The Second Chorus

Chapter 36: The New Teacher

Monday morning, Ms. Chen was already in Room 112 when Adam arrived, a coffee in one hand and a binder in the other, and she had rearranged the chairs into a half-circle before anyone else showed up.

"Mr. Reyes." She didn't stand. "You're early."

"Habit." He took the chair at the edge of the arc, which put his back to the door and gave him a view of the whole room. Fourteen years of firehouse training made a man do that automatically. He'd have liked to stop.

Vasquez had been clear: Monday's committee meeting, Room 112, eleven-thirty sharp. All communication cc'd. No hallway conversations, no post-rehearsal debriefs, no standing outside a doorway with your hands in your pockets trying to figure out what to say. It was the cleanest thing anyone had said to Adam in a month, and it made him feel like he'd been stripped of a language he'd only just learned.

Gabe came in at eleven thirty-two. He was wearing a faded green sweater Adam had seen before, and he looked like he hadn't slept well, and he sat down two chairs away from Adam with a nod that landed somewhere over Adam's left shoulder.

"Gabe." Ms. Chen slid a folder down the table. "Your notes."

"Yes, ma'am." He pushed the folder back across. "Bridge is still open. She won't let me—" He caught himself. "She won't let anyone finish it. Last I heard."

"So I understand." Ms. Chen looked at the folder without opening it. "I've read your arrangement. It's good work. I'm going to use most of it."

Something small and complicated moved across Gabe's face, and Adam, who had spent weeks learning to read that face, recognized it as relief, and hated that he recognized it.

They talked logistics for thirty-eight minutes. Stage plot. Sound check. Order of acts. Whether the gospel choir would still be doing their Shrek medley because apparently there was some kind of ongoing dispute about it. Gabe gave his input in short, careful sentences, and he did not look at Adam once, and Adam did not look at him except when he couldn't help it, which turned out to be a lot.

At the end, Gabe packed his bag and stood, and Ms. Chen said, "Mr. Aldridge," and he turned back. "Mayra's rehearsal is Wednesday at four. You're welcome to observe. From the back."

A beat.

"I don't think that's—" Gabe started.

"You've been her teacher for nine months." Ms. Chen's voice didn't move at all. "You're welcome to observe from the back. That's not a favor."

Gabe left. Adam sat in the chair for another minute, doing nothing, and then went home.

Wednesday, he picked Mayra up at the curb at 3:50 and drove her to Northgate himself, because the alternative was letting her walk and having her come home with a story about a bus. She didn't talk on the way over. She had a folder in her lap with the song in it, and she kept her thumb on the corner of it like the paper might fly away.

Ms. Chen had the choir room, which was bigger than the music room and had risers and a piano that was actually in tune. She let Mayra set up her own mic stand. That was probably deliberate.

"Can I hear it from the top?" Ms. Chen sat at the piano, hands off the keys.

Mayra looked at her.

"Not for notes. I just want to know where you're going."

"It's not finished."

"Sing me what is."

Adam stood by the door with his arms crossed. He wasn't supposed to be at the back of the room—Vasquez hadn't technically said he couldn't be in his daughter's rehearsal, but the memo had what a memo has, which is a certain tone—so he stood at the door and tried to make himself small.

Mayra sang. The verse again, still honest, still slightly off in a way that made you look at her. The chorus, which she'd finally finished the week before and which was better than it had any right to be. And then the bridge, which stopped at the same place it had stopped for three weeks.

Ms. Chen nodded. "Okay. That's good."

"It's not done."

"No," said Ms. Chen. "It isn't. So let's work on the transition into the bridge first. Mm-hm. Your chorus ends on a lift, and you go straight to a drop, and the drop isn't earning itself because you haven't given it anything to fall from."

Adam watched his daughter's face harden, and then, slowly, un-harden, because Ms. Chen was right and Mayra was twelve and even at twelve she could feel the difference between being managed and being told the truth.

"Can you play it?" Mayra said.

Ms. Chen played it. She played it the way it was written and then she played it a different way, dropping the last chord of the chorus a half-step into the bridge, and Mayra stood there with her mouth slightly open, and Adam's chest did something he couldn't quite identify.

The half-step. The same drop Gabe had suggested. He'd have known it anywhere.

"Where'd you get that?" Mayra asked.

"Your teacher wrote it in his notes." Ms. Chen looked at the page. "He wrote a lot of things in his notes."

Mayra didn't answer that. She looked at the folder in her hands for a long time, and then she said, "Fine," which from her was practically a hymn, and they worked for another forty minutes and got four measures further than anyone had in three weeks.

The weeks after that went like this.

Monday, Room 112. Festival business. Gabe at the far end of the table, Adam at the other end. They said "hi" and "good to see you" and "I'll send the stage plot" in the tones of two men who had never touched a single thing about each other. The third Monday, Adam realized he had started checking the column of the room where Gabe sat before he even sat down. The fourth Monday, he realized he'd been standing in the hallway outside Room 112 for five minutes with no reason to be there, and he went in early.

Wednesday, choir room. Mayra rehearsing, Ms. Chen coaching, Adam at the door. Gabe showed up once, in the fourth week, and hovered at the back of the risers for the whole hour with his hands in his pockets, and Mayra saw him and didn't say anything, and when he left he didn't look at Adam, and Adam walked out to his truck afterward and sat in it for eleven minutes with the engine off.

Friday, Saturday, Sunday, they didn't see each other at all. Adam worked his desk shift, shoulder glued to an ice pack, and read the fire reports he wasn't allowed to run on. At home, Mayra was polite. She was always, always polite now. She said thank-you and yes please and she did her homework without being asked, and she had stopped telling him about her day. He didn't know how to ask her to start again.

One night he found himself scrolling back through his phone to the texts from six weeks ago. *Rehearsal's Wednesday at four. You want to come by early?* He scrolled further. *your harmony was right.* *thanks.* *can you stay after?* He read them the way you read someone else's mail after they're dead, looking for something he must have missed.

He wasn't stupid. He knew what the feeling was. It had been there since the first fight in the school hallway, if he was honest, since the first time in the music room when Gabe had looked up and said *play it in D*, and Adam had played it in D and felt something shift under his feet, like stepping onto a floor that had always been there and just never had a wall.

He just hadn't let himself look at it too closely.

And now he couldn't look away from the empty chair at the end of the long table on Monday, or the way Gabe's shoulders came up around his ears when he was tired, or the way his coffee cup had a chip out of the rim and he drank from the same side every time. He'd noticed that, at some point, in the music room. Six weeks ago. A month before the fight.

He was sitting in his kitchen at 11:40 on a Thursday, alone, because Mayra had gone to bed at nine and the house had gotten very quiet, when his phone buzzed.

Gabe. Not a group thread. Just Gabe.

*I think I found someone who has Elena's master tape. His name is Rick Salinas. He's got a studio over in Cortez. He wants to meet Saturday at 2. You in?*

Adam read it three times. His hands felt cold and his throat felt tight, and he thought, distantly, that grief was a strange organ that didn't follow the rules of the rest of the body.

He typed back: *I'm in.*

Then, before he could stop himself: *Does Mayra know?*

A pause. Three dots. Then: *Not yet. I wanted to ask you first.*

Adam sat in the dark kitchen with the phone in both hands, and for the first time in a month, he felt like he was standing inside his own life instead of watching it through a window.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 36: The New Teacher · The Second Chorus · Lumen Reads