds neither of them said anything or moved or looked at each other. His hand was warm and dry and larger than she remembered, which was a strange thing to remember at all, because she had never held it.

She did not pull away. That was the part she would think about later, in the dark, at three in the morning, with the shame of it and the wanting of it both.

Then the elevator at the end of the corridor chimed.

Bousquet came out of it already talking, phone to his ear, canvas bag sliding off his shoulder — "No, no, I'm here, I'm here, hold the page—" and he turned the corner and saw them, and Gabriel let go of her hand.

It was the smoothest thing she had ever seen anyone do. He let go, stepped half a pace back, transferred the court order into his right hand and held it out toward Bousquet, and by the time Bousquet's eyes came up from his phone there was nothing in the corridor but two business partners with a piece of paper.

The journalist took the order, read it, and made a low whistle through his teeth.

"Denied," he said. "They denied the seal."

"Denied," Mathilde said. Her voice came out entirely normal. She was pleased about that and appalled at herself for being pleased.

"Five business days," Bousquet said, already scrolling his notes. "That's Thursday for the documents, which is exactly when I said I'd hold the story, so now it's a question of whether they stiff my deadline with another filing or whether I get the manifest first. Either way I can write the sealing denial today. A court calling their timing suspicious on the record — that is a paragraph, that is a lead."

"Manon needs to be recorded before any of it runs," Gabriel said.

"Tomorrow at three, my paper's lawyer, my recorder." Bousquet tucked the order into his bag. "Don't be late and don't bring anyone else."

He was gone back into the elevator before either of them could answer.

The corridor was very quiet. Mathilde looked at the closed doors, at the waxed floor, at her own right hand, which was hanging at her side doing nothing at all.

"We should go," she said.

"Yes," Gabriel said. "We should go."

They walked to the stairs without touching, and neither of them said a word about it, and it sat between them the entire way down.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 56: The Seal Denied · The Proof of the Pudding · Lumen Reads