The Tide-Token

Chapter 10: What Cáel Forgot

The cave mouth breathed salt and rot behind them, and Cáel walked out of it like a man carrying a full glass he couldn't set down.

Niamh kept three paces back. The net-weights were wrapped in her jumper, bundled against her ribs, and the fifth—the wrong one—sat against her sternum like a stone that had been pulled out of deep water and never warmed. She'd stopped expecting it to.

They followed the tide line south. Gravel, then sand, then gravel again. Muirín's cave shrank to a smear of black on the cliff and was gone.

"Say it," Cáel said.

"Say what."

"You've been walking behind me for twenty minutes like I'm something that might turn around."

She came level with him. His profile was the same as it had been an hour ago—straight nose, the small scar through one eyebrow, hair wet from the cave spray. She had memorised that face across nine months for no reason she was willing to name, and now she was studying it like a page she'd have to hand back.

"How does it feel?" she said.

"Gone." He said it flat, the way you'd report weather. "It's a gap. I know there's supposed to be something in it. I know the shape of the thing that's missing. I just can't—" He gestured vaguely at his own chest, gave up on the gesture. "It's like reaching for a name."

"What was it?"

"My first kiss." He said it easily. That was the awful part. "Muirín took it. It's in a jar on a shelf now, I expect."

"No." Niamh stopped walking.

He stopped a step later and turned.

"I mean what was it *about*." She made herself say it. "Who."

"Ah." Cáel looked out at the sea. The light was going copper over Inis Mór and the water was doing that late-evening thing where it looked like it was being poured rather than moving. "I should be able to answer that. I can tell you the frame of it. It was November. There was a boat, and someone laughing so hard they went over the gunwale, and I caught them by the wrist and—that's it. That's all that's left. It's like a story I was told about someone else."

"And the person?"

"Someone from before." He frowned, not at Niamh, at the middle distance. "I can't see her."

"You can't see her," Niamh repeated.

"I can't see her at all. I try to put a face on it and there's nothing there. Just the fact of a face." He picked up a flat stone and didn't throw it. "It's funny. I remember being angry about losing it. I remember thinking, stupid, I remember thinking *this will be worse than I can—*"

He stopped. The stone was still in his hand. He turned it over, and over, and then went very still.

"Cáel."

"I can't see my mother," he said.

Niamh's blood went to her feet.

"I can't." He wasn't looking at her. He was looking at the stone. "I can remember she was tall. I remember she used to take the salt off the windows in winter. I remember her hands. I know what the memory tastes like—I know it was there, I know I used to be able to—"

He shut his eyes.

"I don't know what her face looked like."

The wind went through the grass on the ridge above. Somewhere behind them a gull was arguing with another gull. Niamh could not make herself say anything for a long moment, and in that long moment she understood precisely what Muirín had done, because Muirín had said it out loud and neither of them had heard it: *a first-kiss memory*. Fine. Small. Cheap. And what is a first kiss, exactly, in a mind as old as his? What's tangled in it? Whose face was she wearing when he kissed her?

There was no such thing as a small memory. That was the trick. A first kiss has a face on it, and the face belongs to the first person you ever wanted, and if you are a man who has been alive eight hundred years, the first person you ever wanted was standing in a kitchen on a winter morning scrubbing salt off the glass.

"You traded me your mother," Niamh said.

"I traded you a kiss." His voice had gone thin. "I didn't know it would—"

"No. You didn't." She put her hand on his arm and he flinched like she'd come at him with a blade, which she supposed was accurate enough. "Cáel. Look at me."

He looked at her. Grey eyes, no wetness in them. That was somehow worse than tears.

"Tell me what you've still got."

"Her name. I've got her name. Éibhlin." He said it like a man reciting a line he hadn't checked in years. "I've got that she used to sing off-key on purpose to make my father laugh. I've got that she was afraid of the dark and wouldn't admit it and made me sleep with the door open until I was forty." A breath. "I've got everything except the part where I know what she looked like."

"You've got more than most people get," Niamh said, and knew as she said it that it was the wrong thing, and knew it was true anyway, and hated both facts.

"Yes," Cáel said. "That's been true of me a long time."

He dropped the stone.

They walked.

Niamh carried the weights and tried not to think about the one against her sternum. It was cold in a way the others weren't. The four silver weights from the Kinvara shrine had gone warm in her hands within a minute, the way anything of the sea-trade does when it recognises kin. The fifth had stayed cold. Not the cold of metal in evening air—the cold of a thing that has decided not to know you.

A net-weight whose net she'd never seen. A fifth in a set of four. Muirín had let her buy it. Muirín had let her buy *all* of it, which meant either the sea-witch had been beaten, or the sea-witch was still selling.

"What happens now?" Cáel said. "The net?"

"Dún Aonghasa. The boat shrine under the west wall." She'd done the reading years ago, an undergraduate essay on coastal votive deposits, and the memory was sandy and vague and she wanted to lie down on the beach and sleep for a year. "The weights were supposed to hold the shrine-net on its pegs. If I put them back—"

"You think the net comes back."

"I think the thief wanted the net, and took its anchors so it couldn't be raised."

Cáel nodded slowly. "That's clever. That's not how a thief thinks."

"How does a thief think?"

"He takes the thing he wants." He was scanning the horizon automatically now, the way he did—gatekeeper's habit, checking for rifts in the light. "Someone took the anchors and left the net. Someone wanted it to stay down."

Niamh felt the fifth weight go a degree colder against her skin, which she would have sworn was not possible in the open air.

She said, "How much further?"

"Two hours along the shore. We'll shelter under the cliffs near Dún Eoghanachta."

"Right." She shifted the bundle in her jumper. "I'll carry these. Don't ask."

"Niamh."

"Don't."

He looked at her. He had a look he did—very steady, very patient, the expression of a man who has waited out sieges and high tides and worse—and it had never bothered her before, and it bothered her now because she was lying to him and he was choosing not to notice.

"All right," he said.

They walked south along the flat sand. The sun went behind Black Head and the sky went from copper to grey and the sea turned the colour of a bruise. Niamh counted her steps for a while and then stopped counting.

Muirín had taken his mother's face and left him the name, which meant the sea-witch could put a shape on the loss and hand it back or sell it on, and if she had the face she had a handle. That was what Muirín did. She had the rosary, which was decades of a mortal woman's love with a person attached, and she had a first kiss with a mother's face attached, and she'd called the rosary *a key that opens people*, and Niamh understood suddenly and completely that they had not paid a price in Muirín's cave.

They had put two more keys in a lock someone else was holding.

She thought about saying it. She thought about the fifth weight and the way it refused her, and the fact that she'd already not said it twice today, and that each not-saying made the last one easier, and she thought: *if I tell him now, in the dark, on the sand, with his mother's face gone, he will go back for it, and I don't know what he'll be when he does.*

So she kept the bundle against her ribs and kept walking.

Behind them, far back along the coast, a bell rang.

Niamh's skin went tight. It was not midday. It was not even an hour anyone counted out loud. It rang once, and once only, the way bells do when they're not ringing for anybody, and Cáel stopped dead in the sand and did not turn around, and did not offer to explain, and Niamh—looking at the back of his head, at the shoulders she'd watched walk out of a cave an hour ago—counted the rings she'd heard since Kilcorney and came up one short of a pattern, and asked the only question that mattered.

"Cáel. Whose bell is that?"

He didn't answer.

He started walking again, faster.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 10: What Cáel Forgot · The Tide-Token · Lumen Reads