Nicolas was on the floor of the hotel room with his back against the bed frame when Benjamin came through the door, still holding the bakery bag he'd bought two blocks up Sainte-Catherine and never opened.
"Sergei Morozov," Benjamin said.
Nicolas looked up. He didn't ask who that was. That was the tell.
Benjamin closed the door behind him and stood in the narrow entry with his coat still on, the paper bag going damp in his fist. "He came to the studio. Thursday. Two men with him. He wanted forty thousand dollars and he wanted it then, so I gave him the Grolier. My Grolier, Nicolas. The one I bought with the money from my father's estate. It's gone."
"Did he hurt you?"
"Did you know?"
"Did he put hands on you?"
"Did you *know.*" Benjamin threw the bag onto the desk. A croissant split its paper and rolled out, flaking onto the carpet. "Because he said something. He said the book I'm restoring already had another buyer. And you're sitting on the floor not asking what I told him, not asking whether he knows where we are, not asking anything a person asks when their partner gets shaken down by a man who breaks fingers for rent. You're asking whether I'm hurt. Like you already knew the rest."
Nicolas got up slowly, the way you do around someone who might bolt.
"Yes," he said. "I knew."
Benjamin had thought the confirmation would land differently. He'd rehearsed it on the walk back - the cold snap of it, the clean cut. Instead it just made the room smaller. He sat down on the edge of the bed.
"How long."
"Since April. Before I called you." Nicolas stayed standing, hands loose at his sides, deliberately not moving closer. "When I put the listing out for a conservator, I did it through a broker. A woman named Hélène Fauré, Geneva. She handles private collections, discreet ones, and she's very good, and when I described the piece - the John Clare manuscript, the threadwork, the Dutch paper - she told me I wasn't the only person looking. Someone was buying up the whole of Edith Matheson's estate. Every item that surfaced. Storefronts, estate sales, private lots. Paying far over asking, through intermediaries, never a name on the paperwork."
"Christ." Benjamin pressed the heels of his hands against his eyes. "You hired me to restore a stolen book you knew someone else wanted, and you didn't think that was worth mentioning."
"I hired you because I wanted the truth, and I thought a second buyer meant a second lead. Someone else who cared about Edith. Someone who might know what she was." Nicolas's voice was level, and the levelness was worse than anger. "If I'd told you on day one that a faceless buyer in Geneva was circling, would you have taken the job?"
"No."
"Then it worked."
"That's not - " Benjamin stood up again, too fast, and the room pitched. "That's not a plan, Nicolas, that's just lying with extra steps. You don't get to decide what I can handle and call it strategy. I've been carrying this thing since a photograph fell out of a binding. You've been carrying it since you were six. Those aren't the same weight, but I still get to know what's on my back."
Nicolas was quiet for a moment. Then: "You're right."
"I know I'm right."
"I mean it. I should have told you." He finally crossed the room and sat on the desk chair, elbows on his knees, close enough now that Benjamin could see how tired he was - two days of trains and phone calls and that flat hotel light doing him no favors. "When Hélène first told me about the second buyer, I thought - here's the machine. Here's the thing that took Julian. I could feel it turning, Ben. And I decided I'd rather have you angry at me later than have you walk away then."
"That's still the same decision. You just did it in the past tense."
"I know."
Benjamin looked at the croissant on the carpet and, absurdly, wanted to laugh. He picked it up, brushed a hair off it, put it back in the bag. "Forty thousand dollars," he said. "That's what your secrets cost me. I want that on the record."
"Noted. I'll pay you back."
"You'll pay me back out of the *trust fund.*" Benjamin said it flat, watching his face. "The trust fund from the parents who died the week Julian was stolen. Whose terms you still haven't explained to me."
Nicolas met his eyes and didn't flinch. "Not tonight. I promised you the accident, and you got the accident. The trust is next. But first we deal with Geneva."
"Meaning?"
"Meaning Hélène's comment was four months ago and we've never pulled it. If a private collector has been buying every fragment of Edith's estate, that collector was bidding against my broker in auction records. It's all public. Provenance, consignors, the buying entity's name if it registered to bid. You can't buy that volume of estate material through auction houses and leave no trace."
Benjamin sat down on the bed again, reaching for his own laptop this time. "You should've led with this."
"I'm leading with it now."
They worked for two hours with the desk lamp and the curtains shut. Benjamin pulled the databases he used for provenance research, the ones he could still log into with his professional credentials, and Nicolas walked back through Hélène's correspondence line by line: a Matheson first edition sold at a Rhenish house in February, a box lot of her correspondence in London in March, a set of early photographs in Amsterdam in May. Each time, Nicolas named the lot and Benjamin found it.
Consignor on file for the first: a liquidator acting for the Estate of Margaret Ellery.
Second: same.
Third: same, and the buyer's paddle number resolved, after a registration record and a wire transfer memo in a scanned invoice someone had carelessly left in an archive, to a name.
Benjamin read it aloud, twice, because the first time Nicolas didn't move.
"The Ellery Trust."
"Ellery." Nicolas was already typing. "Margaret Ellery. That name was in Peggy's account? The bookseller - the woman who knew J. Vance?"
"She said Vance came in twice a year. She didn't give me every name he ever mentioned, but I have the transcript." Benjamin flipped through the paper notes from Vermont. "Here. Vance told her he was buying on behalf of a collector, a woman he never named, and that she had *family money and a family grudge.* Peggy thought he was being theatrical."
"He wasn't being theatrical." Nicolas stopped typing. "Margaret Ellery is the grandmother. The one Claire lives with - no. Lived with." He looked up. "Claire Ellery. Hoboken. The granddaughter and the grandmother. You met her, you said she gave you the box of papers."
"She gave me *a* box. The day after I met her." Benjamin's skin was going cold. "The Ellery Trust is Margaret Ellery's estate. Still active, still buying. That means whoever administers it has been collecting Edith Matheson's things for years - and one of the first things they ever bought was Margaret's own correspondence."
"Which means the trust isn't an estate." Nicolas stood. "It's a person. A living person, spending Margaret's money, using Margaret's name. And Margaret was at the scene."
"Witness addendum. E. Matheson."
"*E.*" Nicolas said. "I've been reading that as Edith."
Benjamin turned the laptop toward him. The auction record glowed there, harmless and bureaucratic: consignor, lot number, transfer date, beneficiary. "Claire told me her grandmother died in 2009," he said. "So who's been signing the checks since?"
Nicolas grabbed his coat off the hook. "We're going back to Hoboken."