The Unbinding

Chapter 11: What the Shrink Said

The waiting room was two chairs and a ficus that had given up. Benjamin sat with his coat across his knees because the armrests were too narrow for it and the floor was the kind of beige carpet that showed every footprint, and he didn't want to leave one.

"He's running late," Nicolas said. "He's always running late."

"You've been here before."

"Four years." Nicolas turned his phone face-down on his thigh, then face-up again. "Since I started sleeping with the lights on."

Benjamin didn't say anything. The clock was a real mechanism, not a screen, and it ticked in a way that made the room feel like the inside of an old watch. He'd been in rooms like this before, when he was a boy, waiting for adults to decide things about him. He remembered the chairs and the carpet but not the decisions. That was the trick of it. You kept the furniture.

"I didn't bring you here for you," Nicolas said.

"I figured."

"I brought you because I need a witness."

Benjamin looked over. Nicolas was examining the ficus like it owed him money.

"Not a witness to me being crazy," Nicolas went on. "I know how that sounds. Dr. Ekwueme has a witness. He has a degree and a leather chair and a witness's whole vocabulary. What I need is a—" He stopped. Restarted. "An archivist."

The door at the end of the hall opened and a man in a cardigan put his head out and said, "Nicolas," and Nicolas stood up and straightened his cuffs and went in and shut the door, and Benjamin was alone with the clock.

He was in there fifty minutes. Benjamin didn't read his phone; his phone had the photographs of both letterhead pages on it, and he didn't want to look at them in a stranger's waiting room, as if that would be a kind of exposure. Instead he thought about the stamped case number on the Society sheet, the one the water had eaten, and how there were only two plausible digits where the fold had gone brown, and how he could probably resolve it under raking light if he had the sheet and an hour. He didn't have the sheet. Nicolas did.

When Nicolas came out his face was washed out and calm in the way faces get after crying, though Benjamin didn't think he had cried. Dr. Ekwueme shook Benjamin's hand and said, "You're the book man," which meant Nicolas had talked about him, and then the door was closed and they were walking down the stairs, and Nicolas said nothing for four blocks.

It was cold. The Avenue was doing its evening thing, delivery bikes threading between cabs, a man selling flowers under a theater marquee. Benjamin kept his hands in his pockets and kept pace and did not ask.

"Right," Nicolas said finally. "I'll tell you what I told him, and you'll tell me if it's a memory or a story."

"What's the difference?"

"That's the whole question." Nicolas stopped at a crosswalk. "If someone tells you a story enough times when you're small, you keep the story. You can't check it against anything. There's no photograph, there's no—" He gestured at the city, at all its records. "Nothing."

"Okay," Benjamin said. "Tell me."

"I'm in a van."

They crossed. Nicolas talked into the wind.

"I'm maybe four. There's a bench seat in the back, vinyl, the kind that's cold and then it isn't. There's a woman in the front. She's not driving, there's a man driving, but I don't have him at all, he's just a shape with a hat. The woman turns around and she's got sunglasses pushed up on her head and she says, hold your brother's hand. That's it. That's the first thing I've got. Everything before it is nothing."

Benjamin waited a light, a block, another light.

"And there's a hand," he said.

"There's a hand," Nicolas said. "Small. Smaller than mine. That's the whole of Julian. A hand in a van. Everything else I have about him I learned from the ledger and from you."

They passed a laundromat, a bodega, a bank with its windows full of a lit-up money-market figure that kept ticking. Benjamin took out the small notebook he kept in his inside pocket—the one with the marbled cover, the one he used for condition notes—and a pencil, because ink was for conclusions.

"What are you doing," Nicolas said.

"Recording it. As given." Benjamin wrote the date at the top. Then: *Van, vinyl rear bench. W, 4 yrs. Female, front passenger, sunglasses on head. Driver male, hat, no face. Statement: "hold your brother's hand."*

"Say the rest."

"There isn't any rest."

"There's the smell. There's the light. Close your eyes."

Nicolas gave him a look, and Benjamin kept the pencil up, and after a moment Nicolas closed his eyes and stood on the sidewalk with his hands in his coat like a man listening for a train.

"It smelled like—" His jaw worked. "The heater. When you first turn on a heater for the winter and it burns the dust off. That smell."

"Good."

"Sunglasses were red." Nicolas opened his eyes. "Rimless. Red lenses. I don't know what that is. I might be making it up because you asked."

"Noted." Benjamin wrote *red, rimless* and then *subject concedes possible confabulation.* "Where were you going?"

"Rain. Grey outside the windows. Not city grey—" He frowned. "Nothing past the windows. Fields. Trees."

"Route."

"I don't know."

"How long?"

"Long. Long like you're small and it's long. Then we stopped and the woman opened the back and picked up Julian out of the seat, and I climbed out on my own because I was four and that mattered. There was gravel. A building with a porch." He stopped. "And then there's a room with a rug, and I'm eating a sandwich, and that's the next thing, and it's months later. It's a different season. I have a different coat."

Benjamin wrote it down. He was aware of his own handwriting slowing. The van. The vinyl. The smell of a heater burning dust.

He knew that smell. He knew it the way he knew the waiting-room chairs—furniture kept, decisions dropped. He did not write that down.

"You're making a face," Nicolas said.

"I'm making a condition note."

"Liar." Nicolas started walking again, faster. "The shrink says the panic is about not knowing. He says the body keeps score when the mind drops the card. He wants me to draw it. I told him I can't draw. He said draw it anyway. I bought the paper. It's in a drawer."

"Draw it."

"Don't tell me what to do."

Benjamin turned the notebook, showed him the page. Nicolas read it standing still in the middle of the sidewalk, a woman with a stroller swerving around him. He read it twice.

"You made me sound like a document," he said.

"You sounded like one."

"That's—" He laughed, one short note, and it was not a good laugh. "You're the only person who's ever done a useful thing with what comes out of my mouth." He handed the notebook back. "Rule three says we pay for information. Does this count?"

"It's your information."

"Then the ledger's yours."

"Don't do that."

"Look," Nicolas said, and started walking again, and Benjamin followed, and they went three more blocks like that, past the bank and a church and a bookstore with a lock on its gate. At the corner Nicolas stopped and didn't look at him and said:

"Here's the thing Dr. Ekwueme won't say out loud, so I'll say it to you. The story has a hand I'm supposed to be holding. Fine. But a van with a woman who doesn't drive, and a driver with no face, and a stop in the country—that's not a snatch." He turned then, and his eyes were very steady. "There's no other child in that van. There's no crying. Whoever drove us was allowed to drive us, and the woman handed Julian to somebody at the porch, and I went in and I got a sandwich."

Benjamin said nothing.

"Kids who get taken," Nicolas said, "get taken from something. We came from nothing. No mother in the front seat, no house on the other side of the ride. Just the dust smell and then the coat."

"Nicolas."

"I don't think Julian was taken," he said. "I think he was left."

The traffic light changed and the walk-sign blinked its white man and neither of them moved, and Benjamin stood there in the cold with the pencil still in his hand, thinking about a room he couldn't picture, and the smell of a heater burning dust, and a woman's voice telling somebody small to hold a hand.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 11: What the Shrink Said · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads