The awning was gone. That was the first thing Noah noticed — the green canvas that used to sag over the entrance on 14th, the one with a hairline tear near the left seam that Arthur had pointed out on their first dinner like it was a personality flaw in the building. In its place was a black metal canopy, squared off, with recessed lighting that made the sidewalk look like the lobby of a hotel nobody could afford.
"Under new management," Arthur said, reading the small placard by the door.
Noah looked at him. Arthur's hands were in his coat pockets, shoulders level. He looked like a man arriving at a negotiation.
"We can go somewhere else," Noah said.
"No." Arthur pulled the door. "We came here."
Inside, the room had been rearranged. The bar that used to run along the left wall had been moved to the back, and the tables — the same tables, Noah thought, the same scarred oak two-tops that had been there since the place opened — had been pushed closer together under new pendant lights, low and warm and a little too bright over the center of each table. A server in a black apron met them at the host stand and asked for a name.
"No reservation," Arthur said.
The server glanced at the room. Half the tables were empty. "Two?"
"Two."
He seated them at a table near the window, the same window, Noah realized, the same window where he had spent the first twenty minutes of that first dinner not eating his bread and trying to decide whether the man across from him was flirting or evaluating him. He had decided neither and both. He had been right.
The menus were new. Laminated. Noah opened his and looked for the things they had ordered.
"The duck's still here," he said.
"The short rib is not."
"It's under 'large plates.'" Noah turned the menu toward him. "Same description. They just moved it."
Arthur took the menu and read it the way he read everything — slowly, once, as though the second reading would be for someone else's benefit. "Onion jam. That's the same."
"We should order the same things."
"Why?"
Noah shrugged. "To see if it holds."
Arthur set the menu down. "That's not a reason."
"It's a reason."
The server came back with water and a bottle of something Noah hadn't ordered. "Compliments of the house," she said. "New ownership wants to meet the neighborhood."
"Gentrified already," Noah said when she'd gone.
Arthur picked up his glass and didn't drink. "You're the one who wanted to come back."
"I wanted to come back to the table. Not the concept."
"There is no table without the concept. You taught me that." Arthur took a sip. "Everything is the room it's in."
Noah laughed, short. "That's the most speechwriter thing you've ever said to me."
"I've been listening."
They ordered the duck and the short rib. The duck came with the same blackberry gastrique, the short rib with the same onion jam, and when the plates arrived Noah watched Arthur take the first bite and wait for the verdict.
"It's the same," Arthur said.
"I think it's different."
"You think it's different because the light is different."
"Maybe."
They ate for a while without talking. The room filled around them — a four-top of men in suits and loosened ties, a couple at the bar who kept leaning toward each other over a shared plate of something fried, a woman alone at the corner table with a laptop and a glass of wine. The noise level rose and settled. Noah found himself listening to it the way he listened to a room he was about to speak in, checking it for the register, for the place the sound gave way.
"You have a cardiology appointment," Arthur said.
"Thursday."
"Are you going to tell me what they say?"
"I'll tell you what they say."
Arthur nodded and cut his short rib. "You say that like it's a concession."
"It is."
"I know." He didn't look up. "I'm not asking you to concede. I'm asking you to keep the appointment."
Noah set down his fork. "You're the one who missed nine days."
The fork in Arthur's hand stopped. He set it down and folded his napkin, corner to corner, once, then again, then pressed the fold flat with his thumb. Noah recognized the gesture — the car, in July, the night everything had started to come apart. He had catalogued it then without knowing he was cataloguing it.
"Yes," Arthur said. "I did."
"Are we going to do that?"
"I don't know what 'that' is."
"The part where you tell me why."
Arthur looked at the window. Outside, a bus went by and the light changed on the glass. "I was angry about the voicemails. I told you that."
"That's not the same as why you didn't call."
"No." He turned back. "It isn't."
"Then why."
Arthur was quiet for long enough that the server refilled their water and left again. "Because I knew what you were going to tell me," he said finally. "About the report. About the caption. And I knew that once you told me, I would have to decide what I was going to do about it, and I didn't want to decide. I wanted one more week of not deciding."
"That's not a decision either."
"I'm aware."
"It's a decision to do nothing. You know that better than I do."
"I do." Arthur's voice was even. "And I've spent nine days deciding it was the wrong one, and I still haven't decided the right one, which is — " He stopped. "Which is why I'm here and not somewhere else."
Noah picked his fork back up and ate the last of the duck. It tasted the same. He wasn't going to say it tasted the same.
"The lawsuit," he said. "The one under the Ellison provision."
"I've read the filing."
"Of course you have."
"It's not — " Arthur leaned back and looked at the ceiling for a second, a gesture so unlike him that Noah almost asked if he was all right. "It's not a case that's meant to be won. It's a case that's meant to establish the question."
"You mean it's meant to make my name the answer to the question."
"Yes."
"So the press."
"Eventually."
"And they'll call you first."
"They'll call me eventually." Arthur looked at him. "They'll call you first. You're the named party."
Noah set his fork down on the plate and pushed it an inch away. The woman with the laptop had closed the laptop and was drinking her wine and looking at nothing. The four-top of men had ordered dessert. The couple at the bar had paid and were putting on their coats.
"I don't have a lawyer," Noah said.
"I know."
"I don't have a statement."
"I know."
"I don't even know what the statement would be. 'I am the Ellison in the Ellison provision, and I — '" He stopped. "That's not a sentence I've ever had to write."
"I could help you write it," Arthur said.
Noah looked at him. "You'd be writing it against your own campaign."
"Yes."
"That's a conflict."
"It's several." Arthur almost smiled. "But you're not in the room for them, and I'm not in the room for yours. I've been thinking about who could do it cleanly."
"You've been thinking about it."
"I've had nine days."
Noah laughed, and it came out real, and he was surprised by it — the sound of it in the room, in this room, at this table. "You sat in your house and thought about who would represent me against the thing you built."
"I sat in my house and thought about a lot of things."
"Like what."
Arthur looked at the bread basket, which they had not touched, and then at Noah. "Like whether you would still want to be at this table if I told you the truth about what I intend to do, and whether the truth would change the answer, and whether I would tell you the truth anyway." He took a breath. "In that order."
"That's the most speechwriter thing you've ever said to me."
"I know."
The server came by and asked if they wanted coffee. Arthur said yes. Noah said yes. She cleared the plates and left.
"You never answered the question," Noah said. "What kind of relationship this is."
"I know."
"And you're not going to answer it tonight."
"Not the way you asked it." Arthur wrapped both hands around the coffee cup when it came, and they were steady, and Noah watched them anyway. "You asked it as a thing with a title. I don't have a title. I have a decision I haven't made and a man I keep sitting across from, and I notice that I have been calling you every time I have something to say and then not calling you when I have something to lose."
"That's a lot of words for — "
"I want to do this without a deadline."
Noah stopped.
Arthur didn't look away. "The campaign has a deadline. The lawsuit has a deadline. The report has a deadline. Everything we have is sitting inside something that expires." He set the cup down. "I'm not asking you to sign anything. I'm asking you to stop measuring this in days. I want to do this without a deadline, and I don't know what that costs yet, and I'm telling you before I know."
The coffee was getting cold. Outside, the bus came back the other way and the light changed on the glass and changed back. Noah sat with his hands flat on the table and understood, with a clarity that felt like the moment a room goes quiet before someone speaks, that he had been given something, and that the something had edges he couldn't see, and that he was going to say yes before he knew what the edges were.
"Okay," he said.
"Yes?"
"Yes."
Arthur picked up the bread basket and finally took a roll. "Good," he said, and broke it in half.