The Proof of the Pudding

Chapter 73: Manon's Testimony at Trial

The courthouse on the quai awaited them at nine, a limestone block that somehow managed to look both patient and indifferent. Mathilde had dressed as she did for a service: white shirt, dark jacket, nothing that invited a second look. Gabriel walked beside her through the security line without touching her, because they had decided, that morning, over coffee and the crust of a tart, not to.

"You don't have to be brave today," he had said at the pass, not looking at her.

"I know," she had said, and packed her bag.

The courtroom was small enough that she could smell the varnish on the benches. Bertrand Fauré sat in the box with his striped tie and his hands folded as if he were waiting for a table reservation. Aurélie sat three meters behind him, in a grey knit dress, alone; their lawyers were separate, and their jaws were set in the same direction, which was away from each other. That was the first thing Mathilde noticed, and it was the thing that told her the case was already over.

The prosecutor read the counts in a flat voice: use of forged records, falsification of commercial documents, procurement fraud on a scale of four million euros across eleven municipal contracts. The procurement records, the prosecutor said, had been obtained from the company's own archive, and they matched the escrow ledgers exactly. Mathilde's copies, the ones she had carried in a padded envelope to Sorel's office back in November, sat in a numbered exhibit on the bench between two bailiffs.

Then they called Manon Kessler.

She came in through the side door with her chin up. She had cut her hair since the last time Mathilde had seen her, and she wore no makeup, and she looked, from the witness stand, like someone who had spent the last year deciding what she was. The clerk swore her in. She said her name and her former title, logistics coordinator at Fauré Holdings, and her current title, which was "on leave."

The prosecutor asked who had instructed her to alter the temperature logs.

"Mr. Fauré," she said. "Directly. In his office. Two days before each site visit."

"How many times?"

"Eleven times, over three years. The falsified logs covered deliveries to the school canteens in the fifth and seventh arrondissements." She paused. "I kept a copy of every version. I gave the originals to the court."

"Where did you keep them?"

"In a locker at the pool on rue Viala. With my daughter's swim cap." She glanced at Mathilde for the first time, and then away. "I thought if they were in the locker, I could pretend they weren't real."

The defense lawyer for Bertrand began his cross-examination gently, then less so. Had she been dismissed from the company? Yes. Had she asked Mr. Fauré for money after her dismissal? Yes. Was that money a threat? No, it was severance she was owed, and she had documentation for every day of it. Had she discussed her testimony with the complainant, Mathilde Renaud? Yes. In what context? Ms. Renaud had sent her a pastry and asked her to eat properly. The courtroom laughed — a nervous, released laugh, the kind that comes out of a room that has been holding its breath.

The lawyer asked if she was trying to take revenge.

"No," Manon said. "I'm trying to be able to buy bread again."

There was a silence. The judge wrote something down. The lawyer sat.

Aurélie's lawyer tried the same door and found it locked. Manon's answers did not change. When it was over, she stepped down from the stand and walked past Mathilde's bench, and for one step she slowed, and Mathilde saw her hands were shaking, and then she was gone through the side door.

The court broke for lunch. Gabriel bought two ham sandwiches from a kiosk by the river and they ate them on a bench with the wind coming off the Saône, and neither of them said anything, because the day was not finished.

The verdict came at two. Guilty on all counts, both defendants. Bertrand Fauré, forty-one months, with a suspended sentence of five years on the commercial-ban charge. Aurélie Fauré, fourteen months, suspended, plus a fine of sixty thousand euros and a five-year ban from any corporate directorship in France. The judge's voice did not change for either of them. The courtroom was quiet, and then there was a rustle of the room's furniture, and then it was over.

Mathilde watched Bertrand as the sentence was read. She watched his hands, which stayed folded. She watched his jaw, which did not move. She watched him look, once, at Aurélie, and then look away, and she understood, with a certainty that surprised her, that he had never seen either of them. Not her, not his wife. He had seen only the building, the contracts, the margin. She had been an instrument for nine years and she had believed she was a daughter, and the mistake was entirely hers, and she paid for it. But the man in the box paid too, and she found she could not feel the triumph she had expected. She felt the floor. She felt the floor of the bakery under her feet, and she was standing on it, and that was the whole of her feeling.

They filed out through the corridor. Gabriel was a step behind her and she turned and looked at him, and he looked back, and then they walked together, and that was enough.

They stopped at the doors where the corridor opened into the grey afternoon light, and stood aside from the departing crowd.

"Manon," Mathilde said. "She came in from the side door."

"She did."

"I liked her. In the old job. She used to bring her daughter to the Fontaine bakery on Saturdays, and I would give her a brioche at the end of the day, and Manon would say no, no, and I would put it in the bag anyway." Mathilde looked at the doors. "I didn't know she was keeping a locker full of evidence."

"She was keeping a locker full of herself," Gabriel said. "The evidence was the part she had to keep."

Mathilde was quiet for a moment. Then she said, out loud, in the corridor, in the ordinary voice she used for inventories and orders:

"I trusted him like a father."

Gabriel did not say anything. He did not take her hand, because they had agreed, that morning, over coffee and the crust of a tart, not to. He just stood there, and let her have the sentence, until it had stopped being a sentence and was just a fact, like the temperature of the river.

"He gave me my first station," she said. "He showed me how he wanted the pâte levée rolled. He told me I was the best candidate he'd seen in ten years, and he said it in front of the whole brigade, and I went home and cried in my kitchen because I thought —" She stopped. "Because I thought I had a family in this trade. And I did, in a way, but it was a business. I was a business."

"You were a person inside a business," Gabriel said. "That's not the same as being a business. You can't run a business on pastry."

She looked at him, and something in her face gave, one small notch, the way a tart shell gives just before it's ready to come out of the oven.

"No," she said. "You can't."

The afternoon light was moving down the façade of the courthouse, and the taxis were starting up on the quai, and the crowd from the courtroom had scattered into groups of two and three along the pavement. Sorel came down the steps toward them, buttoning his coat.

"Good," he said. "It's good."

"The building," Mathilde said.

"The permit's been stayed, on the strength of today. It's not gone. We'll need to settle the debt, but the building is not gone." He looked at her. "It'll take a lease, and it'll take money, and the bank that holds it now is a local one, and they'll talk to you. That's a conversation for another week. Go home."

He shook both their hands and walked off toward the bridge, and Gabriel and Mathilde stood on the steps for a moment longer than they needed to.

"I want to make a brioche," she said.

"You made one yesterday."

"A different one. With the beurre de Charentes, but a long ferment. I want to be in the kitchen when it comes out."

"Okay," Gabriel said. "Let's go be in the kitchen."

They walked to the Métro, and the train was crowded and nobody knew who they were, and that was, Mathilde found, a considerable relief. At Bellecour an old woman with a shopping trolley recognized her from the bakery and asked if the shop was open again. Mathilde said yes, and that they were sold out of the signature plate, and the woman said she'd come Saturday.

"She'll come Saturday," Gabriel murmured.

"She'll come Saturday," Mathilde agreed.

At the Fournil Saint-Antoine they unlocked the side door and put the lights on and stood for a second in the corridor, listening to the building. It was empty, and it was theirs, at least for now, and the man in the striped tie was in a cell on the other side of the river for a while.

Mathilde filled the till drawer's key and opened it, and the first thing she saw was the auction notice folded under the butter dish, and she took it out and held it in the light, and then she put it back, because it belonged there. Then she washed her hands and put on her apron and started weighing flour, and Gabriel put the water on, and the brioche began the long slow rise it would take until tomorrow morning, when they would pull it out of the oven and someone would come in and ask what was in it, and they wouldn't know the whole story, and that was fine.

Somebody had to buy bread again. That was the whole of it.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 73: Manon's Testimony at Trial · The Proof of the Pudding · Lumen Reads