The Term of Kinship

Chapter 54: The Review Findings

The review board's hearing room was smaller than Vera had expected for a body that could decide the shape of Lila's life, a converted conference room on the fourth floor of the state family court building with a long table, eight chairs, and a window that looked onto an airshaft. Frost sat at the head. Two other reviewers flanked her, a pediatric ethicist named Okonjo and a retired appellate judge named Barrow. A court reporter's fingers hovered. No gallery, no cameras, no press. Only the parties.

Vera and Nolan sat on one side of the table with their attorney, a lean Omega woman named Sasha Rios who had taken the case for the price of the filing fee and the promise that Vera would never lie to her. On the other side sat Cecilia Marchetti in a dove-gray suit, her own counsel beside her, and behind them a woman Vera had never seen before in a black blazer with a Helix Well visitor's badge on a lanyard.

"Before we take appearances," Frost said, "I want to note for the record that this board received a written submission from Helix Well Biosciences at seven-forty this morning. Counsel, are you here to move for intervention?"

The woman in the black blazer stood. "I am. Helix Well has a direct interest in the validity of the placement instrument at issue and in the confidentiality of its proprietary protocols. We move to intervene and to seal."

"Noted and held," Frost said. "Ms. Rios, Mr. Chen, Ms. Marchetti. You've all received the preliminary findings?"

"We have," Sasha said.

Frost opened a folder. "Then I'll read the operative conclusions into the record and explain what they mean, because I don't want anyone in this room to walk out of here with a misapprehension."

She read.

*First.* The compatibility instrument commonly called the match test, developed by Helix Well under license from the family court system and used in this jurisdiction for eleven years, was not a validated psychometric or biological instrument. It had never been peer-reviewed. Its internal validity coefficients, where they existed, were below any threshold a professional body would accept. In plain terms, the report said, the test did not measure what it claimed to measure, and no placement decision in the state should rest on it.

Nolan's hand, under the table, found Vera's and held it.

*Second.* Beginning no later than the prior fiscal year, data generated by the administration of the match test — including the responses, the family compositions, the biological sex and secondary-gender markers, and the identifying metadata of every child and guardian assessed — had been exported and sold to Helix Well's commercial partners, at least three of which operated in the insurance and consumer-lending sectors. The consent forms signed by guardians did not disclose the sale. The board had forwarded this finding to the state attorney general.

The black blazer wrote something down. She did not look up.

*Third.* The specific assessment prepared for the placement of L. Marchetti-Chen had been altered after the fact. The board accepted Mr. Nolan Chen's account of the alteration, made under penalty and against his own interest, and credited his cooperation. The underlying data, when reconstructed from the vendor's own backup by the board's forensic examiner, did not support the adverse recommendation. It supported, in the board's considered view, the continued placement of the child with Ms. Vera Chen and Mr. Nolan Chen.

*Fourth.* In light of the above, the board recommended that the Superior Court decline to disturb the current placement, and further recommended that the placement proceed under a remedial guardianship plan to be designed by this board and reviewed at ninety-day intervals for the first year. The plan would include quarterly home visits, a mandated parenting curriculum for both guardians, and a requirement that any material change in either guardian's household be reported within ten days. The board's recommendation was advisory. The final decision belonged to the judge.

Frost closed the folder. "Ms. Marchetti. You filed a petition for visitation. Do you wish to be heard?"

Cecilia Marchetti looked at her lawyer, then at Vera. For a moment the room held still. Vera had spent four months building a case against this woman in her head, and now Cecilia's face was doing something Vera had not budgeted for. It was tired. It was the face of someone who had run out of a story she had been telling herself.

"I withdraw the petition," Cecilia said. "Your Honor — Dr. Frost. I'd like to say why."

"Please."

"I filed because I believed the test. I was told it was science. My son is dead, and I wanted a reason. I wanted a reason that didn't require me to look at what I actually did, which was to keep my distance from him because he married an Alpha, and that was shameful to me, and I couldn't say that to anyone, so I said the test instead." She paused. She did not cry, and Vera respected her for that. "I am not Lila's grandmother. I have no business in that child's life unless she wants me in it when she's old enough to say so. I withdraw."

"Counselor?" Frost said.

"Withdrawn," Cecilia's lawyer said, and sat down.

"That's accepted," Frost said. "The petition is dismissed without prejudice."

The black blazer stood again. "Dr. Frost, Helix Well still moves to intervene. The board's second finding — the data finding — rests on documents Helix Well disputes. We ask for a hearing on the data question before the board transmits any referral to the attorney general."

"Denied," Frost said. "The referral is not yours to contest in this forum. If you want a hearing, you may have one in front of a judge."

"Then we'll take it to a judge," the woman said, evenly. "Helix Well will move to intervene in the Superior Court case. We'll argue that the match test is a clinical instrument, not a legal determinant, and that the data was anonymized and therefore not subject to the disclosures the board is implying. We'll ask that the board's findings be stayed pending our motion."

Frost did not react. "You'll have your hearing. I'll see to it."

The clerk cleared her throat. "Judge Halloran has availability four weeks from today, the fourteenth, for a final hearing on placement and any motions to intervene. Counsel, please confirm."

Sasha glanced at Vera. Vera nodded. "Confirmed for the respondents," Sasha said.

"Confirmed for the petitioner," Cecilia's lawyer said.

"Helix Well will be there," the black blazer said.

Frost stood, and everyone stood. "Four weeks," she said. "The remedial plan will be circulated within ten business days. Mr. Chen, Ms. Chen." She looked at them a beat longer than she looked at the others. "You did the right thing in this room last week. I want you to know that the board's recommendation takes that into account. It is not a reward. It's a factual finding. You told the truth and the record reflects it."

"Thank you, Dr. Frost," Nolan said.

They filed out. In the corridor, Cecilia's counsel went one way and Cecilia went the other, and Vera watched her go and felt, unexpectedly, nothing. Not forgiveness. Not triumph. Just the flat, clean absence of an enemy she'd been carrying.

"She dropped it," Nolan said, as if he needed to hear it again.

"She dropped it," Vera said.

"That means the only thing left in front of the judge is us." He looked at her. "And Helix Well."

"And Helix Well." She pulled out her phone. The 11-C response was due to the Securities Division in nine days. The forensic examiner's report on the match test was now part of a state attorney general referral. Her own on-record admission from last week was a line in that referral's appendix, sitting there under her name, waiting for somebody at the division to connect it to the disclosure she'd been terminated for.

She put the phone away.

"Vera," Nolan said. "If the judge stays Frost's findings while Helix Well argues, the remedial plan doesn't start. No home visits, no curriculum. The placement goes back to provisional. Four weeks of provisional, with an intervenor in the case. That's not the same as us losing. But it's not the same as us winning either."

"No," Vera said. "It's not."

"Four weeks," he said.

"Four weeks," she said.

They walked out into the afternoon light on Centre Street, past the vendor selling pretzels and the man selling umbrellas, toward the subway, and neither of them said it out loud: that a company whose shares she still held, in a fund that had already fired her, was about to stand up in front of a judge and argue that the instrument that had nearly taken Lila from them was nothing more than a clinical tool.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 54: The Review Findings · The Term of Kinship · Lumen Reads