The knock came at 4:40, which Benjamin knew because he had been watching the clock since three, when the appointment at Scarsdale would have been ending and he was still in Brooklyn with a scalpel in his hand and no phone call from Nicolas.
Two of them. A woman in a gray coat with a badge already open, a man behind her who looked like he lifted weights on his lunch hour.
"Mr. Cole? Benjamin Cole?"
"That's me."
"Detectives Ruiz and Farrow. Can we come in?"
He stepped back. They came in and looked at the studio the way cops look at rooms — exits, corners, anything that might need naming later. The V-track press, the bone folders aligned on the mat, the Marantz camera on its arm above the worktable. Benjamin had a Morisot plate half-lifted on the suction pad and he set it down carefully, aware of his own hands, aware of being watched while he did it.
"Nice place," Farrow said.
"I teach Tuesdays and Thursdays. The rest of the time I'm here."
"Which is convenient," Ruiz said, "because we're here about a theft complaint filed this morning. A Scarsdale resident. Judge Alan Crenshaw."
Benjamin let his face do nothing. Years of holding fragile paper had taught him the trick — stillness reads as calm, and calm reads as innocent. "I don't know the name."
"That's funny," Farrow said, "because a witness puts two men at his residence yesterday afternoon. One of them gave the name Nicholas Ash."
"I don't know that name either."
Ruiz took out a notebook. She didn't open it. "Mr. Cole, let's not do the part where we're stupid. The appointment was made by phone from a number registered to an LLC that traces back — three hops, but we can trace hops — to a man named Nicolas Ashford. You've been seen with him. Sotheby's. The Frick. A restaurant on Atlantic Avenue two weeks ago where you had the risotto."
The risotto. He remembered the risotto. He remembered the waiter's thumb in the plate and Nicolas saying, without looking up, that the man would have made a superb forger, and meaning it as a compliment.
"So I know him," Benjamin said. "That's not a crime."
"Did he take anything from Judge Crenshaw's house?"
"No."
"You were there."
"On a private appraisal. At the invitation of the owner."
"And Mr. Ashford's role?"
"Client of mine. Interested in the library." That much was even true. "He thought he might buy."
"Judge Crenshaw says he never invited anyone named Ash. He says two men came to the door and one of them went back inside alone after the appraisal and stayed there." Farrow leaned against the edge of the worktable and Benjamin had to physically stop himself from saying don't lean there. "The judge is a dying man, Mr. Cole. He made his statement from bed. He was quite specific."
"Then his memory is better than his manners."
Ruiz smiled the way people smile at the last of their patience. "Here's where we are. The judge says a first edition went missing. Bayntun binding. Worth more than my car and probably my house. He says the only people in that room were you and your friend. So either Mr. Ashford took it, or nobody took it and the judge is confused. So I'll ask again. Did he take it?"
Benjamin thought about the two missing volumes beside the plate-bearing book. The clean shelf gap. Somebody had been moving records out of that house before they ever got there.
"No," he said. "He didn't take anything."
"Where is he now?"
"I don't know."
He didn't. That was the trouble. Nicolas had dropped him at the studio at eleven and said he had a few errands, and errands in Nicolas Ashford's mouth were a variable that could hold anything. He had not called.
"Would you tell us if you did?"
"I'd tell you he didn't steal a book."
"Is that not telling us?"
"That's all I have."
They stayed another twenty minutes. Farrow walked the perimeter and looked at the photographs in the hallway — the ones of the bindery, the ones of hands, no faces — and Ruiz asked for Nicolas's address and Benjamin said he didn't have one and watched her write something down, and then they left the way they came, and the door clicked, and Benjamin stood in the middle of his own studio with his heart doing something steady and wrong.
He locked the deadbolt. He put the Morisot back in its clamshell box. He washed his hands because he didn't know what else to do with them.
The note was on the floor of the vestibule when he went to put the chain on.
He must have stepped over it walking in. It was a piece of typing paper, folded twice, no envelope. The letters were cut from a magazine — actual cut letters, glued down in a straight line, which was almost more frightening than anything printed, because it meant someone had sat down with scissors and done this with care.
*DROP IT OR YOUR MOTHER PAYS.*
He read it three times. The third time he noticed the letters were in a font that appeared nowhere else in the city — a heavy condensed serif, the kind of typeface used for the word PREMIUM on a grocery circular — and that the person who made it had lined the baseline up almost perfectly, which meant practice, which meant this was a kind of paperwork, and the man who had signed Nicolas's mother into a car in 1994 had spent his life doing paperwork.
He called Ruth.
It rang four times. Ruth's phone was always at the bottom of a bag, and she always answered on the fourth ring, as if the first three were for principle.
"Benny. It's late, are you eating?"
"Are you home?"
"Of course I'm home, where else does a woman my age go at—"
"Listen to me." He kept his voice level. He heard the levelness land wrong and made himself keep it anyway. "I need you to pack a bag. A small one. Tonight."
Silence. Then: "What's happened."
"Nothing's happened. There was a note."
"What kind of note."
"A note on my door." He closed his eyes. "It said if I don't stop what I'm doing, you pay."
He heard her breathing change. Not fear — Ruth Cole did not do fear in the voice, she did it in the hands and the dishes — but something older, something that sounded like an engine deciding.
"Who sends a thing like that," she said. "Who does that."
"Someone who knows where you live. That's the only thing that matters right now. Do you have a bag?"
"Benny—"
"Do you have a bag."
"I have a bag." A drawer opened. Clothes, hangers. "It says *your mother*, that's what it said? That's how they put it?"
"That's how they put it."
"Then they know you have one." Her voice had done something he hadn't heard in years. It was the voice from the years he had almost forgotten — the years that came back to him in seams and photographs sewn into gutters, the years of an apartment with a mattress on the floor and a woman who fed him from a can and left him at a church on a Sunday. "That's the thing, Benny. That's the thing I hoped nobody would ever say to you."
Benjamin's hand tightened on the phone.
"What thing."
Another silence. A zipper, slow.
"Not on the phone," Ruth said. "I'll come to the city. Get me a hotel. Somewhere with a lobby and a man at the desk. And then you and me are going to have a talk I've been not having for thirty-four years."