The Speechwriter's Silence

Chapter 82: The Coffee After

The coffee shop was wedged between a shuttered florist and a laundromat on a block in Shaw that still had cobblestones under the asphalt, and Noah got there eleven minutes early because he had learned at some point in the last two weeks that arriving early was the only way he knew how to be nervous without showing it.

He took the table by the window. He read the menu twice even though he was going to order drip coffee. He put his phone face-down on the table and then turned it face-up and then turned it face-down again.

Arthur came in at 2:04, black coat, no umbrella, wet at the shoulders — a real rain, the late-October kind that fell without weather in it, just water and grey. He shook out his coat at the door and saw Noah and crossed the room like he had been crossing rooms toward him his whole life, which was a thing Noah had noticed about him in the hospital and had been unable not to notice since.

"You're early," Arthur said, sitting.

"You're wet."

"It's raining."

"I can see that."

Arthur flagged the counter with two fingers without looking at it, an inherited gesture so perfectly senatorial that Noah had to bite the inside of his cheek. He ordered a flat white. Noah, who had rehearsed ordering drip, ordered a flat white too.

Neither of them said anything for a moment.

"So," Noah said. "No campaign."

"No campaign," Arthur agreed. "I've been — I've been awake at seven every morning for two weeks and I don't know what to do with it. I went to the gym Monday. I went again Tuesday. By Thursday I was doing it twice a day and I realized I was just trying to tire myself out enough to stop thinking."

"Did it work?"

"No." Arthur turned his cup a quarter turn. "You?"

Noah hadn't planned to answer honestly, and then answered honestly anyway. "I've been sleeping. Actually sleeping. My cardiologist says my numbers are better than they've been since I started on the campaign. So I'm — I'm thriving, apparently. Emotionally I'm a disaster, but the electrocardiogram is very happy."

Arthur laughed — that clipped, surprised laugh that came out of him maybe once a week, like a door he kept shut most of the time.

"You're not on the campaign either," Arthur said. "I know that. Hollis told me you resigned the day after."

Noah looked at him.

"I'm not angry," Arthur said quickly, and then: "That's a lie. I was angry for about four days. And then Dr. Fitz came to the house and told me that a man with your condition who doesn't slow down sometimes doesn't get a second warning, and I — I stopped being angry. It took about nine seconds after that."

"Nine seconds."

"I counted."

Noah wrapped both hands around the cup. The flat white was too hot; he drank it anyway.

"So Whitfield's people called me," he said. "Two weeks ago. Before the hospital. They wanted a statement on the Ellison provision, which I did not give them, and then they wanted me to sign a consulting agreement that would have involved me not talking to you."

Arthur looked at the table. "I know."

"You know?"

"Camille told me." He lifted his eyes. "Nine days before I called you. I've known about the committee report since the Thursday before the bill signing. I've known about the caption. I've known about all of it."

The rain picked up against the window. Noah set down the cup so hard a little of it slopped over the rim.

"Nine days."

"Yes."

"Arthur."

"I know." Arthur's jaw worked once. "I told myself I was giving you space. I told myself you'd call me when you were ready, and I — Noah, I have spent my whole life not being the person who calls first, and I don't have a good reason and I know it. I'm not asking you to forgive it. I'm telling you that you've now heard it from me and not from someone else, which is how it should have been nine days ago."

"That's the whole reason you asked me here."

"No." Arthur drank his coffee. "That's not the whole reason I asked you here."

The bell over the door rang. A man came in with a stroller, wrestling it around the doorframe; the shop's whole volume went up and then down. Noah watched Arthur watch the door, the reflex of a man who had spent thirty years in rooms where someone might be listening.

"No script," Arthur said, when the shop was quiet again. "I want to try a conversation that isn't a negotiation or a statement or a thing you have to draft and then delete. I don't — I haven't done that. I don't know if I know how."

"You're doing it now."

"Badly."

"You're doing it," Noah said. "I've written the other kind of conversation for sixteen years. This is better."

Arthur was quiet for a moment. Then, evenly: "Does your mother still call on Sundays."

"Yes. She wants to meet. I've been putting her off."

"Why?"

"Because I don't want to explain the last year to her in the length of one phone call, and I don't want to lie about it either." Noah shrugged. "She'd ask about you. Or she'd not ask, which would be worse."

"She'd ask," Arthur said. "I've met your mother's kind."

"You have not met my mother."

"I've met her voicemail."

Noah laughed — actually laughed, a whole one — and was surprised by how much he'd needed to. Arthur's mouth tilted, and Noah watched it happen and did not pretend not to.

"You're not drinking," Arthur said. "I ordered you the same thing and I don't actually know if you like flat whites."

"I have no idea if I like flat whites."

"Then why'd you order one."

"Because you did," Noah said, and then heard himself, and looked at the window.

The rain was easing. Outside, someone went by on a bike with the seat wrapped in plastic, and a woman on the sidewalk was putting up the awning on the next storefront, a new one, still taped. Noah watched her work for longer than he needed to.

"I don't have a job," he said, to the window. "I have some savings. I have a cardiology appointment Thursday. That's my whole calendar."

"Good," Arthur said.

"It's not good, it's terrifying."

"It's good." Arthur set down his cup. "You've had a real heart event and a committee that named a provision after you, and one of those is going to be a problem that does not care whether you're ready for it. I'm not going to pretend I don't know that."

Noah turned back to him. "What do you mean."

"There's a lawsuit. The caption's been tested — the first challenge under the Ellison provision was filed ten days ago, and the press will find out you're the Ellison before you decide what you want to say about it." Arthur held his eyes. "You didn't know."

"I knew about the provision. I didn't know there was already a case."

"Now you do."

"How —"

"I read. I still know people." A pause. "I'm not on the battlefield anymore, Noah. I'm just not going to watch you walk into one blind."

The barista wiped the counter. Noah sat with his hands flat on the table and felt his own pulse, which he had been taught in the hospital to feel, and had been doing, and hated.

"Okay," he said finally. "Okay. Thank you for telling me."

"I could have told you from the car. I came here instead because I wanted to tell you sitting down."

"You came here because you wanted coffee."

"I came here," Arthur said, "because I have spent nine days composing a reason to see you and I finally admitted to myself I didn't need one."

He said it plainly and then looked away, at the rain, at the window, at anything — and his hands were still, which Noah noticed, which he had been noticing all hour, and which he decided not to say anything about.

The bell over the door rang again. A different man, with a wet dog.

Arthur turned back. He folded his napkin in half and then in half again — a nervous gesture, an old one, Noah had seen him do it in the back of a car in July — and spoke to the napkin.

"Have dinner with me."

Noah's cup was almost empty. He didn't move it.

"Not as a client," Arthur went on, still to the napkin. "Not as the son of a candidate. Not as anything that has a title you could write on a card. I want to sit across a table from you and eat something and find out what you're like when you're not taking notes on me."

"Arthur."

"I'd like to say yes or no," Arthur said. "Either is fine. I know what I'm asking."

The rain had stopped. On the sidewalk, the woman had finished with her awning and was standing under it, pleased with the work. Noah looked at her for one more second — for balance, for air — and then looked at Arthur, who was looking at the napkin, which by now had been folded down to something the size of a card.

"Yes," Noah said.

Arthur's head came up.

"Yes," Noah said again. "But I'd like a question answered first, and I'm asking it now because you said no scripts."

"Ask."

"In the hospital you told me you knew the kind of warning I had." Noah held his eyes. "What was yours."

Arthur looked at him for a long moment. The folded napkin sat in front of him, small and neat. He didn't unfold it.

"They ran me for governor in '98," he said. "I was forty-one. I came off the trail in the spring and I didn't tell anyone for a month that I couldn't feel my left hand in the mornings." He picked up his cup; the coffee in it was gone; he set it back down. "I've never said that out loud. Not to Camille. Not to Margaret. Not to anyone."

The barista called out a drink order that wasn't theirs.

"Ask me again about dinner," Arthur said.

"When."

"Saturday."

"Saturday," Noah said. "Yes."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 82: The Coffee After · The Speechwriter's Silence · Lumen Reads