The figures at the gate did not knock. They stood in the lane where the lamplight from the kitchen window could not reach them, and after a long minute one of them struck a match, cupped it, and let it burn down to his fingers before he shook it out. It was not a signal. It was a way of being seen.
"Inside," Lucien said. "Now."
Claire had already moved. She pulled the shutters closed in the front room and latched them without a sound, the way a person does when she has done it before. Marguerite, who had been sitting with the Corot on her knees, stood up slowly and set the painting on the chair as though it were a sleeping child.
"How many?" she asked.
"Two."
"Then there will be more by morning. They do not come two at a time unless someone is watching the road." She looked at Adele. "You brought this to my door."
"I brought a photograph," Adele said. "Someone else had already found you. They telephoned from the café before we ever climbed your hill."
Marguerite's mouth tightened. She did not argue. She turned to Claire and said something low and rapid in a dialect Adele could not follow, and Claire nodded once and went out through the back of the house.
"We have the cart at five," Lucien said.
"Five will be too late."
"Then we take my motorcar."
"You have no motorcar," Adele said.
"I have a motorcar," Lucien said, "borrowed from a man in Fontainebleau who does not know yet that I borrowed it. It's in the tavern yard behind the church. It will hold four if one of us is thin."
Marguerite made a sound that was almost a laugh. "I have not been thin since the war."
They went out the back, through a kitchen garden wet with dew, and over a low wall into an orchard that ran along the spine of the hill. Marguerite carried nothing but her handbag and the Corot, wrapped in a piece of oilcloth Claire had pulled from under the sink. Claire came behind them with a lantern shuttered to a slit. No one spoke. Behind them, once, they heard the front gate creak open and then close again, and then the sound of a man's voice calling politely through the door of an empty house.
They reached the tavern yard a little before midnight. The car was where Lucien had left it, a black Peugeot with a dent in the near wing and a smell of wet wool inside. Lucien cranked it twice before it caught. The engine noise seemed to fill the entire valley. Claire stood at the gate with the lantern still shuttered and watched them go, and Adele understood that the daughter was staying behind, deliberately, as bait and as witness and as the only one of them with no name on any list.
Marguerite sat in the back with the painting against her knees. Adele sat beside her. For the first long stretch of road, none of them said anything.
"They will go to the house first," Marguerite said at last. "Not to the town. They will want to be sure of me before they warn anyone else."
"Then we have until morning," Adele said.
"We have until morning," Marguerite agreed. "After that they will not need to be sure. They will only need to be quick."
Paris took them in at half past three. Lucien drove straight to the rue de Seine and stopped in the shadow of an awning two doors from Adele's studio.
"You cannot go in," he said.
"It's my studio."
"It is the first place they will go, and you know it." He looked at her in the dark of the car. "Where else can you put her?"
Adele thought. There was one answer, and she had been avoiding it for a week.
Madame Colbert's. The old restorer's building on the rue de Braque, where Adele had learned her trade and where the attic rooms had been half empty since Colbert's sister died. Colbert was seventy-one, deaf in one ear, and hated everyone in the trade except Adele. She had never asked for help in her life and did not want to begin now.
"Do it," she said.
They put Marguerite and the Corot in the attic room at five in the morning. Colbert came down in her nightdress, looked at all three of them, looked longest at Marguerite, and said, "You are the Vasseur widow." Marguerite said nothing. Colbert said, "Good. Then you can sleep in my sister's bed; she was a difficult woman and it will not mind you." She went back upstairs.
Lucien left at dawn to return the borrowed car and to buy passage on a later boat; he would sail in four days instead of two, and he did not say why, and Adele did not ask.
She got back to the rue de Seine at seven.
The street was already awake, but not in the way streets are usually awake. There were two policemen at the corner, and a knot of neighbors standing well back from the smell, and the smell itself reached Adele from the end of the block. Smoke, but not the clean smoke of a chimney. Something underneath it: linseed, turpentine, varnish, rabbit-skin glue — the whole pantry of her trade, burning.
The studio door was a black mouth. The firemen had already come and gone. Water ran in a slow sheet across the threshold and into the gutter, and in the water were flecks of ash that had been canvas, and a corner of gilded frame.
Adele stood at the tape and did not move.
The ground floor was gone. The frames were gone, the easels, the trestle table, the drawers of pigments, the jars of mastic and dammar she had bought one at a time over six years. Her brushes were gone. The little kiln she used for warming panels was gone. In the back, where she had stored the linings and the stretchers and the half-finished portrait of a woman in a green dress that had taken her three months, there was only a hole in the roof through which the morning sky was showing, very blue, obscenely blue, as if nothing had happened.
The upper floor was smoke-stained but standing. The firemen had broken a window to get at it.
"Madame Moreau?" One of the policemen had come up behind her. He had a notebook and the patient, courteous expression of a man who has already decided what he thinks.
"Yes."
"You are the tenant of these premises."
"I am."
"Your neighbor reports that you were away last night."
"I was in the country."
"With whom?"
Adele looked at him. In four hours she had become the kind of person to whom that question could be asked.
"With a friend," she said. "On private business."
"Your business left some things behind." He turned a page. "There is a smell in the back room. Kerosene. This was not an accident, madame. Do you have enemies?"
The answer came to her with such clarity that it frightened her: she had made them in the last eight hours, and she had been making them for a year, and she had simply refused to count them.
"No," she said. "I have patrons."
The policeman wrote that down.
She walked to the rue de Braque in a daze of smoke and did not sleep. At noon Colbert woke her with a cup of coffee and said, "The widow wants to see you."
Marguerite was sitting at the attic window with the Corot propped on the sill in the gray light, and she had the same look on her face that Adele's father had worn when the bank took the shop: not grief, exactly. Arithmetic.
"They burned your studio," Marguerite said.
"Yes."
"Then they know you have something, and they know you are not going to give it back." She turned from the window. "The hairpin. You have it?"
Adele took it from her bag and laid it on the sill beside the painting.
"Good," Marguerite said. "Now you must understand what you are holding. The hairpin is a tool. The Corot is a confession. But neither of them will hang anyone, because in a courtroom it is one woman's word against a syndicate's lawyers, and they will call you a hysteric and me a lunatic, and they will burn whatever else they have to burn." She put her hand flat on the frame of the painting. "The Comtesse was vain. She had the works photographed before they were relined, every one, with the true owners' names written beneath. If any record of that survived, it did not survive in a ledger."
Adele looked at the frame. It was old, worm-eaten oak, gilded, with a deep rabbit and a back panel that had been planed flat. Too flat. A frame that old should have had a curve in the back, a hollow, a place for the wood to move.
"Madame," she said. "Where did the Comtesse keep her photographs?"
Marguerite smiled for the first time since the garden.
"That," she said, "is the right question."