The Second Chorus

Chapter 75: The First Fight

The fight started over a permission slip.

Adam found it on the kitchen counter, crumpled, Friday's date circled in green marker. Overnight field trip to the dinosaur dig outside Cañon City. Cost: eighty dollars. Signed in a hand that wasn't his.

He read it twice. Then he read the signature line again, where Gabe had written his name like it belonged there, like it had always been there.

"Hey." Gabe came in from the garage with two bags of groceries, February cold still on his jacket. "They had the good coffee finally, I grabbed—"

"Did you sign this?"

Gabe set the bags down. Looked at the paper. "Yeah. She was going to miss the deadline."

"Her deadline was Monday."

"Her deadline was Friday and she told me it was Monday because she thought you'd say no." Gabe pulled his gloves off, slow. "Don't be mad at her. She was scared."

"I'm not mad at her." Adam set the slip down flat, flattening it with his palm. "I'm asking why my daughter's permission slip got signed by somebody with no legal standing to sign it."

The room got very quiet. Down the hall, the shower hissed. Mayra was in it, which meant she couldn't hear them, which meant this was the only window they had and both of them knew it.

"That's not—" Gabe stopped. Started again. "She asked me to. It was going to sit there and she wanted to go."

"So you decided for me."

"I didn't decide anything. I just— the dig's a good thing, Adam. She's been talking about it for two weeks."

"I know what she's been talking about. I live here."

Gabe's jaw tightened. He started putting groceries away, cans into the pantry with more force than canned peaches needed. "Okay. So this is about more than a piece of paper."

"It's about you making calls about my kid."

"I made a call about a field trip."

"You signed her name on a form." Adam heard his own voice going hard, the voice he used at the station when he needed people to move fast and not argue. "That's not the same thing as a call. That's paperwork. That's answering for her."

"Because I'm the one who's here when the form gets handed out."

It landed. Adam felt it land. He stood very still.

Gabe heard himself and his hands stopped over the grocery bag. "That's not what I—"

"That's exactly what you said."

"It's what I meant about the form." Gabe turned around. His face had gone careful, which was worse than angry. "You're on shift two nights a week. You're at the station until ten. When the paperwork comes home, it comes home to me. I didn't ask for that. It just happens."

"So you're the parent now."

"I didn't say parent."

"You signed a permission slip."

"To help." Gabe's voice finally rose to meet his. "To help her, because she was going to sit home and watch a good thing go by, and I've watched a lot of good things go by and nobody signed anything for me."

"That's not her job. She doesn't owe you your childhood back."

The words hung there. Adam heard them come out and every word after he'd said them was worse than the last.

Gabe went pale, then red, then still. He set the last can down without sound.

"You want to take that back," he said quietly.

"Tell me I'm wrong."

"You're wrong." Gabe's hands hung at his sides. "God, Adam, you're so wrong it's not even— I'm not trying to be her father. Nobody can be her father but you. I know that. I'm trying to be somebody who's here, and you keep—" He stopped. Pressed his mouth shut hard.

"Keep what."

"Nothing."

"Finish it."

"You keep deciding which rooms I get to stand in." Gabe grabbed his jacket off the hook. "And then when I stand in one, you tell me I overstepped. I don't know the rules and you won't give me any, and then you get to be mad at me for guessing wrong."

"I never told you it was wrong to care about her."

"You just told me her childhood isn't about me." Gabe's voice cracked on the last word and he got it back under control. "So which is it."

"I said there's a line—"

"You drew the line and didn't tell me where it was." Gabe pulled the door open. Cold came in. "Call me when you figure out where I'm allowed to stand."

The door shut. Not a slam. Adam would have preferred a slam.

He stood in the kitchen for a long minute and then began, methodically, to finish putting away the groceries.

The next two days were the kind where the house worked exactly as well as it always did — meals, laundry, homework, the truck dropping Mayra at school — and where every room had one chair empty in it.

Gabe answered texts. Short ones.

*Fine. Busy week, five rehearsals.*

Adam wrote whole paragraphs and deleted them.

He wasn't wrong about the form. That was the thing he kept returning to, at 3 a.m., on the recliner, in the dark. He was her father. There was paperwork and there was standing, and standing came from him, and it wasn't unreasonable to want to know who was signing his daughter's name on anything.

Then he'd remember Gabe's face when he'd said nobody signed anything for me, and he'd have to get up and walk around.

On Tuesday he came home and found Mayra sitting on the kitchen counter with her shoes on the cabinet and her arms crossed.

"Hi," he said. "Shoes."

She didn't move. "You had a fight."

"Who told you."

"Nobody had to tell me. He hasn't been here in two days and you keep putting your mug in the wrong cupboard." She looked at him steadily. She had Elena's eyes and Elena's way of not blinking when she wanted an answer. "I'm not a baby, Dad."

"I know you're not."

"I heard it." Mayra uncrossed her arms and put them in her lap and looked suddenly, badly twelve. "Not all of it. The end part. About how I don't owe him anything."

Adam's stomach dropped through the floor. "Mayra—"

"That's not true." Her voice wavered and held. "I asked him to sign it. I did that. It's not his fault and you made him leave and it's— it's my fault—"

"Hey. No." He crossed the kitchen and pulled her off the counter into a hug and she let him, which at twelve was its own kind of answer. "Nothing that happened is yours. You hear me? Not one part of it."

"You yelled at him."

"I know."

"Because of me."

"Because I'm an idiot," Adam said into her hair. "That part's on me. That's completely on me."

She pulled back, sniffed, wiped her face with the flat of her hand like she wasn't going to give it the satisfaction. "Then fix it."

"It's not that simple."

"It's not complicated." She hopped off the counter, done with him, twelve again. "You tell him you were wrong and he tells you he was wrong and then we all live here. That's it."

*We all live here.* She said it like it was a fact of the world.

Adam stood in his kitchen and understood, suddenly and completely, exactly where the line was. He'd been drawing it around Gabe. He should have been drawing it around the two of them, together, and standing inside it with him.

He grabbed his keys.

"You driving there now?" Mayra called after him.

"Yeah."

"It's a school night."

"I know."

"Just checking." She was grinning when he looked back. "Tell him I'm going on the dig whether he signs it or you sign it."

Gabe's apartment above the music shop had one window lit. Adam rang the bell and then, because he was a firefighter and this was an emergency of a particular kind, he rang it again.

Gabe opened the door in socks. He didn't look surprised. He looked tired, and he looked at Adam like he wanted to let him in and couldn't quite.

"I'm not here to win," Adam said.

"I didn't think you were."

"I shouldn't have said it. About your childhood. That was— I took the worst thing I knew about you and I used it, and I've never done that to anybody in my life and I did it to you." He made himself keep going. "You're right that you're here when the forms come home. You're right that I never told you where the line was and then I got mad when you crossed it. That's not fair. That's on me."

Gabe held the door. Then he stepped back, which meant *come in*, and Adam did.

"I shouldn't have said the thing about being here when the forms get handed out," Gabe said, closing the door behind him. "That wasn't about helping her. That was me feeling sorry for myself and putting it on you."

"Yeah."

"I don't actually think I'm her parent. I never once thought that."

"Good," Adam said. "Because I need you to be something else she doesn't have."

Gabe looked up at him, wary. "What."

Adam reached into his jacket and pulled out the permission slip. He'd ironed it, which was perhaps the most embarrassing thing he'd done all year.

"I need you to sign it," he said. "And then I need to put you on the school's approved-contact list, because she's going to need somebody when I'm on shift and she's got a fever and it's not an emergency she can call 911 for. And because Friday I want both of us to drive her up to that dig." He held the paper out. "If you still want to."

Gabe looked at the paper for a long moment without taking it.

"Approved-contact list," he said finally.

"Yeah."

"That's a real form. There's a real form for that."

"There is."

Gabe took it. His hands weren't quite steady, and he smoothed the paper flat like Adam had done two days ago, and something in his face decided.

"Okay," he said. "But we're making rules. Actual rules. Because I am not doing this again on instinct and I am not guessing." He looked at Adam straight. "You have to teach me the house. I don't know it like you do."

"I know you don't." Adam felt, for the first time in three days, like he could breathe. "So we'll teach each other."

Then his phone buzzed in his pocket. And kept buzzing. He pulled it out, and it was Carla Voss, calling at 9:40 at night, which meant she was calling from home, which meant it wasn't about a scheduled meeting.

He answered.

"Carla."

"Adam." She sounded different than her professional voice. Tired, and something underneath it. "I need to tell you something and I'd rather you hear it from me than from the county in the morning. The disclosure file — there's a second part. I got it pulled forward." A pause. "It's about the foster mother. She didn't just call the county asking about Gabe. She's petitioning to reestablish contact, and she's named Gabe as next of kin."

Adam went very still in Gabe's small kitchen, the permission slip in Gabe's hand, Gabe watching his face change.

"And there's a problem," Carla said. "There's a reason that file was sealed, and Gabe doesn't know about it."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 75: The First Fight · The Second Chorus · Lumen Reads