The Unbinding

Chapter 73: The Testimony

The grand jury room was smaller than Benjamin had imagined, beige and windowless, with a water stain on the ceiling tile above the court reporter's head that he couldn't stop staring at. Eleven jurors in two rows of chairs. No judge. No gallery. Just a stenographer's machine clicking, and the low hum of the ventilation, and Assistant U.S. Attorney Margaret Han, who had spent the last forty minutes making him answer the same six questions in six different ways.

"Mr. Cole." Han didn't look up from her legal pad. "You've testified that by October you suspected the provenance document was forged. Is that correct?"

"Yes."

"And you continued to work for Mr. Ash anyway."

"I continued to restore the manuscript."

"For Mr. Ash." She let the name sit. "Knowing that the document placing it in his possession was, in your professional opinion, a fabrication."

Benjamin folded his hands on the table. The scrap of torn provenance was still in his coat, in the courtroom's cloakroom, three doors and one long hallway away from this room. He hadn't touched it since the night he took it out of the drawer. He hadn't mentioned it. No one had asked. He had spent four days deciding whether its absence from his testimony was a lie of omission or simply the difference between an answer and a confession.

"I kept working because he asked me to help find a person who was missing," he said. "A man named Julian Marsh. That was the actual purpose of the job, and it was a real one. The manuscript was the cover story."

"Couldn't you have called the police?"

"I didn't know a crime had been committed."

"You suspected a forgery."

"A forgery of a provenance document isn't the same as a crime against a person," Benjamin said. "I'm a conservator, Ms. Han, not a lawyer. I thought if I walked away, someone would disappear and no one would ever learn why."

Han set down her pen. "Mr. Cole, are you aware that Mr. Ash's real identity has never been documented? That the name he used for six years does not belong to any living person?"

"I'm aware."

"And yet you continued to work with him. Even after your own studio was searched. Even after agents questioned you about the very document you now say you suspected."

"Yes."

"That sounds naïve."

"It was."

A juror in the front row — a woman with gray hair pulled back, a library cardigan — looked up from her notebook and looked at him, and Benjamin couldn't read the look. He'd spent most of his adult life being looked at, and he'd learned that being looked at and being understood were two entirely different transactions.

"Let me ask you this," Han said. "Knowing everything you know now — Mr. Ash's real identity problem, the forgery, the federal investigation — would you do it again?"

Benjamin didn't answer for a moment. The stenographer's machine clicked. The water stain on the ceiling tile looked, if he tilted his head, a little like a bird in flight.

"I don't know," he said finally. "I know what I did. I've told you what I did. I'm not going to make it sound better than it was, or worse than it was. You've got what there is."

The room was quiet. Han looked at him for a long moment, then at her pad, then at the foreman, and said, "Nothing further."

The immunity order came down from the court an hour and forty minutes later, typed on a single page with the wrong font in the caption block. Benjamin read it twice in the hallway outside the hearing room, standing under a fluorescent panel that buzzed slightly, and then a third time because the words didn't seem to be doing what words were supposed to do.

He had testified truthfully. He had said what he did and why he did it, in the plainest language he owned, and he had not once said the phrase that would have made it easier: he had not said the words *I trusted him.* He had said *I chose to keep working.* There was a difference, and the difference was everything, and Han had caught it and had asked him about it twice and had let it stand.

The foreman signed. The court reporter signed. Benjamin signed at the bottom, his name in the same fountain-pen carefulness his mother had taught him, and handed the pen back to a clerk who put it in a plastic bag and handed him a different pen and a different page and asked him to sign that too.

Outside the courthouse the July air was thick with exhaust and the kind of heat that comes off stone, and the press was a wall of cameras on the far sidewalk behind a police barricade. Benjamin came down the steps slowly, hands empty, and did not look at them.

Nicolas was by the fountain, in a blue shirt with the sleeves rolled to the elbow, no jacket despite the heat advisory, hands in his pockets. He had been in the building all day, in a room on the fourth floor with a lawyer whose name Benjamin was still not entirely sure of, being asked his own six questions in his own six ways. They had not spoken since the Paramus hotel, since the phone call, since *the debt is settled and I'm taking the evening train.*

Benjamin stopped an arm's length away. The fountain behind Nicolas was the kind they built in the sixties and let go, green at the base, with a low spatter that kept the air around it a few degrees cooler.

"The immunity order came through," Benjamin said. "Your side's clear."

"I heard." Nicolas took his hands out of his pockets. He looked the way Benjamin had seen him look only twice before — the night at the club, and the morning after the search — composed on the surface, and underneath it something working, some calculation running that Benjamin had spent six years learning to read the way he read water stains and broken gutter cords.

"You testified honestly," Nicolas said.

"I told them what I knew."

"You told them you suspected in October."

"Yes."

"You could have said you didn't." Nicolas's voice was even. "You had every reason. They were never going to prove when the thought first crossed your mind — I've seen the emails, they're clean. You could have walked out of that room as a witness with a clean record and a story that didn't cost you anything. Han would have had nothing to use and nothing to charge."

"I know."

"So why didn't you?"

Benjamin looked at him. It was very hot on the steps of the courthouse, and his shirt was stuck to his back, and somewhere behind the police barricade a camera with a long lens was pointed at him and finding him uninteresting. He thought about the torn scrap of provenance in his coat pocket. He thought about the drawer in his studio. He thought about six years of a face he'd drawn into a manuscript's margin and then sewn shut.

"Because I kept working with you," Benjamin said. "That's what I did. It's the truth, and it's mine, and I don't want a version of it that isn't. I've spent my whole life re-backing old stories so they don't fall apart. I'm not going to do it to my own."

Nicolas looked at him for a long moment, and Benjamin watched the calculation finish and something else move into the space behind it, something the calculation had been running to avoid.

"You could have saved yourself," Nicolas said quietly. "Why didn't you?"

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 73: The Testimony · The Unbinding · Lumen Reads