They came for Cáel at dawn, and they did not knock.
Niamh woke to the smell of salt and hawthorn and something older, colder—wet stone, grave-cold. Three figures stood in the mouth of the cave where they'd sheltered, and the light behind them was not the light of the rising sun. It was a flat silver, like the underside of a wave, and it did not move when the wind moved.
Cáel was already on his feet. He had put himself between Niamh and the door before she'd fully opened her eyes, and that told her more than any words.
"Bríd," he said. "You're early."
"Time is a courtesy we extend to those who keep it," the woman in the centre said. She was tall and narrow, dressed in grey that held no water though the sea-spray hung in the air, and her face was pleasant in the way a smooth stone is pleasant—agreeable until you try to grip it. "Cáel mac Éibhlin. You are summoned. You and the mortal."
"The mortal has a name," Niamh said, getting up. Her back ached from sleeping on rock. She kept her voice level. "And she doesn't take orders from people who walk into her shelter uninvited."
Bríd looked at her then, and Niamh felt the look the way you feel cold water finding a seam in your boot. "You signed a geis, Niamh O'Connell. That makes you ours to summon and ours to answer for. The uninvited clause does not apply."
"Then say what you want."
"Come," Bríd said. "The court is not here."
The crossing took less time than walking out of the cave had. There was a door in the cliff where there had been no door, and behind it a hall lit by lamps that burned with a blue-green flame, and in the hall eleven seats arranged in a half-circle, ten of them filled. Niamh counted twice. Ten present, one empty, and no one looked at the empty one.
Cáel stood beside her with his hands loose at his sides. She had learned to read that looseness. It was the stillness of a man ready to move, exactly as still as he was dangerous.
Bríd took the centre seat. She did not sit so much as let the chair receive her.
"Cáel mac Éibhlin, gatekeeper of the western threshold. You have walked with a mortal under contract for three months of our time. You have touched the Kinvara nets, the shrine-weights, and the fourth relic without leave. You have been seen in the market at Kilcorney bargaining with a known thief."
"I was buying back what was stolen," Cáel said.
"You were seen on the coast with Muirín." Bríd's voice did not rise. It did not need to. "You gave the sea-witch a memory. That is not theft. That is not trade. That is a gift, and gifts have a price."
"I gave her what she asked."
"You gave her a key." The councilor to Bríd's left—a stout man with barnacle-crusted brows and fingers like roots—spoke without being invited. "Muirín holds two keys now. The mortal's rosary and your memory. She can open either door, and you stand in both rooms."
Niamh stepped forward before Cáel could answer. "You're the council. You enforce the contracts. So enforce them. The thief is still out there—"
"The thief was human," Bríd said.
The hall went quiet in a way that had nothing to do with sound.
"You know who it was," Niamh said.
"We know what it was." Bríd folded her hands. "The shrine at Kinvara held four silver net-weights. In 1898 a fisherman named Tadhg Ó Ruairc cut one from the net and sold it to a collector in Galway. In 1974 a woman named Mairead ní Dhomhnaill took two from the shrine by night and buried them in a field she did not own. In 2003 a boy of nineteen, name of Declan Quinn, stole the fourth because he thought the shrine was a wishing well and the weights were lucky stones. Three thefts. Three nights."
"And each of you was gatekeeper on that night," the barnacled councilor said. "Every door those humans walked through—you held it."
Niamh turned and looked at Cáel.
He had not moved. His face was the careful blank she had seen him use on bargains, and that blankness frightened her more than any expression would have.
"Answer," Niamh said.
"I held the doors," Cáel said.
"You let them through."
"I did not stop them."
"That's not the same thing. You're the gatekeeper. You could have stopped them. You didn't."
"No."
Niamh felt the floor of her understanding drop an inch. She had been walking the coast for weeks with this man. He had traded his mother's face for her. He had given up something he could not get back, and she had believed—what? That he was simply unlucky? That the council had failed him?
"Why not?" she said. Her voice came out wrong, sharper than she meant, and she did not correct it. "Three times. A hundred years. Why did you let three humans walk into a shrine and take the relics you were set to guard?"
Cáel looked at Bríd. Bríd looked at him. Something passed between them that Niamh could not read, and that, more than anything else, made her want to hit something.
"Answer the mortal," Bríd said. "She is entitled to the truth under the contract."
There was a long pause. Then Cáel said, quietly, "Because the court required it."
The blue-green lamps guttered. The ten councilors sat very still.
"Explain," Niamh said.
"I cannot."
"Then I demand—"
"You cannot demand it either." Bríd's voice cut through clean. "The terms under which the gatekeeper served are sealed. You may ask him. He may answer with what he is permitted to answer. What he is permitted to answer is: he was placed at each threshold on the night of each theft, and the relics passed through his hands, and he did not prevent them. That is the fact. The why of it is not yours."
"Not mine," Niamh said. "Not his. Who, then?"
Bríd smiled. It was a very small movement, and it did not reach her eyes, and Niamh marked it.
"That is not your concern either. What is your concern is the net. You have all five weights?"
"Four," Niamh said.
The lie came out smooth, and she was ashamed of how smooth it came. The fifth weight sat in the inner pocket of her coat, cold and wrong and clicking faintly against the others whenever she walked. She had not told Cáel. She did not intend to tell Bríd.
"Four," Bríd repeated. "And one missing."
"The fifth belongs to Muirín."
"The fifth has always belonged to Muirín. That is why it was hidden in the shrine net—to keep it out of her hands. And you gave her a door." Bríd turned her gaze to Cáel. "You should have let the mortal's memory go. You had no right to pay her toll."
"He had every right," Niamh said. "It was my contract. My memory. He paid it for me because I told him to."
"You told him to give up his own memory?"
"I told him not to hand her mine. He chose."
"Then he chose poorly." Bríd rose. "The court finds no violation in the mortal's conduct. She signed in good faith and she has served her term. The gatekeeper's conduct is a matter for the court, and the court will consider it. Until then, Cáel mac Éibhlin, you will remain under the mortal's contract supervision—you will guide her to the shrine and restore what was taken. After that, you will answer to us."
"For what?" Niamh said.
"For the doors he held open," Bríd said.
They were walked out. The door in the cliff closed behind them like a stone sinking into water, and then there was only the Burren and the wind and the sea breathing.
Niamh stood with her back to the rock for a while. Cáel stood a few feet away, facing the water, and did not look at her.
"Nineteen twenty-eight," Niamh said finally. "Your mother's name was Éibhlin. You told me that."
"Yes."
"Bríd knew your father's name. She called you 'mac Éibhlin' like it was a title. How old are you, Cáel?"
He was quiet for a moment. "Old enough that the century you call stolen is a morning I remember."
"And in 1898 you let a fisherman take a shrine-weight."
"Yes."
"Because the court required it."
"Yes."
"So the court ordered the thefts."
"I did not say that."
"You didn't have to." Niamh pulled the fifth weight from her pocket. It lay in her palm, cold, wrong, not warming to her hand the way the others did, and she held it up so he could see. "I've lied to you for a week. This is the fifth one. Muirín's. It was in the shrine net with the others, and it's cold and it doesn't answer to me, and I think the thief didn't steal from the shrine. I think the thief stole *to* the shrine. Someone put that weight back."
Cáel looked at the weight. He did not look surprised. That, more than anything, told her she was right.
"It rings," he said. "The bell you heard on the coast."
"It wasn't a bell."
"No."
"Whose was it?"
Cáel turned to the sea, and the wind moved his hair, and for a moment his face was the face of a man standing where he had stood for a hundred years.
"Belongs to the one who set the doors," he said. "And we are not going to talk about it until we're at the shrine."
He started walking. Niamh stood with the cold weight in her hand and watched him go, and the bell she had heard once—no, the bell she had heard *before*, on a cliff she could not name—rang again, small and clear, somewhere behind them, and Cáel did not turn around.
She put the weight back in her pocket, where it did not warm, and followed.