The Second Chorus

Chapter 40: Gabe's Door

Gabe had his hand on the kettle when the buzzer rasped. Not his usual three-note pattern—someone leaning hard on it. He set the kettle down and crossed to the door.

Through the peephole: Mayra Reyes, backpack strap twisted in both fists, face streaked and swollen, eyes fixed on the door like it owed her something.

He opened it. She didn't say anything. She just looked at him, and her chin came apart.

"Okay," Gabe said. "Okay. Come in."

She stepped past him into the kitchen and stood there, small under the pendant light, tears coming the way they come when you've been holding them for a whole ride across town. Gabe pulled a chair out. She didn't sit. He put the kettle back on because his hands needed a job.

"Your dad's on his way," he said. A guess. He'd texted Adam the second she'd knocked. Adam had read it and the little dots had started and stopped three times.

"He's going to be mad," Mayra said.

"Probably he's scared. Those can look alike from the outside."

She wiped her face with her sleeve. "You called him."

"I texted him. There's a difference, and I'm hoping he respects it."

She almost laughed. It came out as a hiccup. She sat down then, hard, and put her forehead on the kitchen table, and Gabe stood at the stove and let the kettle fill the silence with its rising murmur. Outside, the street was doing its Saturday-afternoon nothing: one car, a dog barking twice, the plains wind scraping what was left of the snow.

The knock came twenty minutes later, fast and flat. Gabe opened the door. Adam's jacket was half zipped, hair wild from the drive, and he looked past Gabe before he looked at him.

"She's here."

"Kitchen."

Adam went by him. Gabe stayed in the doorway a second, watching the hallway, in case anyone else had followed. Nobody had.

By the time he got to the kitchen Adam was on his haunches in front of Mayra's chair, one hand hovering near her shoulder like he'd forgotten how to land it.

"Mija."

"I know you're mad."

"I'm not—" He stopped. Looked at Gabe, then at the floor, then at her. "I'm not mad. I was worried sick."

"You lied."

The word sat there. Adam didn't flinch, which Gabe thought took something.

"I didn't tell you about the recording," Adam said. "That's true."

"Eight weeks. It was in your toolbox. Under the—with the stuff you never touch."

"I know."

"Mom's voice is on it and you had it in a box."

"I know."

She finally looked at him. Her face was terrifying to watch—not because it was angry, because it was young. "Why."

Adam sat all the way down on the floor. It was the only honest thing to do, Gabe thought, and he wondered if Adam had thought it or just done it.

"Because the first time I played it," Adam said, "I got about forty seconds in and I couldn't breathe. I sat in the truck in the driveway and I couldn't get out. So I put it away. And then every week I didn't get it out, it got harder to get out, and I told myself I was waiting to have it restored, and then I told myself I was waiting for the right—there wasn't a right time, Mayra. There was never going to be a right time. I just didn't want to be the one who broke."

"You're not the only one who misses her."

"I know."

"Then why do you get to be the one who decides when we're allowed to feel it?"

Adam had no answer for that. His hands were open on his knees and empty. Gabe turned the burner off. The kettle didn't whistle.

"Can I say something," Gabe said, "or would you rather I make myself scarce."

Mayra looked at him. Then, unexpectedly: "Say it."

"Your mom's song stopped in the middle of a word. Second chorus. It just—ends." He kept his voice level. "That's not a release. That's a work tape. She wasn't done. Somebody in the room probably said 'let's break for lunch,' and that's where the tape stopped, because that's where they broke for lunch."

"How do you know that?"

"Because I've heard a hundred of them. Because Salinas had the session log and it says break, 12:40. Nobody stopped on purpose, Mayra. She just didn't get back."

Mayra was quiet. Her fists had loosened on the backpack.

"I want to finish it," she said.

Adam's whole body went stiff. "No."

"Why."

"Because it isn't ours to finish." He said it fast, like he'd rehearsed it on the drive. "It's hers. And I'm—" he dragged a hand down his face— "I'm not going to sit in a room and help you build an ending on top of the last thing she ever made. I can't. I'm telling you the truth this time and the truth is I can't."

"See," Mayra said, flat. "You say I get to feel it and then you put a lock on the only part that matters."

"Mija—"

"No. You don't even want me to try. You just want me to put it back in the toolbox."

"That's not—"

"It is. It is what you want."

Gabe put the two mugs he'd made on the table because he didn't know what else to do with his hands. Neither of them touched them.

"Okay," Gabe said. "Can I try a third thing? If it's stupid, throw it out."

Mayra's eyes were red and she looked at him dully. "Fine."

"Don't finish hers."

She opened her mouth.

"Hear me out. Don't finish hers. She stopped mid-word—that's hers. Leave it. But she wrote you something, whether she meant to or not, and it's unfinished, and it's *pointing*, and the whole time you've been telling me about that bridge you can't write, I've been thinking—you're not trying to fill her hole. You're trying to answer the phone."

Adam frowned. "What?"

"She heard a question," Gabe said to him. "In the second chorus. She told me it stops like somebody got cut off mid-sentence. That's what an unfinished song *is*. It's a sentence without a period." He looked back at Mayra. "So don't finish her sentence. Write your own. Answer the one she left."

Mayra stared at the table. Then at Gabe. Then, slowly, at Adam, who was still sitting on the kitchen floor with his back against the cabinet.

"Like a duet," she said.

"Like a response. It can be anything. Same melody, different melody, doesn't matter. It just has to be yours."

Mayra pulled her backpack up onto the table and dug in it—deeper than schoolbooks—and came out with a spiral notebook, bent at the corner, the one Gabe had seen her carrying since September. She set it down between the mugs. She didn't open it. She put her hand flat on the cover like a book she was swearing on.

"If I do it," she said to Adam, "you can't put it in the toolbox."

Adam was quiet for a long moment. Then: "If you do it, I'll be in the room."

"Promise."

"I promise."

She looked at him a while longer, testing it. Then she nodded once.

"I'm not going back to Ms. Chen's arrangement," she said. "I want mine."

"Fine," Adam said.

"And I'm going to need—" She stopped, looked at Gabe, and then looked away, quick. "Never mind."

"What?"

"Nothing."

"Mayra."

She flipped the notebook open to a page of crossed-out lines. "I'm going to need somebody who knows how songs end," she said, to the page. "That's all."

Gabe's turn to be quiet. He picked up a mug, mostly to have something to hold, and the coffee was too hot so he just held it.

"I can do that," he said. "Not as your teacher. Vasquez would have my job and your dad's." He glanced at Adam—whose face, for the first time since he walked in, had something in it other than fear. "We'll figure out the words for it. Saturdays. Somewhere that isn't a school."

Adam stood up. He looked like a man who'd been standing in front of a door for two months and had just now noticed it wasn't locked.

"Saturday," he said.

"Saturday," Gabe said.

Mayra closed the notebook. She still hadn't drunk her coffee. She looked small and wrecked and, for the first time in weeks, aimed at something.

Then her phone buzzed on the table, screen up. All three of them saw it.

**PRINCIPAL VASQUEZ** — Mayra, I heard you left campus mid-activity and I have some questions. Please have your father call me tonight. Also—Adam's phone went off. He pulled it out. Same name. The same block of text, more or less, and then one more line that only he could see.

*Separately: I've had two reports about Mr. Okafor's apartment today. I'd like to clear this up before I have to make it a formal matter.*

Adam held the screen so Gabe could read it. Gabe's stomach dropped through the floor.

Nobody had reportable business at Gabe's apartment today except the twelve-year-old sitting at his kitchen table. He looked at Mayra. She was already looking back.

"Somebody called her," Mayra said. "Somebody saw my bike."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 40: Gabe's Door · The Second Chorus · Lumen Reads