The Unbinding

Chapter 35: The Matheson Husband

Nicolas didn't read the rest of the letter that night. He folded it along its original creases, slid it back into the roll-top desk, and said, "Tomorrow," in a voice that meant don't ask. Benjamin didn't.

They slept in the car with the doors locked, the heater coughing every twenty minutes, the wall of photographs behind them pressing through the cabin's dark windows like something that watched whether or not anyone was inside to see it. Benjamin woke at four with his neck stiff and the letter's first line going around his head: *I am not your brother, and I am the reason our parents are dead.*

They drove back to Montreal at first light and found a diner off Saint-Laurent where the Wi-Fi worked and the waitress didn't look at Nicolas's face twice, which was the only requirement either of them had left.

"Edith Matheson's husband," Benjamin said, opening his laptop on the sticky table. "Julian's letter said the debt was to Matheson. Edith's husband. So there's a Harold."

"You're sure the letter said that."

"You read it to me."

"I read the first paragraph to you." Nicolas wrapped both hands around his coffee. He hadn't slept, or he'd slept with his eyes open, which for Nicolas was the same thing. "It said a name. I'm asking if you're sure it's the name."

Benjamin pulled up the archives and let the answer be the screen. Census records, property filings, an obituary index for Quebec and New York. It took him eleven minutes, and then he turned the laptop around.

"Harold Matheson," he said. "Died 2005. Obituary in the *Gazette*. Deputy commissioner, New York City Agency for Child Services, 1981 to 1997."

Nicolas stared at the scanned column. "That's a city official."

"That's a city official whose job was placing children in foster care." Benjamin heard his own voice go flat the way it did when a binding was worse than it looked and the client had lied about provenance. "Edith Matheson, the wife Julian's parents were going to turn in. Harold, the husband who ran child placement for the entire city."

"For the entire city," Nicolas repeated. "You're saying —"

"I'm saying the foster care system and a trafficking operation had the same address and nobody noticed for sixteen years." Benjamin pulled the laptop back. "We need the court records. If Julian's parents were going to 'turn them in,' there had to be a file. Something somebody started."

The records request took the rest of the morning. Benjamin had a conservator's credentials and a researcher's patience, and he used both, calling in a favor from a Queens archivist he'd done free work for two summers ago. She came back at noon with a case number and a warning.

"It's sealed," she said over the phone. "Family court, 1996. Investigation into improper placement of minors. Sealed in '98."

"Sealed by whom?"

There was a pause, paper shuffling. "Sealed *for* the subject. Harold Matheson. He petitioned to have it sealed, and it was granted, and the investigator's report is still in the file. Never prosecuted. That's all I can see from here, Ben. You didn't hear the case number from me."

He said thank you and hung up and wrote the number on a napkin.

"So the investigation happened," Nicolas said. "And it went nowhere."

"The investigation happened, and the man who ran child placement for New York City got it sealed under his own name, and he was never charged, and he died in 2005 with an obituary that called him a dedicated public servant." Benjamin folded the napkin. "A sealed file like that doesn't stay sealed. Not forever. Someone in the family has standing to petition to unseal it. Widow, children."

"Edith."

"Edith." Benjamin looked up. "If Edith Matheson is still alive, she can open that file herself. Or she can refuse to."

Nicolas set down his cup. "You think she'd refuse."

"I think a woman whose husband died in 2005 while an investigation into his child placement practices sat sealed in a basement probably has opinions about it being opened." Benjamin closed the laptop. "We have to go back to New York anyway. There's no signal at the cabin and no way to trace that text from here. And I can't call Tomas from the road without a better story than the one I gave him."

"You already gave him a story."

"I gave him a bad one." Benjamin didn't elaborate, because elaborating meant saying *I lied to my lawyer,* and Nicolas already knew that, and saying it aloud would make them even. "There's one more thing. The file was sealed in '98, three years before Julian and Nicolas's parents died. The crash was in '99."

Nicolas went still.

"Julian's letter says his parents were going to turn the Mathesons in," Benjamin said. "But the investigation into Matheson was already closed and sealed three years before. So what were they going to turn him in *for*?"

The waitress came by and refilled Nicolas's coffee. Nicolas didn't touch it. Outside, Saint-Laurent ran gray and cold and ordinary, people carrying groceries, a dog tied to a parking meter, and none of them knew that two men at a diner table were holding a dead man's secret between them like a lit match.

"Something the first investigation didn't cover," Nicolas said finally. "The file was *improper placement of minors.* That's bureaucratic. That's stacking them in the wrong homes. Families getting the wrong file, siblings split up, that kind of thing. It's ugly but it's administrative."

"And the parents were going to turn them in for something the administrative charge didn't touch."

Benjamin looked at the obituary still open on the screen. Deputy commissioner. Sixteen years. Hundreds of placements. Every one of them a child handed to a family through a signature Harold Matheson controlled.

"Nicolas," he said slowly. "The first file says *improper placement.* That's the charge that got investigated, and it got sealed, and it went away. But what if improper placement wasn't the crime. What if it was the paperwork."

Nicolas's eyes came up.

"Someone who runs child placement for a whole city doesn't have to traffic anyone," Benjamin said. "He just has to *assign* them. Wrong addresses, closed adoptions, files that lose a child's real name. You don't need to hide a child if you're the person who decides what the file says in the first place. You just write them into a different life and the life they came from can't find them, because the paper trail says they were never there."

"Then the parents found out."

"They found out something specific enough to threaten him with," Benjamin said. "And the day after Julian overheard them arguing about it, they were dead."

He stopped, because the sentence was sitting there doing what it was doing, and because Nicolas was looking at him like a man doing arithmetic he didn't want the total of.

"Say it," Nicolas said.

Benjamin said it.

"The organization wasn't just hiding children. It was selling them. And Harold Matheson had his hand on the paperwork that made it legal, and it worked for sixteen years, and the only two people who ever tried to stop him are dead."

The diner was loud around them, cutlery and Spanish from the kitchen and the door chime going every few seconds, and none of it reached the table. Nicolas picked up his coffee at last and drank it cold and set it down very carefully, the way a man sets down something he doesn't want to break.

"Then the file is the whole thing," he said. "The sealed one. If it lists placements, names, families —"

"Then it lists children," Benjamin said. "Children who got sold. Children who are still alive somewhere not knowing whose they are."

Like you, he didn't say. Julian's letter claimed he wasn't Nicolas's brother. If that was true, then Nicolas himself was the first entry in the ledger, and the only question left was who had written him in.

"We drive tonight," Benjamin said. "We get to New York, we find Edith Matheson, and we make her open her dead husband's file."

"And if she won't?"

"Then we find someone who can." Benjamin folded the napkin with the case number and put it in his wallet, next to a photograph he'd stopped being able to look at directly. "There's an art dealer who bought a sketchbook off us. Sergei. He knew Julian, he knew about the network, and he's been circling this thing longer than either of us. There's something he's not telling us."

Nicolas's mouth tightened, but he nodded.

"Then that's where we start," he said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 35: The Matheson Husband · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads