The courtroom was smaller than the one where the guardianship petition had been argued, a chancery courtroom on the eighth floor with bad air and a radiator that ticked. Vera sat in the second row with her hands folded, which was what she did now instead of checking her phone, because there was no phone to check.
Nolan stood at the lectern. He had a legal pad and one pen. He'd refused to let Sam Idris sit with him as counsel of record.
Judge Halloran let Helix Well's attorney go first, which was the courtesy of the court to a moving party, and the attorney—a tall Beta woman named Priya Raghavan in a gray suit that had been tailored somewhere that charged for it—used all of it.
"Your Honor, Helix Well is a diagnostics company. We licensed a proprietary algorithm. Clinicians used it to estimate compatibility. That is a clinical tool, not a legal determinant. Now a professional disciplinary board has issued preliminary findings that mischaracterize our product, adopt an unverified claim of a data sale, and threaten a regulatory cascade against a company that has not been charged with anything." Raghavan set a binder on the lectern. "We move to intervene so we can be heard before the findings harden. And we ask that the board's findings be stayed pending our motion."
"Ms. Raghavan," Halloran said, "your product was the basis for a placement determination that this court, in reliance on it, made. You understand my concern."
"I do. And the answer is that our contracts with the placement agencies expressly state the score is advisory. If the agencies treated it as a threshold, that is an agency decision." She paused, one beat, the pause of someone who had done this many times. "The data was anonymized, Your Honor. Fully de-identified before any transfer. There is no privacy interest left to vindicate."
"Who did you sell it to?" Nolan asked. He was on his feet before the judge invited him, and he caught himself and said, "Sorry. May I respond?"
"Sit down, Mr. Osei, you're across the room from the lectern," Halloran said. "You have the floor."
Nolan walked to the lectern. He looked tired in the way that means a person has been reading until two in the morning, which Vera knew he had been. He had a single sheet of paper.
"Your Honor, I'd like to examine their expert. Dr. Hollis."
Raghavan's head came up. "Dr. Hollis is present. We anticipated this."
She was small and precise, seventy-one years old, with a note on her CV that read *twenty-two peer-reviewed publications on reidentification risk*. Nolan had found her on Saturday, and Vera had watched him find her, because she'd been in the kitchen making coffee and he had said, out loud, to no one, "There it is."
"Dr. Hollis," Nolan said. "You filed a declaration saying the data was de-identified and cannot be re-identified."
"That's correct."
"On what basis?"
"On the basis of my review of the transfer documentation and standard industry practice. The identifiers – name, address, Social Security number, date of birth – were stripped before transfer."
"Were they hashed?"
"They were removed."
"Would you agree that hashing and removing are different things?"
"I'd agree they're different techniques."
"Which one did Helix Well use?"
"I reviewed the documentation they provided me." Dr. Hollis looked at Raghavan. Raghavan gave her nothing. "I believe they removed the identifiers."
"You believe."
"I reviewed the documentation."
Nolan put the sheet of paper on the lectern and smoothed it flat with one hand. "Your Honor, I have a printout from the public disclosures page of Meridian Mutual, a health insurer headquartered in Ohio. It lists the outside experts compensated by Meridian's Clinical Evidence Council in the last fiscal year. On page four, in alphabetical order: Hollis, Judith P., MD, MPH. Thirty-eight thousand dollars."
The radiator ticked twice.
Raghavan was up. "Your Honor, experts routinely consult for multiple parties. This is not a conflict."
"It is if Meridian is the buyer," Nolan said. He didn't raise his voice. Vera had learned, in a year of watching him, that he never did. "Meridian Mutual is one of four insurers that placed a rate adjustment program in front of the New York Department of Financial Services five months ago. Their filing relied in part on actuarial data derived from prenatal compatibility scores. Dr. Hollis, did you know that Meridian buys the dataset?"
"I know Meridian has purchased de-identified clinical data in the past."
"Did you know they purchased this one?"
"I was not told the specific vendor."
"Did you ask?"
Silence.
"When you wrote that the data was anonymized and could not be re-identified," Nolan said, "and you did not disclose that your principal client was also the purchaser, did it occur to you that a court might have wanted to know that?"
"Objection," Raghavan said. "Argumentative."
"Sustained," Halloran said. He turned to Dr. Hollis anyway. "But I'll ask you the same question, Doctor. Did it occur to you?"
Dr. Hollis folded her hands. "I was engaged to review the de-identification methodology. I did that. I did not consider my other engagement relevant to the methodology."
"It's relevant to me," Halloran said.
Vera felt her own pulse in her throat and deliberately slowed her breathing. She had spent fourteen years sitting in rooms where a person's credibility dissolved in real time, and she had learned that the moment was always quieter than people expected. Dr. Hollis's hands were steady. That was what made it land.
"Mr. Osei," Halloran said. "What are you asking for?"
"Production," Nolan said. "The transfer agreements, the license agreements, the rate-adjustment program documents—any contract between Helix Well and any insurer or actuarial firm that used the scores. Unredacted as to scope and consideration. And Dr. Hollis's engagement letters, both of them."
"Ms. Raghavan."
"Your Honor, we're not a party to the Meridian agreements. And the Helix Well contracts are commercially sensitive."
"Then I'll take them under seal and read them myself," Halloran said. He was writing. "You have two weeks. Certified copies, everything, and if anything is redacted you file the redaction log under separate cover and I decide whether the redaction stands. If I find that a contract you hold ties a score to a premium, I will be extremely displeased with everyone in this room."
"Our motion to stay—"
"Denied." He didn't look up. "The board's findings stand. The remedial guardianship plan proceeds. Produce the documents, Ms. Raghavan, or I will find someone at your company who can."
Raghavan stood very still for a moment, then sat down and began writing on her own pad with a pen that she clicked once, sharply, before she wrote.
Nolan came back to the row and sat down beside Vera. His hands were shaking a little, the fine tremor of a body that had been holding still against adrenaline. He set them flat on his legal pad and let them shake.
"Two weeks is fast," Vera said quietly.
"Halloran doesn't like being used," Nolan said.
"In the gallery," Vera said, "second row from the back, left side."
He turned his head the way a person does when they don't want anyone to know they're turning their head.
Dr. Frost was sitting alone at the end of a bench with her canvas bag on her knees. She was not smiling broadly, because she was not a woman who did that. But the corners of her mouth had come up, and stayed up, and she was writing in a small spiral notebook with a kind of brisk pleasure, as if she'd just watched a thing she'd waited eleven years for.
Vera caught her eye. Dr. Frost nodded once, a small movement, and went back to her notebook.
"Okay," Nolan said. "Okay." He was still shaking. "Sam's going to want a statement by tomorrow. And I need to look at what Meridian's rate filing actually says before somebody else does, because if the clause is in there—"
"It isn't in there," Vera said. "You don't put a clause like that in a public filing. You put it in the contract and reference the filing."
He looked at her.
"You worked in this industry for fourteen years," she said. "I know where the bodies are buried. The question is whether the bodies are in paper."
"Two weeks," Nolan said again, and this time it sounded like a different sentence. "Vera, if they produce a contract linking score adjustments to premiums—"
"Then it's not a clinical tool anymore."
"Then it's insurance pricing built on a test that was rigged, sold to the exact people who charged by it, and we've been arguing about whether it's a legal determinant when the actual question was who got paid." He picked up his pen and put it down. "Sam's article was about the forgery. This is bigger and it's not about me at all."
Behind them, the door opened and closed as people began to leave. Raghavan was on her phone in the well of the court, speaking rapidly, one hand cupped around her mouth.
"Four weeks to the final hearing," Vera said. "And fifteen days to my 11-C response. If Halloran reads a premium clause into the record before the Securities Division does—"
She stopped, because she'd heard it at the same moment he had. Raghavan had turned, phone still at her ear, and was looking straight at Vera across the empty courtroom, and there was something new in her face: not hostility. Arithmetic.
"She knows who you are," Nolan said.
"She knows whose carried interest is frozen," Vera said. "And she knows what a state AG does with a company that sold a lie and charged by the lie." She picked up her coat. "Get me the Meridian filing. I'll find the clause."