The knock came at 4:40, which was wrong. Nobody knocked at the studio at 4:40. Deliveries came before noon, clients came by appointment, and the building super came whenever he felt like it, whistling first so you'd know it was him.
This knock was flat and patient. Three raps, then silence, then three more.
Benjamin set down the bone folder and looked through the peephole. Two men in dark coats, and behind them, filling the corridor like a piece of weather, Sergei Morozov.
He thought about not opening the door. He thought about the fire escape, about the back stairs, about the fact that Nicolas was sixteen blocks away at a records office and wouldn't be back for two hours. Then he thought about what a locked door meant to a man like Sergei, and he turned the deadbolt.
"Benjamin." Sergei came in without being invited, the way water comes into a low room. The two men stayed by the door, one on each side, hands folded. "You look well. Working hard."
"I'm working."
"You're always working. That's what I like about you." Sergei walked a slow lap of the studio, taking it in — the padded table, the drying rack, the drawers of tools, the press in the corner. He stopped at Benjamin's bench and touched the cover of the folio lying there, the one Benjamin had been consolidating all afternoon. "Paper and glue. An honest trade."
"What do you want, Sergei."
"The forty thousand." Sergei turned. His face was pleasant. It was always pleasant, which was the problem. "You borrowed it in March. We agreed on six weeks. It's been four months. I've been patient, Benjamin. I've been more than patient."
"I've been paying."
"You've been paying the interest." Sergei smiled. "Interest isn't the loan. You know that. You knew that when you signed."
Benjamin's mouth had gone dry. In March the money had been for the deposit on the Queens storage unit and the Vermont trip and the private records pulls, and Nicolas hadn't yet told him about the trust fund, and Benjamin hadn't wanted to ask, hadn't wanted to be the man who asks. So he'd gone to Sergei because Sergei had helped him once before and never once mentioned it, and that, Benjamin understood now, had been the entire design of the first favor.
"I can have the principal by the end of the month."
"The end of the month is a story people tell me." Sergei picked up a scalpel from the tray, examined the blade, set it down exactly where it had been. "I don't want the end of the month. I want the forty thousand, and thirty-eight hundred in accrued interest, and I want to stop having this conversation. Two of my men have been watching a door in Montreal for a week because of you. Did you know that?"
Benjamin went very still.
Sergei watched him go still, and his pleasant face did something almost affectionate. "You think I lend forty thousand dollars to a bookbinder for no reason. You think I'm a bank."
"I think I'm a name on a list."
"You're a name on a list." Sergei nodded, agreeable. "But a useful one. So here is what happens. You give me something now, tonight, so I know you're serious. And then you keep doing what you're doing, and when you're done, we talk again."
"I don't have forty thousand dollars of anything."
"You have a collection."
Benjamin felt it land like a hand on his chest. His collection was four shelves behind a fireproof door in the back — sixty-odd books, some of them his life's whole argument with the world. He'd started buying at nineteen, the year he'd decided he was going to be somebody who kept things instead of losing them, and he had never once sold a volume. Not in the bad year. Not in the worst year.
Sergei had seen it. Of course Sergei had seen it. He'd been inside the studio before. He'd stood in that exact spot and asked polite questions about binding styles.
"Not the whole collection," Sergei said, as if conceding something. "One book. You pick it. I don't know books. I know what a man won't sell, and I know that's the thing worth taking."
Benjamin walked past him into the back room. He stood in front of the shelves for a long moment with his hands at his sides. He could hear the radiator ticking, and one of the men by the door shifting his weight, and somewhere down the block a truck backing up, that flat electronic chime.
He took down the 1923 edition. The one with the errata leaf, the one he'd found in a dead man's estate sale in Poughkeepsie fifteen years ago and paid nine hundred dollars for when he had eleven hundred dollars to his name. It was worth twenty-five, maybe thirty on a good day at auction — not the forty they needed, but close enough to buy the month. He wrapped it in the acid-free paper he used for client work and carried it out and set it on the bench.
Sergei unwrapped one corner, looked without interest, and nodded. One of the men came forward and took it, and it was gone from the room the way the forty thousand had been gone from his account in March: instantly, completely, into a place where he had no reach.
"Good," Sergei said. "Now the other thing."
Benjamin waited.
"The book you're restoring. The sketchbook."
Everything in the room tilted a few degrees.
It was Nicolas's commission. It was the whole reason the two of them had met — a folio of pencil sketches and sewn-in marginalia that Edith Matheson had sent through a private dealer, and Nicolas had hired Benjamin to stabilize it, and Benjamin had opened it four months ago and found himself looking at a photograph of a five-year-old boy standing in front of a house in Connecticut. Himself. He had never told Sergei its name. He had never told anyone.
"It's a client piece."
"It's a client piece. Sure." Sergei buttoned his coat, unhurried. "I have another buyer who's interested in it. Very interested. Has been asking around about it since spring."
"Then they can ask my client."
"Your client." Sergei's tone made the word small. "Your client hasn't been honest with you, and you know it. That's not a criticism. Nobody's honest. But here's what I'll tell you as a courtesy, because you've been good for years and I like you: I need that artifact. Not tonight. But I need it. Two weeks. You finish your restoration, you give me the book, we subtract what it's worth from what you owe, and everybody walks away clean."
"It's not mine to give."
"Everything's yours to give," Sergei said. "You just have to decide what you'd rather keep."
He moved toward the door, and the two men folded in behind him, and at the threshold he paused and looked back at Benjamin with that pleasant face, and said, "Two weeks," and then the door closed and the corridor was quiet and Benjamin stood alone in the middle of his own studio with his hands shaking.
He locked the deadbolt. He leaned against the door.
The sketchbook was in the safe, in its clamshell box, exactly where it had been since morning. He knew its condition down to the millimeter. He'd written the treatment report himself. He'd noted the sewn photograph on the front pastedown, the four-panel pencil drawing on the recto, the foxing pattern, the two leaves guarded with Japanese tissue.
And Sergei had called it an artifact. Not a book. Not a sketchbook.
An artifact.
Which meant somebody had described it to him, and had described it in those words, and had described it well enough that Sergei Morozov — who could not name a single book on Benjamin's shelf and who thought paper and glue was an honest trade — knew to want it.
Benjamin crossed the studio and knelt in front of the safe and turned the dial with fingers that still weren't steady. He opened it. He lifted the clamshell out and set it on the table and opened the lid, and there it was, the same folio he had spent ninety hours with, the same folio that had put his own childhood face on a stranger's page.
He had never told Sergei what was inside it. He had never told Sergei it existed.
So whoever the second buyer was, they hadn't heard about it from him. They'd heard about it from someone who already knew, which meant one of two things: either Nicolas had been talking to people he hadn't told Benjamin about, or somebody had been talking about this book for a very long time, long before the two of them ever walked into each other's lives.
He reached for his phone and stopped with his thumb over Nicolas's name.
Two weeks. Another buyer. And a man who didn't read books, using a word like artifact.
He put the phone in his pocket without calling, and stood there in the dim studio with his hands at his sides, and understood, slowly and without any comfort in it, that he was the last person to have been told the truth about what he had been holding.