Benjamin had been back in the city for six hours when the knock came. He'd spent the train ride from Paramus watching the Hudson slide past the window, trying to decide whether the eighty thousand dollars sitting in his account made him feel relieved or hollow. The answer, it turned out, was neither. It felt like a transaction. It felt like the only thing he'd ever been good at: trading one thing of value for another and not asking what the difference was.
The knock was polite. Two knocks, then a pause, then a third. Federal.
He opened the door to his studio, which still smelled faintly of the vinegar solution he used for foxed paper. Two agents. The woman did the talking. Special Agent Reyes, evidence jacket over a blouse, badge already open in her hand. The man beside her, Agent Pruitt, kept his hands at his sides and his eyes on the workbench, on the half-finished codex propped open on the cradle, on the shelves of clamps and bone folders and the little jar of wheat paste.
"Benjamin Cole?"
"That's me."
"We'd like to ask you a few questions. Voluntary. You're not under arrest." She said it the way you'd say a doctor's appointment is routine. "Is there somewhere we can sit?"
He gave them the studio, which was all he had. The apartment above it was a bed and a kettle. The studio had two chairs and a stool. Reyes took the stool. Pruitt stood by the door, which Benjamin understood after approximately four seconds was not an accident. The exit was his if he wanted it, and Pruitt was stationed to make sure he knew it would be noted.
"Mr. Cole, we're investigating the identity of a person you've worked with for six years," Reyes said. "Nicholas Ash. You've probably seen the coverage."
"I've seen it."
"He's cooperating with us. Fully. He's already given us a proffer. That's relevant to you because it means most of what we know, we know from him, and we'd like to hear it from you independently."
Benjamin sat down on the second chair. The wood creaked. Outside, someone had taped a flyer to his street-facing window at some point, some protest or manifesto, and the paper had been rained on and gone gray.
"Okay," he said.
"You restored a manuscript for him in September. A sixteenth-century manuscript with a provenance document."
"Yes."
"Who prepared the provenance document?"
"I was told it came with the manuscript."
"Told by whom?"
"By him."
She wrote nothing down. She didn't need to. Pruitt did, in a small notebook, the mechanical patience of a man who had been doing this for twenty years and had stopped expecting surprises.
"Did you examine the document?"
"I examined it. It was period-appropriate materials. The ink matched. The hand matched. If you want my professional opinion, it was a very good forgery. Better than most I've seen."
"You're saying you couldn't tell."
"I'm saying I didn't. There's a difference." He heard the defensiveness come into his own voice and disliked it. "I wasn't asked to authenticate it. I was asked to restore the binding and treat the leaves. The provenance was loose. It came in a sleeve."
"Whose sleeve?"
"His."
Agent Reyes leaned forward slightly. She had a flat, unhurried face. Benjamin had the sense she was not measuring his guilt but his usefulness.
"Mr. Cole, when did you first suspect it was forged?"
There it was. The question had been coming since the moment he opened the door, and he'd known it, and he'd had a train ride and six hours to prepare an answer, and the answer he had prepared was not the answer he wanted to give, which meant the answer he prepared was probably the true one.
He looked at his hands. There was a callus at the base of his right middle finger from the scalpel. Ink under the nail from a watermark he'd been tracing that morning.
"I suspected something was wrong with the document in October," he said. "Not that it was forged. That it was inconsistent. The watermark didn't sit right. I told him I wanted to look closer and he told me not to bother."
Pruitt's pen stopped. Reyes didn't move.
"So you suspected the provenance was false as early as October. And you continued working with him."
"I continued because I wanted to find a man named Julian Vance. I was using the association to get information about him. That's the truth and I'm not going to dress it up."
"And you didn't report the suspected forgery."
"No."
"To anyone. No police, no bureau, no ethics board."
"No."
"Because you wanted something from the relationship more than you wanted to be correct."
Benjamin looked up at her. "Because I wanted to find someone," he said. "You can put it however you like."
She let the silence sit. Outside, a truck braked somewhere down the block. Pruitt turned a page.
"Here's where we are, Mr. Cole," Reyes said. "Mr. Ash has given us a full account of the provenance work. He's offered testimony in exchange for immunity on the identity charges, and he's made it clear he never intended to defraud the manuscript's owner or you. But the forged provenance itself is a separate matter. It was used in a transaction. There's a question of who knew what when, and you just told me you knew in October."
"Knew what? That a watermark looked wrong."
"That a document in your professional custody was inconsistent with its purported date. You're a conservator. You know that's not a small thing."
He did. He'd known it in October too, sitting in that terrible apartment, looking at a photograph of himself at six years old sewn into a binding. He'd known it and he'd swallowed it, because there was another question in front of him that mattered more, which was who had put his photograph there and why.
"Are you charging me?" he asked.
"Not today." Reyes closed her jacket. "But I want to be straight with you. The United States Attorney's Office can charge failure to report a suspected forgery where it facilitates a fraud, and the fraud here is the movement of a stolen sixteenth-century manuscript. That's not a small count."
"I didn't move it. He already owned it."
"You treated it. You returned it to circulation in a form that made the fraud usable." She paused. "I'm not telling you what I think. I'm telling you what a prosecutor can argue."
Benjamin's mouth had gone dry. He reached for the jar of paste on the bench, an old habit, something to hold. "So what do you want."
"Your testimony," Reyes said. "On the record. Not as a cooperating witness to the identity matter. As a witness against Mr. Ash on the document. If you give us a truthful account of what you knew and when you knew it, and you don't withhold, the office is inclined to treat you as a witness, not a defendant."
"You're asking me to testify against him."
"I'm asking you to tell the truth about him. Whether you call that against him is your business." She stood. Pruitt closed his notebook. "He's already waived his privilege. He knows what you know. He told us you'd tell the truth, actually. His exact words were that you're the most honest person he's ever met, which for a man in his position is a strange thing to say."
The door didn't close hard. They never do. It just clicked, and then Benjamin was alone in the studio with the paste in his hand and the gray flyer on the window, and somewhere on the street a television van idled, waiting for him to come out and say something for the cameras.
He set the paste down. He pulled out his phone and looked at Nicolas's number for a long moment without calling it, because there was nothing to say yet that wasn't a question, and the only question that mattered was whether Nicolas had told the agents about the witness arrangement the same way he'd told them everything else, and whether the "most honest person" line had been a kindness or a setup.
Then he opened a drawer under the bench and took out the scrap of provenance paper he'd torn off in October, the little corner with the watermark that didn't belong, the thing he'd palmed and pocketed in a moment he hadn't fully understood then and understood completely now. He looked at it, and he did not photograph it, and he did not throw it away.
He put it back in the drawer, under the jar of paste. He'd need to decide what it was for. The agents hadn't asked whether he'd kept any piece of the document, which meant either they didn't know, or they already did, and if they already did, then everything he had just told them was now a test.