Nicolas lived above a framing shop on a block where the storefronts had been bricked over and painted the same tired cream, as if the landlord had bought one color in 1998 and never needed another. Benjamin climbed the stairs with the sketchbook wrapped in a cotton bag against his chest and his jaw set so hard his teeth ached.
Nicolas opened the door before he knocked. He was wearing a gray henley with the sleeves pushed up and there was ink on his fingers, and he looked at Benjamin's face and stepped back to let him in without saying anything.
The apartment smelled like coffee and dust and something faintly chemical. Papers covered the table, the sofa, the floor by the radiator, sorted into stacks that only made sense to him. Benjamin set the bag down in the one clear rectangle of table and unwrapped the sketchbook.
"I went through it cover to cover this morning," Benjamin said. "Not just the signatures and the gum arabic. Everything."
"I know. You called me at seven."
"Provenance document." Benjamin slid the folded sheet out from between the back cover and the spine lining. It was typed, single-spaced, on cream paper with a deckle edge and an 1890s watermark he'd already held to the light. An affidavit, sworn by Margaret Ellery, claiming she had inherited the sketchbook from her father, Harold Ellery, upon his death in 1968, and that it had passed to her unbroken, undisturbed, in the family's possession for sixty-one years.
Nicolas leaned against the counter and crossed his arms. "And?"
"Courier."
"What?"
"The typeface." Benjamin held the page up. "Courier. Monospaced, slab serif, designed for the IBM Selectric in 1955. This font did not exist in 1968, and it definitely did not exist in 1907. Whoever typed this affidavit used a machine made sometime after 1955 and backdated a document claiming the book entered the Ellery family before the First World War."
Nicolas didn't move for a second. Then he reached over and picked up his coffee and took a drink, which Benjamin already understood was what Nicolas did instead of flinching.
"You went to a typewriter expert," Nicolas said.
"I went to my own eyes and a magnifier. I've read about eight hundred provenance documents. This one has a period after the wrong abbreviation, the margins drift down the page like whoever typed it got tired, and the watermark is on the wrong side of the fold." Benjamin pulled the page back toward himself. "There is no Margaret Ellery affidavit. Your file is invented. Which means you knew the book had no clean chain, and you typed one anyway, which means —"
"I made it," Nicolas said.
"— which means you put a fraud into an auction catalog under the Ellery name, to a room full of people who will bid on it because Margaret Ellery's estate is the provenance."
"I made it," Nicolas said again, quieter. "The night before I brought it to you. I wrote the wording, my lawyer's assistant typed it from my draft, and I aged it with tea and a little heat. It's a good forgery. It's not a great one. I knew a conservator would find it eventually, I just needed it to survive the catalog photograph and the preview week."
Benjamin heard the words and then heard them again and something behind his sternum went cold and flat. "You gave me a stolen book with a forged provenance and let me start work on it."
"I gave you an unsigned book with no providence and I let you start work on it," Nicolas said. "I would have told you. That's the whole point of the rules."
"Which rule was that? The one about not lying to each other? Because I don't remember our napkin saying anything about that."
"The one where we share what we find before we touch it." Nicolas set the mug down. "I found a problem with the paperwork and I fixed the paperwork. That's not the same as hiding the book."
"It's the same as putting me on the wrong page of the story." Benjamin's voice came out lower than he intended. "Every decision I made about this sketchbook for the last four weeks — which pages I stabilized first, how I sequenced the conservation plan, what I thought the auction house would need, what I told the archivist — I made it believing this book had a clean title. You let me sign my name to a lie."
"I didn't sign your name to anything."
"Did you read the treatment authorization? Because my name is on it. My name and my license number, in the house file, certifying that I examined the book and its documentation in good faith." Benjamin picked up the page and turned it over, then back. "If anyone down the line calls the affidavit a fake — and somebody will, because the paper is wrong for the decade and the ink is modern and I can see the tea stains from here — the first person in the chain they come to is the conservator."
Nicolas exhaled. He pushed off the counter and walked to the window, which looked out at the back of the building next door. "I know."
"You know."
"I know. I thought about it. I went through it for a week before I brought you the book." He turned with his arms folded again, and there was something flat and steady in his face that Benjamin was starting to recognize as the place Nicolas went when he had already done the math and didn't like the answer. "The Ellery estate can't attest to the book. Margaret's granddaughter told you that herself — she's never seen it, she doesn't have a paper trail, and she won't return my calls. A book with no title doesn't sell, and I need it to sell."
"Because you owe Sergei forty thousand dollars."
"Because I need the eighty thousand I'll get for it to not be thirty thousand." Nicolas said it without heat. "And because if this book gets any real attention, people start asking where it came from, and the more people ask where it came from, the closer somebody gets to the Society. Including you."
"Don't pretend this was for me."
"I'm not pretending anything was for you. I'm telling you why I didn't stop." Nicolas came back to the table. "You want the honest version? The honest version is that I made the forgery because I wanted the money, and I brought you the book because I wanted to know what was inside it, and I handed you a lie because I needed you to want it too. And I got both, and you're standing in my kitchen."
Benjamin's hands had gone into fists without permission. He opened them. Laid them flat on the table on either side of the affidavit.
"You're telling me I'm your accomplice."
"You are my accomplice." Nicolas's voice dipped. Not cruel. Just done being careful. "You examined the document, you made notes on it in your treatment log, you told the archivist that the book's paperwork was in order when she asked. Every hour you spent on that book after I handed it to you is another hour you can't get back. If I go down, you go down. Which is why I didn't have to tell you. I told you anyway. Because I'd rather have you at the table furious than standing across it."
Benjamin looked at him for a long moment. There was a blue vein at Nicolas's temple that he hadn't noticed before, and a small nick under his jaw where he'd cut himself shaving. Neither of those things helped.
"You've done this before," Benjamin said. "The forgery."
"Almost exactly this. Twice, both times for dealers, both times on paper I couldn't trace." Nicolas didn't look away. "I stopped after the second one because a man who buys dead names should have limits. Then I bought a sketchbook with a photograph of a six-year-old in it and I didn't have a limit anymore."
The radiator knocked somewhere in the wall. Outside, a siren went up Seventh and died out toward the bridge.
Benjamin pulled the treatment log from his bag and set it on the table. He opened it to the page where he'd described the affidavit as "in original condition, unremarkable," initialed and dated. His own handwriting. Careful and small, the way he wrote everything. He looked at it for a long time.
Then he took out his phone.
"What are you doing," Nicolas said.
"Documenting it." Benjamin lifted the affidavit off the table, laid it flat, and shot the full page, then the watermark against the lamp, then the typeface at two centimeters with the phone held steady. Close-up of the period after the wrong abbreviation. Close-up of the tea stains under the lamp, which were obvious now that he knew to look. He turned the page over and shot the verso, where Nicolas's assistant had let the ribbon strike through one letter onto the backing sheet — a ghosted "r" with a serif that hadn't been invented in 1968.
"Tell me why," Nicolas said. He sounded tired rather than angry.
"Because in eighteen months, when this thing goes wrong and someone opens a file on it, I want there to be one photograph in the world where I can point and say I documented the fraud the day I found it. I want a timestamp. I want my own file on this book that doesn't go through you." Benjamin pocketed the phone. "You wanted me at the table. Fine. I'm at the table. But I'm keeping my own copy of the menu."
Nicolas watched him for a beat. Then, very slowly, the corner of his mouth moved — not a smile. Closer to the moment before one.
"Okay," he said. "You're learning."
Benjamin wrapped the sketchbook back in the cotton and picked it up. On his way to the door he stopped with his hand on the knob.
"The Society's letterhead had a case number on it," he said. "Water-damaged. Partially obscured. I want to know what it says before the auction house starts caring, which means I want to know this week, which means I want to know what else you didn't tell me."
"I already showed you the letterhead."
"The letterhead you chose to show me," Benjamin said. "That's different." He opened the door. "I'll see you tomorrow. Bring the ledger."
He heard Nicolas say something behind him as the door swung shut, but the stairs were already taking his weight and the words disappeared down the stairwell with him, and Benjamin kept walking, holding the bag against his chest, the phone warm in his pocket with the first evidence in the case that had his own hands on it.