The Unbinding

Chapter 40: The Missing Page

The page was gone.

Benjamin stood at the workbench with the overhead light angled down and his bare hands still wrapped in cotton gloves, though he’d stopped needing them for handling two minutes ago. The sketchbook lay open at the gutter between folios sixteen and seventeen. He could see the stubs—faint, nail-wide tabs of paper where the leaf had been cut flush to the binding—and the corresponding gap in the sewing structure where the thread had been slipped and re-knotted. Whoever did it had made a clean job. Nearly invisible unless you knew the book’s signatures the way he did.

He knew them. He’d spent eleven hours on this binding, mapping every chain stitch, every kettle loop, every faint indentation left by the original binder’s awl. The leaf that should have sat between the two facing pages of a woodcut of a Bodhisattva and a blurred photograph of a young man in a monastery courtyard did not exist anymore.

Portia had been in this room less than an hour ago.

Benjamin straightened and reached for his phone.

She answered on the second ring. “Mr. Cole.”

“The page. The one with the photograph of Julian. It’s gone.”

A pause on her end—not long, but enough that he heard her exhale through her nose. “Yes.”

No denial. No pretense. The calm of someone who had prepared this answer. Benjamin’s jaw tightened.

“You cut it out.”

“I did.”

“In my studio.”

“While you were in the back getting the record box you claimed you couldn’t find.” A small, dry sound—possibly a laugh. “I had scissors in my bag. It took nine seconds.”

Benjamin set the phone on the workbench and stared at it, then picked it up again, because he needed his hands for something and there was nothing in the room he was allowed to break. “You photographed the gutter seam first.”

“To confirm the first photograph’s insertion pattern. I wanted to be sure before I removed the second one. And I didn’t want you walking in on me.”

“You came here to take it.”

“I came here to verify it was still there,” Portia said. “The removal was a decision I made five minutes after I arrived. You have a habit of being more observant than I anticipate.”

Benjamin looked down at the book. The page was gone, but her visit had left other marks. He’d seen her hands move; he just hadn’t understood what he was watching. The way she’d turned the book slightly toward herself, the way she’d held the folio flat while he was out of the room. She’d done it right there under his light, and he’d sold her the book for the price of a glance.

“The Ellery Trust has been doing this,” he said. “Not just you. This isn’t new.”

“It’s been happening since 1998,” she said. “Well before my time as counsel.”

“But you’re continuing it.”

“I’m curating it,” Portia said, and the word landed like a slap. She’d used it earlier, but hearing it again now, with the empty gutter visible under his light, he understood she meant it. “The archive contains thousands of records. Most of them are inert. Some of them name people who are still alive, still powerful, still serving on boards and benches and commissions. The trust removes the ones that could be weaponized.”

“Weaponized.”

“Surely you’ve noticed by now, Mr. Cole. Nothing in this archive is neutral. Every page is a fuse. I’ve spent four years deciding which ones to cut before someone lights them. That’s not erasure. It’s containment.”

“It’s lying.”

“It’s triage.”

Benjamin closed the sketchbook and set it aside. His own hands looked strange to him: the careful hands of a man who spent his life repairing what other people had broken, now holding a book with a freshly emptied page. He pulled off the cotton gloves, one finger at a time.

“Why cut the second photograph specifically?” he said. “The first one was already removed before I got the book. So you took out the second one too. What’s on Julian’s face that you couldn’t let me keep?”

Portia was quiet for a moment. Somewhere behind her he could hear the low murmur of a television or a street. “The building in the background.”

“It was a courtyard.”

“It was the Matheson estate. The property at Rhinecliff, before it was sold in ‘03.” Her tone had changed, softer and more careful. “There is one other photograph in existence of that courtyard, in a 1994 county assessor’s file. If someone—a journalist, a prosecutor—matched the architecture in Julian’s photograph to that file, they could establish a timeline. They could place a dozen children at that estate between 1989 and 1996. I can’t have that.”

“Can’t, or won’t?”

“Both,” she said. “Those children are grown. Some of them have families now. Some of them don’t know what happened to them. If the archive surfaces, they surface, and the people who sold them are sitting in rooms where they can still reach them.”

Benjamin thought of Sergei’s son Alexei, dead at twenty-nine, having never known why he’d been placed where he was placed. He thought of the letter he’d sent without asking Nicolas.

“You’re protecting the network,” he said.

“I’m protecting what’s left of the network’s victims,” Portia said. “There’s a difference, even if you don’t like it.”

“Then why are you telling me this?”

“Because you’ve already found the Matheson court file and you sent the letter. I read the Post-it you left on the desk.”

Benjamin’s hand went still over the glove. He hadn’t left a Post-it.

“You’re bluffing,” he said.

“I’m not. It was under the record box. Two lines. ‘You should have told me before you sent it.’” A pause. “My uncle Leslie used to write things like that to my grandmother. She kept all of them.”

The room felt colder. Benjamin looked at the corner of the desk where he sometimes left scrap paper, and there was nothing there, but he couldn’t swear there hadn’t been, hours ago, before Portia arrived, before he’d spent the afternoon distracted. She’d been in this studio for twenty-two minutes. She’d seen everything he hadn’t guarded.

“You’re not the only one whose family was destroyed,” Portia said.

He waited.

She let the silence stretch long enough that he heard her shift the phone to her other ear, heard the small rustle of a coat. “Edith Matheson was my grandmother,” she said. “Harold was my grandfather. I grew up in that house until I was thirteen, until Harold died and the estate went into probate and the children—the ones who were placed there, the ones who were still around—started asking questions. I didn’t know what any of it was. I was thirteen. All I knew was that my grandmother stopped speaking to my mother and that the trust was set up the year before Harold died by a man whose name I didn’t learn until law school.”

“The trust was set up to protect him.”

“The trust was set up to outlive him,” she said. “And to keep the record of what he did from becoming the record of what everyone did. I inherited it. Not by choice.”

Benjamin turned the sketchbook toward the lamp again, running his thumb along the cut edge of the gutter. It was clean. Almost invisible. The work of someone who had spent years doing exactly this.

“You want me to believe you’re different from them,” he said.

“I want you to believe I’m the only one left who’s trying to close the operation without killing the people who survived it,” Portia said. “Come to the trust tomorrow morning. Bring the sketchbook. Bring Mr. Ashford.”

“Why him?”

“Because he’s spent longer living with a false name than anyone in this file,” Portia said. “And because I need to know what he traded to get it.”

She hung up before he could answer.

Benjamin stood alone in the studio with the page gone, the photograph gone, and the name Matheson sitting in the room like a thing he’d been carrying without noticing. He looked at the empty folio, then at his phone, then at the door.

He hadn’t told her his own name was in the archive.

She’d never asked.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.