The Unbinding

Chapter 34: The Letter

The letter was three pages, handwritten in blue ink that had faded to the color of an old bruise. Nicolas read the first line aloud and then stopped, his thumb pressed flat against the paper like he was holding a wound closed.

Benjamin stayed where he was, a few feet away, the flashlight lowered so it lit the floor between them and not Nicolas's face.

"Read it," he said. "Or don't. But don't hold it like that. You'll crease it."

Nicolas looked up. For a second he seemed almost grateful - some small, practical instruction to hang onto. He sat down on the floor, back against the desk, and Benjamin sat across from him with his shoulders against a stack of empty crates. The cabin creaked. Somewhere outside, wind moved through the pines, and the flashlight beam jittered against the wall of photographs behind them.

Nicolas read.

"I don't know when you'll find this. Maybe you never will. I've written it a dozen times and burned every one, so I'll keep this one where I can't reach it easily. That's the only way I get through it."

He paused. Swallowed. Kept going.

"I'm not your brother. That's the first thing, and it's the thing you'll want answered, so I'll answer it plain: we shared a house and a name and two people who meant to raise us, but we didn't share a bloodline. You were placed with us. Your file said you'd come from a home in the city, and the file was a lie, because everything the Mathesons touched was a lie. They called you ours. They made you ours. That's not the same as being it."

Benjamin watched Nicolas's jaw work. He didn't interrupt. He'd learned, from years of coaxing cracked spines back into alignment, that the paper would take the pressure only if you let it move on its own.

"I heard them," Nicolas read. "I was six. I used to get up at night and sit on the stairs because the third step didn't creak and I could hear everything from there. I thought I was a spy. That was the year I decided I was a spy. So I heard them, your parents and mine, arguing in the kitchen with the lights off like they did when they thought we were asleep.

"Your mother was crying. She said the words first. I remember because I didn't know what they meant and I asked the housekeeper the next day and she told me never to say them again. 'They're trafficking children,' she said. Not taking them. Selling them. She said we weren't adopted, we were delivered, and there was a man named Matheson who arranged it, and he'd begun asking for money he hadn't asked for before. Rent on us. That's what she called it.

"Your father said the Mathesons had to be stopped. He said there were records, files, names, and he'd go to the police in the morning, and Edith would never see another child pass through her hands. They argued about the rest. Which of us to take when they ran. It went on a long time. I stayed on the stairs. At the end I went back to bed and I didn't sleep and in the morning I told you both what I'd heard. I was proud of it. I thought I'd done something clever."

Nicolas stopped. The flashlight had begun to dim, the beam going amber at the edges. Benjamin reached over and shook it, and it came back a little.

"Keep reading," he said quietly. Not a command. Something nearer to holding a door open.

Nicolas's voice had flattened by the time he started again. "The crash was the next afternoon. I remember the sound of it. I remember the woman on the road with her phone, and the way the light looked through the broken window, and how they wouldn't let me see.

"For twenty years I told myself it was a coincidence, because the other thing was unthinkable. Then I started looking, the way you do when you can't stop yourself, and I found that the man who hit them, a delivery driver named Peter Halloway, was being paid by a company that traced back to a holding a hundred layers deep, and at the bottom of it was Matheson. He drove the truck that killed them because someone paid him to. And I told them. I stood on the stairs and I listened and I went to them in the morning and I handed them a reason to be killed.

"I have never been able to make myself sorry enough. I have tried in every way available to a man. I kept the name they gave me so nobody else could have it. I stayed away from you because every good thing that happened to you was bought with my voice on those stairs, and I didn't have the right to stand next to any of it. You were six and you were placed because of me, and you were watched by the Mathesons because I told two people what I'd heard, and if I put all of that in the same room as you, I don't know what either of us becomes. So I didn't. For thirty years. That was the punishment I chose. It was the only one I could stand."

The last page ended mid-sentence. Nicolas turned it over. Nothing on the back.

He folded the letter along its original creases, carefully, and set it on the floor between them.

The wind pushed against the cabin's front wall. Outside, the flashlight's throw caught a corner of the photo wall - Nicolas at eleven, in a school play, in a costume he must have worn once and never thought about again. Someone had found it in a yearbook and cut it out with a straight edge and glued it carefully to the board, the way a man might handle something holy he wasn't allowed to keep.

Nicolas didn't cry. Benjamin had been braced for it, and it didn't come. What came was worse - a stillness, as if something inside him had been switched off so the rest of him could keep operating.

"You should put it in the case," Benjamin said, meaning the letter.

"I want to burn it."

"Not here." Benjamin shifted forward and put his hand on the folded pages, not to take them, just to stop them drifting. "Not here, and not before we know it's the whole story. He wrote a claim. We don't yet have the paperwork that proves it, and I know you'll hate that I'm the kind of person who wants the paperwork before the grief. But there was a boy on those stairs, Nicolas. He was six. He heard it and he told them."

"And they died."

"They died because someone paid a man to drive a truck into them. Every person in that sentence did a thing. He didn't."

Nicolas looked at him, and for the first time since they'd entered the cabin, something in his face moved. "You keep doing that."

"What."

"Standing between me and the worst thing I believe about myself."

Benjamin didn't have an answer for it that didn't sound like a declaration, so he let the silence stand and picked up the flashlight instead, turning it on the desk. There was a second drawer beneath the roll-top, shallower, and locked. The first had been picked or left open with a key in it; this one wasn't. He took out his pick set and had it open in under a minute - old lock, no tension, easy. Inside were envelopes, sorted by year, and a single brown folder with a rubber band around it.

He opened the folder first. Inside was a photocopy of a newspaper clipping and a photograph of a man in a gray suit at a ribbon-cutting, arm extended across a line of children in matching sweaters. The caption: *Harold Matheson, Deputy Commissioner of Social Services, opens new placement facility.* The date was 1993.

Beneath it, handwritten in the same blue ink, a single line, not in the letter's voice but in a sparer one, like it had been written years later: *He died in 2005. He was never charged. The Mathesons' files went to the state. All of them are sealed.*

"Nicolas," Benjamin said.

Nicolas was on his feet already, looking over his shoulder at the clipping. "Harold Matheson."

"Edith's husband. The man your - the man he heard them name." Benjamin flattened the clipping against the desk. "Former city official. Ties into the foster system, the placement system, the whole machine. And look - he's dead, but the *files* aren't. They're sealed, not destroyed. Sealed records can be unsealed. That's a motion, an order, a judge. There's a path here, and it doesn't run through thirty years of a man punishing himself for something a paid driver did."

Nicolas was quiet a moment. Then he picked up the letter and slid it carefully into the folder, on top of the clipping, and closed it.

"We take everything," he said. "The photos. The folders. All of it."

"There are hundreds of photographs."

"I don't care. I'm not leaving one of them in this cabin for whoever else finds this place."

Benjamin nodded. He pulled the roll of archival paper from his satchel to wrap the bundles, and as he did, something in the second drawer caught the dimming beam - a single photograph, loose, face up, that had been under the folder. A boy of about six, standing in front of a house, holding a paper airplane. Below it, in the careful hand: *1997. First time I saw him. Didn't know yet. Tried to forget the day I found out.*

"Twenty-seven years," Benjamin said.

"And he never once called." Nicolas took the photo, looked at it, and slid it in with the rest. Then he went to the wall, and began taking the clipped pages down, one by one, in order, the way you take down a show when it's over.

The flashlight was nearly out.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 34: The Letter · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads