The Unbinding

Chapter 36: Sergei's Son

They waited until they were back in the car, heater running, before Benjamin made the call. The cabin sat behind them in the snow like something that had decided to be forgotten.

Sergei answered on the second ring. "Mr. Cole. I was beginning to think you'd lost my number."

"Tell me about your son."

The silence was long enough that Benjamin checked the screen. Nicolas watched him from the driver's seat, engine idling, wipers clearing snow in slow arcs.

"Who told you I had one?"

"You did. Twice. Once when you were drunk in my shop, once when you called me at two in the morning to ask whether I believed a person could be repaid for what they'd lost." Benjamin kept his voice level. "You said there was a boy. You said it like it was a thing that had been taken from you."

A breath. Then, quieter: "Alexei."

"Tell me."

"You want the story, you pay for it at the usual rate." But the mockery was gone from Sergei's voice. "All right. No. You know what—you already know the shape of it or you wouldn't be asking."

"Sergei."

"He was placed. Through the agency, the one under Harold Matheson. 1988. My wife, Irina, she was sick. We couldn't—" He stopped. Started again. "They told us it was a private adoption. Clean paperwork. We paid them eleven thousand dollars and they handed us a four-month-old and a birth certificate with our names on it, like he'd come out of her. Irina cried for a week. Happy. You understand? Happy."

Benjamin closed his eyes.

"He was fine until he wasn't. Sixteen, seventeen. Started staying out. We didn't think—teens do that. Then the drugs. Then the lying. Then the stuff missing from the apartment." A dry sound, not quite a laugh. "We were immigrants. We didn't know the system. We tried, you know? We tried everything. Rehab twice. He'd come home clean and kind and then he'd leave again."

"When did he die?"

"2007. October. He was nineteen." A pause. "Fentanyl. Alone, in a room on Pitkin Avenue, in a house with seven other people who were also alone. Nobody called us. We found out three days later from a detective who couldn't tell me anything except the address."

Nicolas had gone very still. Snow gathered on the windshield; he didn't turn the wipers on.

"I'm sorry," Benjamin said, and meant it.

"I don't want your sorry. I want the file." Sergei's voice had gone hard again, but it was a different hardness now—the hardness of a thing held up too long. "I've been hunting the network's records for eleven years. Every dealer, every fence, every dirty clerk who ever touched a placement sheet. I sold your friend the sketchbook because I couldn't find a single name in it, and then I saw you both walk out of that auction, and I thought—maybe they can. Maybe these two can read something I can't."

"That's why you contacted me."

"I didn't contact you. You came to me for paper stock." A beat. "I let you."

Benjamin looked out at the snow. Somewhere behind them in the dark was a cabin with a wall of photographs and a letter that had unmade the last two days of Nicolas's life.

"You said you'd forgive the debt," he said. "For what."

"For everything you find. The placements. The buyers. The Matheson estate. Whatever Julian has in his head. You don't give me your conclusions—I don't want a summary, I don't want your professional discretion. I want the raw thing. Names, dates, scans, letters, phone records. All of it, as you find it."

"That's a lot to hand over to a man who threatened us."

"I never threatened you." A pause. "You know I didn't. I said I could make trouble. I didn't say I would."

"You had someone in Montreal."

"Did I."

Benjamin waited.

"I have clients there," Sergei said. "If one of them texted you a warning, that's between you and them. I don't control my customers' hobbies."

"You're not answering the question."

"No. I'm not. And you're not going to get an answer, so ask a different one."

Nicolas looked at him, a question in his eyes. Benjamin shook his head: not yet.

"If I agree," Benjamin said slowly, "you don't sell to anyone else in the meantime. You don't use anything I give you to hurt the people in it. And you tell me everything you know about Matheson's estate—who inherited, who's alive, where the records went."

"Agreed, agreed, and I don't know."

"Sergei."

"I don't know. That's the truth. Matheson died in 2005 the way men like him die—quietly, in a house in Connecticut, with a bank account and a lawyer. His wife Edith is still alive. That's all I've got. Whether she knows anything is a coin flip. Whether she'll talk to a book restorer from Manhattan is—" He let it hang.

"And the placements?"

"I have a shoebox and a phone. You have the letter, the photographs, and the brother. Combined, we might have enough to move on someone." A pause. "Or we might not. But you owe me eleven thousand dollars and my son is dead and I'm not getting any younger, Mr. Cole. I'll take the trade."

Benjamin turned the idea over the way he turned water-damaged pages—slowly, watching for what would tear.

"Send me everything you have on the estate," he said. "Tonight. I'll send you the letter."

"Deal."

"And Sergei—if this goes wrong, if I find out you sold anything of mine back to whoever is texting from Montreal—"

"You'll what." Not hostile. Curious, almost kind.

"I'll tell Nicolas about your shoebox," Benjamin said. "And I think you already know what that would cost you."

Silence. Then a short breath that might have been respect. "Tonight," Sergei said, and hung up.

Nicolas didn't start the car. Snow piled in the crook of the passenger-side mirror, fat white flakes falling faster now.

"He has a son," Nicolas said.

"Had. Alexei. Placed through Matheson's network in '88, died in 2007." Benjamin set the phone in the cupholder. "He's been looking for the records for eleven years. That's why he sold you the sketchbook—he was fishing for anyone who could read it."

"He's been fishing for me."

"Yes."

"And I bought it." Nicolas pressed his palms against the steering wheel, not gripping, just resting. "I bought a stranger's grief and hung it on my wall for three years."

"You bought a notebook. He sold it. Those aren't the same thing." Benjamin paused. "I agreed to share everything with him. Everything we find."

Nicolas turned to look at him.

"I know what I said about him an hour ago," Benjamin added. "I don't like it either. But his son is dead and he has a shoebox full of paper we don't have, and we have no signal, no police, and a burner phone in Montreal we can't trace. He's the only lever we've got."

"You trust him."

"No. I made a deal with him." Benjamin watched the wipers, which Nicolas still hadn't turned on. "Trust would have been not sending the letter. This is just—"

"Trade."

"Trade."

Nicolas exhaled and finally flipped the wipers on. Two arcs of clean glass. Beyond them, the road ran white and unmarked toward the highway.

"I want to know who's texting us," he said.

"So do I."

"Because if it's him, or someone working for him—"

"Then we'll know tonight." Benjamin picked up the phone again, turned it over in his hands. "He's sending the estate files. We'll have something to compare against. If he's lying, it'll show."

"And if he isn't?"

"Then we have a box of Matheson paper and an old man in Connecticut and a brother who's been hiding for twenty years."

Nicolas put the car in gear. For a moment the world was only the hiss of tires on packed snow and the low hush of the heater.

"Benjamin," he said.

"Yeah."

"You just gave a stranger our whole investigation in exchange for something we can't verify. You didn't ask me."

"I know."

"I would have said yes."

"I know that too." Benjamin looked at him. "I did it fast so I wouldn't have to watch you be kind about it."

Nicolas laughed, once, humorless, and pulled out onto the road.

It took Benjamin forty minutes of staring at the passing snow to admit to himself that he had not, in fact, done it fast. He had done it deliberately. He had wanted Sergei's shoebox and he had wanted, more than that, to be the one who handed the letter over—to control the single piece of evidence that mattered most. He had made the trade for the investigation and something uglier underneath it, and Nicolas, driving quietly beside him with the wipers going, would find out eventually, because Nicolas always did.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 36: Sergei's Son · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads