Portia's office was in the back of the trust's townhouse, a room that had been a parlor once, with a marble mantel and a chandelier too heavy for the ceiling. She'd cleared the desk for them and set out three cups of tea that none of them drank.
"You brought it," she said, looking at the sketchbook under Benjamin's arm.
"You asked me to."
She gestured to a long table by the window, cleared except for a felt mat and a pair of white cotton gloves in her size. "Put it there. Open it where you want." She sat. She didn't move toward it.
Nicolas stayed standing, near the door, hands in his coat pockets. He hadn't said a word since they'd walked in, and Portia hadn't looked at him yet except once, a quick flick at the doorway, the way you check a dog's position.
Benjamin opened the sketchbook on the mat and turned the pages to the seam where the first photograph had been sewn. The gutter was bare now. The thread holes were still there, small and patient.
"You want to know what else I've taken," Portia said.
"I want to know why you took hers specifically. You left the first one."
"The first one was already gone by the time I got to it. You took it. I saw your work in the gutter when I examined the book. You're very good."
"Flattery."
"Observation." She reached for her tea, didn't drink it. "Edith was my grandmother. You know that. What I didn't tell you is that she left me the trust in 2019, when I was thirty-one, and that I had no idea what it actually did until I started reading the files. My mother thought it was a charity. Edith kept it that way on purpose. The paperwork was beautiful." She said the last word like it tasted bad. "I came in as a lawyer expecting to help survivors apply for assistance. Then I found the placements."
"The children."
"Placements, we call them. It's a softer word. Edith liked softer words." Portia set the cup down. "Between 1974 and 1996 the network placed somewhere around four hundred children, almost none of them through legitimate channels. Some were adoptions, if you're generous with the term. Some were not adoptions at all. Some of them were sold."
Nicolas shifted by the door. Portia still didn't look at him.
"You said you've been shutting it down," Benjamin said.
"I've been trying. I've closed the placements office. I've terminated the two shell corporations that still funneled money to the estate. I've spent four years cross-referencing paper. But the network wasn't an organization. It was a set of relationships. A set of favors. You can dissolve a corporation. You can't dissolve the ease with which certain men call each other."
"Which men."
Portia got up and went to a filing cabinet behind the desk, an old one, the kind with a key. She unlocked it, drew out a single manila folder, and set it on the mat beside the sketchbook. No white gloves for this one.
"Vance," Benjamin said, reading the tab. It was the folder he'd seen on her desk.
"Vance was a middleman. Dead. That's not the problem." She opened the folder. Inside were six pages, each in a different hand, all dated. At the top of the first page, in a secretary's neat cursive: *Referred by the Hon. A. Crenshaw.*
"Judge Alan Crenshaw," Portia said. "Southern District, retired in 2002. He sat on the bench for twenty-nine years. He referred eleven children into the network. I have nine of them documented. Two are still unaccounted for." She let that sit. "The adoptions he facilitated were fraudulent. He used his position to make them look clean. And two of the families he placed into are still active - I mean the parents. Still donors to the network. Still, occasionally, using it."
Benjamin looked at the pages. Names, dates, case numbers. A judge's name at the top of the first page only, like a signature on a letter.
"You can't touch him legally," Benjamin said.
"The documents I have are hearsay and decades beyond any statute of limitation. Some of them are stolen. Two of them, I stole." She said it plainly. "What I don't have is a witness. Someone the judge placed, who will say so on the record. Someone credible, who will go on the record and force the Southern District to open an inquiry. One living witness is all it would take. I've been looking for one for two years."
"And you think I'm that witness."
"You're not a placement. You're a placement's child." She finally looked at Nicolas, then. "And you're something else."
Nicolas's voice came flat from the door. "Say it."
"He's the son of a placement, too," Portia said. "Or he's not. That's what I can't determine. The file that would tell me is one of the ones Edith burned, and the only person alive who can confirm it is Crenshaw, because Crenshaw is the man who signed the paper on his mother."
The room got very quiet. The chandelier hummed, faint, from the ceiling.
"Ashford is not a family name," Portia said. "It's a name on a document. In 1988 there was a placement into a family in New Rochelle, and the father was a Crenshaw associate, and the mother died in 1994, and the boy left at seventeen with no ID and no paper trail. I don't know if that boy was you. I've been trying to find out for eleven months." She closed the folder. "If he confirms it, I don't need a witness. I need a judge who placed unlawfully and a man who can testify he was placed. That's an inquiry. That's federal."
Benjamin put his hand flat on the sketchbook, covering the empty gutter. "You had eleven months. Why are you asking now."
"Because he brought me the sketchbook." She meant Nicolas. "Because Crenshaw is dying. He was diagnosed in the fall. His people are already moving the estate, and I have maybe three months before the paper goes into trust and out of reach. I need a yes before then."
"Or what."
"Or I go to the Times with what I have, which is not enough, and he dies with everything sealed, and four hundred people never get a single name." Portia's jaw worked once. "I don't want to do that. It doesn't help anyone. It just makes me feel better."
Benjamin looked at the felt mat, the thread holes, the small patient ruin of the seam. Four years she'd been doing this. The trust's money had paid for the studio's rent that first winter. He remembered that now, undeservedly.
"The Matheson archive," he said. "All of it?"
"Everything I have. The placement files, the correspondence, the two redacted ledgers, the photographs that are left. Including the page I cut." She didn't blink. "I'll hand it over to you as a conservator. As a gift to the trust's collection. You'll have custody. I'll have nothing."
"And in return."
"You and Mr. Ashford help me go after Crenshaw. You find the placement families he used. You corroborate. You testify if it comes to it."
Benjamin was quiet a moment. He could feel Nicolas behind him, the particular stillness of a man deciding something.
"What do you want in return," Benjamin said. "Not for the archive. For him. You said one thing. You haven't said the other."
Portia looked at him for a long time.
"Nicolas Ashford's real identity," she said. "I want his real name, on the record, in writing, before we do anything. The name he was born with. The name on the placement paper. I want it notarized and I want to know whether it matches the one in Crenshaw's file. If it does, we have the case. If it doesn't, we don't, and I want to know that now, not in front of a grand jury."
Nicolas took his hands out of his pockets. "And if I don't have one."
"Then you're the only person in this room who can't help me," Portia said, "and that would be a shame, because I think you're the only one who can."