The Unbinding

Chapter 43: Judge Crenshaw's Library

The house was wrong for a dying man.

Benjamin had expected something shrunken and dim, a place already folding in on itself. Instead the Crenshaw estate sprawled across three acres of Scarsdale green, white-columned and confident, its hedges trimmed to a blade. A woman in her sixties answered the door and led them through a marble foyer where a grandfather clock sounded the hour like it owned the afternoon.

Judge Alan Crenshaw waited in the library.

He was smaller than his reputation. Propped in a wing chair with a tartan blanket over his knees, oxygen tubing hooked beneath his nose, he still carried the courtroom in his face — heavy brow, mouth set like a gavel resting. His eyes went to Nicolas first and stayed there a beat too long.

"Mr. Ash," he said. The voice had gravel in it. "You're younger than I expected for a collector."

"I started early." Nicolas smiled, easy and warm, one hand already extending. "Your Rittenhouse is the reason. My father had a facsimile when I was nine. I've been chasing the real thing ever since."

The judge's grip was dry and stronger than it looked. "Most men your age chase other things."

"Most men my age are boring."

Crenshaw almost smiled. Almost.

Benjamin kept his hands in his pockets and let his eyes do what they were trained to do. Oak shelves, glass-fronted, four walls deep. A Cram 1892 atlas lying flat on a low table, its spine cracked. A run of colonial statutes bound in calf. Everything catalogued, nothing random — the library of a man who had spent sixty years believing order was a virtue.

"Judge, may I?" Benjamin gestured at the shelves.

"You're the appraiser."

He moved along the wall slowly, the way he'd been taught at the Morgan — read the shelf before you touch it. Spine condition. Dust lines. Where a book has been pulled and where it hasn't. Crenshaw's hand had skipped the center of the room for years; the volumes there were bright, unworn. The ones he actually pulled lived at hip height, left of the window.

Where the light fell.

Benjamin pulled one at random and opened it. A New York State reporter, 1968. Vellum, decent. He set it back.

"Anything of value?" Nicolas asked, still seated, still charming, asking the judge about the Rittenhouse printing like a man with all the time in the world. He was good. Benjamin had watched him lie before, at the auction house, in Portia's office, but this was something else — a whole other skin, worn comfortably. It occurred to him, not for the first time, that he had no idea how many Nicks there were.

He kept moving.

Third shelf from the bottom, behind a row of bound opinions. His fingers found it before his eyes did — a slim octavo, green cloth, its spine labeled in gilt too small to read from a distance and too new for the shelf. He slid it out.

A Treatise on the Law of Domestic Relations. Cincinnati, 1911. First edition. The boards were fine, the hinges sound. He opened it and there, pasted to the front board, was the bookplate.

He had seen it once before, in a photograph Portia had shown them on her phone.

A small round seal in cobalt blue, a house with no door, and beneath it, in tidy black letterpress:

HUDSON FAMILY REUNIFICATION SOCIETY

Ex Libris

Benjamin kept his face still. That was the whole job, in the end — keeping your face still while the floor dropped out.

"Judge," he said, casual, turning with the book in his hands. "This one's unusual. A domestic relations treatise with an institutional plate. Was this part of a donated collection?"

The change was fast.

Crenshaw's jaw set. The oxygen line shifted as he leaned forward, and the blanket slid off his knees and neither of them moved to catch it. He looked at the book in Benjamin's hands the way a man looks at a snake on the path.

"Put it back."

"I'm only asking about provenance. For the appraisal—"

"Put it back."

Nicolas straightened in his chair. "Judge, if there's an issue with—"

"There's no issue." Crenshaw didn't look at Nicolas. He was still looking at Benjamin, and the gravel in his voice had gone to something colder. "That shelf doesn't belong to the estate. It's personal. You've been here twelve minutes and you've already found the one thing I told the girl not to leave in the room. That's not appraising. That's looking."

"I—"

"Get out." He pressed a button on the arm of his chair. Somewhere in the house, a bell rang. "Mrs. Lyle will see you to the door. The appraisal is cancelled. There is no appraisal. I don't know what you came for, Mr. Ash, but I know you came for it, and it won't be here long."

Nicolas rose. To his credit, nothing in his face had cracked. "Judge, I apologize if—"

"Out."

Mrs. Lyle appeared in the doorway. Benjamin set the octavo down on the low table, spine out, exactly where a restorer would leave a book — and noted, as he did, the two volumes missing from the gap beside it, and the faint rectangle of unfaded shelf where a third had sat until very recently.

Records. Moved. But not all of them, and not far.

They crossed the marble foyer. The grandfather clock rang a quarter hour. Mrs. Lyle opened the front door onto the bright green lawn, and Nicolas stepped through, and Benjamin was a half step behind him when Nicolas stopped.

"One moment," he said. "I forgot my card."

He turned and walked back into the library, and Benjamin, standing in the open doorway, watched him go. Mrs. Lyle frowned but did not follow.

Nicolas crossed the room in four unhurried strides and crouched beside the wing chair so that his face was level with the old man's — the way you speak to a child, or a dying witness. From the doorway, Benjamin couldn't hear it. He read it off Nicolas's mouth instead, the shape of the words, slow and deliberate, each one placed like a stone.

I know about the boy.

Crenshaw's hands went still on the blanket.

You bought.

The oxygen line twitched.

In 1994.

Whatever color Crenshaw's face had left, it left. His lips parted and nothing came out. His right hand — the one that had pressed the bell, the one that had signed things once — began to move, slowly, along the arm of the chair, toward the small side table where a cordless phone sat in its cradle beside a glass of water.

Nicolas straightened. He put his business card on the table, deliberately, in front of the phone, so that the old man would have to reach around it.

Then he walked back across the marble, past Benjamin, out through the door, and down the steps into the light, and he did not look back once.

Benjamin followed. The door closed behind them with a soft, expensive click.

In the car, neither of them spoke for a mile. The Scarsdale houses slid past, big and green and quiet. Nicolas drove with both hands at ten and two, his jaw working.

"You said you knew about the boy," Benjamin said finally. "You don't. We don't even know his name."

"No," Nicolas said. "But he does."

"Crenshaw could have called the police the second we left the driveway. That's what that reach was — the phone."

"Let him."

"Nicolas—"

"Ben." He took the turn onto the Hutchinson Parkway and his voice was very level, the way it got when he was afraid of it. "He didn't call anyone. Did you see his face? He's not going to call the police. He's going to call someone who isn't the police. And that means we found the right house."

Benjamin looked out the window at the highway. On the fourth shelf from the bottom, behind the bound opinions, a man had kept a book of his own crimes for thirty years and never been able to throw it away.

"It means we found the right house," he agreed. "And now the house knows we found it."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 43: Judge Crenshaw's Library · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads