The Comtesse de Montclair's morning room smelled of beeswax and cold ash. Adele set her case on the worktable, unlatched it, and laid out her brushes in their roll of flannel, her swabs, the small tin of putty rubber she'd made herself from bread heels. The light through the tall windows was the flat, forgiving kind a restorer prayed for, and the Degas waited on its easel beneath a linen dust sheet like a patient.
"Careful with her," the Comtesse said from the doorway. She was seventy and dressed for a funeral she wasn't attending, black from collar to hem. "She weeps."
"Pastels don't weep, madame."
"This one does. Every spring, a little more of her goes." The Comtesse crossed to the easel and lifted the sheet herself, folding it with a maid's precision. "My husband bought her in 'ninety-eight. He said the dancer was looking at him. I never saw it. I saw a girl who wanted to be somewhere else."
Adele stepped closer. *Dancer at the Barre*, a Degas pastel a little larger than a bread board, the figure roughed in with black chalk and laid over with strokes of rose and umber so dry they looked ready to lift at a breath. The paper had cockled along the bottom edge. Foxing, brown as tea stains, crept from the corner. The frame was gilt, gessoed wood beneath, wormed in two places.
"She's been in the frame too long," Adele said. "Pastel wants to breathe. Paper wants—"
"Whatever she wants. You'll give it to her." The Comtesse pressed a key into Adele's palm. "The room locks. No one comes in but you. If Thérèse tells you luncheon is served, you tell her the restoration waits." She paused at the door. "And, madame Delacroix? My condolences on the frame. A marriage of that kind is a cage, but at least it's a well-gilded one."
The door clicked shut.
Adele exhaled and turned to the painting.
She worked the first hour on the frame alone. A scalpel of her own grinding, a sable brush, and a soft cloth took off a century of grime, the dust greasy as earwax in the corners where the rag never reached. The gilt had been regilded once, badly, the later leaf laid over the old with a red bole showing at the joins. Somebody had been in a hurry. Somebody always was.
She was angling the frame toward the window to catch the light when her cloth snagged.
Not on a split in the wood. On something else.
Adele set the cloth down and drew the loupe from her case, wedging it into the socket of her eye. In the channel between the frame's inner lip and the pastel's edge, where a century of dirt had packed itself into a hard grey cord, something glinted.
She reached in with the tweezers and drew it out.
A hairpin. Steel, once, though now bloomed black with tarnish, the kind of pin a woman of the last century would have used to pin a chignon or a hat, four inches long, one end bent into a loop no bigger than a lentil. The loop had a tiny bead of glass set in it, deep red, a garnet perhaps, dulled to the color of dried blood.
Adele turned it under the loupe. The pin was embedded in the dirt, not laid on top of it. It had been there a long time. Longer, she'd have sworn, than the regilding. Somebody had pushed it down into the channel and never come back for it. Not dropped. *Pushed.*
She put it in the pocket of her apron. Restorers kept what they found; the ethics of it were complicated, and the Comtesse would only ask to hold it and then lose it in a drawer. Later she would decide. Later she would ask the right questions.
Then she turned back to the pastel itself, and forgot the pin entirely for six minutes.
Because the pastel was wrong.
Adele had cleaned along the barre—the wooden rail the dancer grips—and the rose of the dancer's skirt where the strokes thinned at the edge. It was there, in the negative space, that she saw it: a line. Faint, black, drawn in chalk and then buried under pigment, but not buried evenly. It surfaced where the pastel had thinned with age, the way a scar shows through thin cloth.
The line ran from the dancer's hip down and out, at an angle no limb of the figure occupied. Adele sat back, took the loupe, and went over the whole surface inch by inch, and found more. A second line, parallel. A curve that might have been the sweep of a second dancer's skirt, another figure once standing where the empty floor was now. The topmost pastel was thick and velvety here—laid on to *cover*, the strokes deliberate and heavy, a hand working fast to hide what lay beneath. Underneath the covering, the old chalk waited.
Adele sat very still. Outside, a carriage went by on the rue de Grenelle, wheels grinding over the cobbles. In the room, nothing moved.
Overpainting happened. A patron wants the nude clothed, the mistress painted out, the dog made smaller. It happened all the time, and Degas—Degas had quarreled with the world his whole life, and patrons had paid men to cut his pictures out of frames and change them. But this was different. This wasn't a patron's cosmetic. The strokes were too hasty, too broad. Whoever had buried the second figure had been *covering a trail*, not flattering a client.
And a hairpin had lain in the channel of the frame for a hundred years, as if a woman had stood here once, leaning close to work, and pushed it down and left it.
Adele put her hand flat on the edge of the table. Her heart had gone quick, the way it did when a cleaning test lifted more than she expected, when the varnish came away and the pigment underneath was a color no one living had ever seen.
She thought, with a clarity that surprised her: *This painting came out of somewhere it wasn't supposed to. And somebody stood right here and made sure no one would ever know.*
The lock turned. Adele flinched and drew her hand back from the pastel.
"Mme Delacroix." The Comtesse stood in the doorway with a card between two fingers. "My man is downstairs. The car is waiting."
"Madame?"
"Thursday. The dinner." The Comtesse's gaze drifted past her to the easel, and for a moment—just a moment—something crossed her face that was not mourning and not civility. It was watchfulness. "You will bring your husband. I have told everyone. It is time Paris saw the two of you together."
"Of course." Adele covered the pastel with the sheet, smoothing it, her hands steady and her mind somewhere else entirely. "Madame—a question about provenance. The dancer. Where did your husband buy her?"
The Comtesse was already in the corridor. "Cologne," she said, without turning. "A dealer there. Nineteen years ago, or twenty. Does it matter?"
The door closed.
Adele stood alone with the covered painting and the locked door and the hairpin in her apron pocket, and after a moment she took out her ledger and wrote, in the back, on the page she kept for things that were not money:
*A hairpin, steel and garnet, in the frame channel. A figure under the figure. Painted over in haste.*
*The Comtesse knows.*
She closed the ledger and put it away. The bones of the wedding dinner were nothing. She could deflect questions about a husband. She could not yet decide, standing in the flat grey light of a locked room, whether she had just been handed a fortune or set at the mouth of a trap.