The cold hit her first, then the sound came back — the roar of the swell dragging off the rocks, the gulls, her own heartbeat slamming in her ears.
Niamh's knees hit the wet stone. Her hand was still out, reaching, salt water running off her fingers in ropes. Below her, the sea chewed at the base of the cliffs where it had just swallowed her sister whole.
The stranger stood at the water's edge. He had not come up out of the foam so much as been there already, the way a rock is there when the tide pulls back. Green eyes, the exact green of deep water over sand. Barefoot on stone that would have cut anyone else open. He looked at her like he had been waiting a long time and had only just decided to be patient a little longer.
"Say it again," he said. His voice was low and unhurried, and it cut through the noise of the sea like it didn't have to try.
"What?"
"What you said just now. To the water. To whatever was listening." He tilted his head. "Say it again, and mean it."
Niamh's mouth was dry with salt and fear. She had screamed something into the wind, she couldn't even remember the shape of it — *take anything, take me, just not her* — the words a person throws out because throwing them is the only thing left to do.
"Please," she said, because that was the truth of it. "Save my sister."
He crouched. She hadn't seen him decide to; he was simply lower now, closer, and she could see something old behind his face, something that had stopped counting years a long time ago.
"You're a folklorist," he said.
She stared at him.
"You walked thirty people down to the causeway this morning and told them the story of the Cailleach's bridge, and you got the version with the third sister wrong, and I let you." He smiled, very faintly. "I know what you are. I want you to know that I know. That matters, for what comes next."
"You were on the walk?"
"I was watching the walk." He looked out at the churning water where Saoirse had gone under. "Your sister has perhaps ninety seconds. Perhaps less. The riptide will carry her out past the third rock and the cold will finish what the current starts. I can reach her. I can put her back on the sand with the breath still in her."
The world had gone very narrow and very bright. Niamh heard her own voice come out flat. "How much."
"One year."
"One year of what?"
"Of service." He stood, and now he was holding something — a flat slab of dark slate, wet as if it had come out of the sea, and a thin nail of something that wasn't metal. "You will come with me at low water. You will go where I send you and you will bring back what was taken. Three things. Three relics, stolen from a shrine older than your town, and each one has to go back to the sea gate it was cut from. That is the task. That is the whole of it."
Niamh looked down the cliffs at the water, at the empty churn of it, and Saoirse was in there, Saoirse who was twenty and afraid of deep water and had only come on the walk because she'd wanted to see her sister be clever.
"What happens after the year?"
"You come back." He said it easily. "The year ends and you come home and you remember it the way you remember any bad week."
"That's a lie," she said. "You don't speak like a thing that tells the truth."
Something moved in his face — appreciation, maybe, or grief, so quick she'd have missed it if she weren't already looking for lies. "It is not a lie. It is not the whole truth. That is not the same thing."
"Then tell me the whole truth."
"Sign first."
"N—"
"Your sister is drowning, Niamh O'Connell. I have been polite because I am owed politeness. Do not mistake it for the way I will always be."
He held out the slate.
She looked at it. Wet black stone, and on its face a line drawn in something that was already drying — a spiral, or a coil, or an eye. The nail in his other hand was white, bone, worn to a point.
"Put your hand on the mark," he said. "Repeat what I say. And then you put your mouth to the sea and you seal it, because that is how a geis is kept on this coast. Salt for the words. Stone for the memory."
"Tell me the whole truth first."
"Sign it and you'll have three hundred and sixty-five days to find out how much of it I hold back." He was already turning toward the water. "Decide. She does not have long."
Niamh put her hand on the slate.
It was cold enough to hurt, and the spiral under her palm felt wrong, like pressing your hand flat on a moving thing. The green-eyed stranger crouched beside her and set the bone point against the stone.
"Repeat. *I am Niamh O'Connell, of Galway, and this year belongs to the gate.*"
Her voice shook. "I am Niamh O'Connell, of Galway, and this year belongs to the gate."
The nail moved. A second line, curling outward from the first.
"*I will go at low water and I will not return until the gate is whole.*"
"I will go at low water and I will not return until the gate is whole."
Third line. Fourth. The spiral was closing on itself, or opening — she couldn't tell, and looking at it made her eyes ache.
"*Three relics, three returns, and no rest until they are given back to the sea.*"
She said it. The wet slate warmed under her palm, which was the thing that frightened her most of all, because nothing about this should be warm.
The stranger lifted the slate to her mouth. "Seal it."
She turned her head and pressed her lips to the flat of the stone. Saltwater hit her tongue, far more than the slab could have held — a mouthful of the whole sea, cold and mineral and alive, and she swallowed it because she had said she would.
The slate cracked.
Not broke — cracked, along a seam she hadn't seen, and settled into two pieces that still fit together, and the lines she'd repeated were now scored into the stone in a hand that looked like hers, if she'd ever written in something that bled.
The stranger stood and walked past her to the cliff edge, and without any ceremony at all, without even looking, he stepped off into the drop.
Niamh screamed and crawled to the edge on her hands and knees.
She got there in time to see him on the water forty feet below. Standing on it. The swell ran under his feet and did not move him. He turned his face up to her once, and then he put his hand into the sea like a person reaching into a pocket, and he drew her sister out.
Saoirse came up onto the rock ledge the way a caught fish comes up — boneless, limp, water pouring off her. The stranger laid her down with his ear to her chest, and Niamh watched him do something with his hand at her throat, one sharp motion, and then Saoirse convulsed and seawater came out of her mouth in a rush and she pulled a breath in after it, ragged and wet and *real*.
Niamh was already running down, slipping on the wet steps, taking them three at a time, screaming her sister's name.
By the time she hit the lower path Saoirse was dragging herself onto her elbows, coughing so hard her whole body shook, her lips grey-blue, her hair a wreck of kelp and salt. Niamh got her arms around her and pulled her up off the stone and held on.
"Jesus — Jesus, Saoirse —"
"I'm —" Saoirse coughed again, spat, wiped her mouth with the back of her wrist. "What — how did I —"
"Don't talk."
"What *happened*?" Saoirse's eyes were wild, flicking past Niamh's shoulder up the cliff. "There was — something in the water, Niamh, there was something that *grabbed* me —"
"There wasn't."
"There *was*—"
"There wasn't." Niamh pressed her sister's wet head against her collarbone and stared at the ledge behind her. Empty. The water ran off the rocks in thin silver lines. No barefoot man. No slate. Nothing but the gulls complaining overhead and the normal indifferent hiss of the tide going out.
She could still taste the sea in her mouth. That, at least, hadn't left.
They sat there maybe ten minutes. Saoirse shook the whole time and Niamh held her and said nothing true, and by the time the tide had pulled back enough to show the black weed on the middle rocks, Saoirse could stand, with help. A couple of walkers coming up the path from Doolin saw them and came running; one had a phone, one had a coat. There were questions. Niamh answered the easy ones. *Slipped on the causeway. Something knocked her in. I got down to her.* She heard her own voice do it cleanly, and she thought: I used to be a person who couldn't lie.
The low water was at twenty past nine that night.
She knew, because she'd built her whole degree around the tides out here. She noticed, sitting on the ambulance bench with a foil blanket over her shoulders while a paramedic checked her hands, that the slick of weed on the causeway was already showing at the base of the cliffs, the way it only did in the last hour before the ebb. She noticed, and then she thought about it deliberately, and she knew what she was doing when she did.
At half eight she walked Saoirse to their aunt's in Lisdoonvarna and promised she'd be an hour behind. She said she needed to call the university about the walk. She said it in that same clean voice. Her sister, still shaking, not yet able to look at the sea, let her go.
At quarter past nine Niamh stood on the wet stone below the cliffs with her shoes in her hand and her jeans rolled to the knee.
She told herself she was here to see if he'd come back. She knew that wasn't true. She was here because her mouth still tasted of salt that wasn't from any sea she'd swum in, and because there was a thing under her breastbone that had been cold since the moment she signed, and because she had repeated the words *I will go at low water* and the words had gone into her like seed, and now they were rooting.
The tide pulled back. The water exposed the lower ledge she hadn't seen from the top of the cliff — the long flat apron of stone, gleaming, laid out like a floor. On it, at the far end, where no apron should be, there was a gap in the rock that let into darkness, and the darkness had a smell to it: cold iron, and moss, and the sea a long way from any beach.
Cáel stood beside the gap with his hands loose at his sides, green eyes catching what little light was left, and he looked at her for a long moment without saying anything at all.
"You came earlier than I expected," he said finally.
"I'm not here because you expected me."
"No," he agreed. "You're here because it's low water. Sit down. Take off your shoes. The rest of the way is barefoot."
She did. She set her shoes on the stone next to her, side by side, neat the way she'd been taught, and then she looked up at the last grey stripe of sky and thought about how there was a version of her from that morning who was still on the top of the cliff, still telling a story about the Cailleach's bridge, still getting the third sister wrong.
That version was gone. There was no road back to her from the bottom of these particular cliffs.
"Three relics," she said. "Who took them?"
Cáel's face did not change. "That," he said, "is the first thing you will need to find out for yourself."
He turned and walked into the dark of the gap, and the stone closed around the sound of his feet, and Niamh stood for one more second on the lip of it with the sea cold around her ankles — and then she followed him in.