The number on the card was a New Jersey landline, and it rang four times before a man picked up and said nothing.
"Mr. Vannier?"
"I don't know a Vannier." The voice was gravel poured slow, the vowels pushed flat by something Slavic. "You have the wrong number or the right one. Depends who's asking."
Benjamin stood at the kitchen window of his apartment, the card pinned under his thumb, Claire's words still in his head—a man called twice last year asking about a sketchbook. "My name is Benjamin Cole. I'm a book conservator. I'm calling about a sketchbook that came out of the Margaret Ellery estate in Hartsdale."
A pause, texture of it like a hand passing over cloth. "That so."
"I was told you consigned it. Through the Ellery estate, 1995."
"I consign many things," the man said. "Consigning is throwing a bottle in the water. Who it floats to is not my business and not my memory."
"Then it'll be easier than I thought. I'll let you go." Benjamin counted. The card had only a number. No name. Nicolas had said Vannier was a name he'd heard in a context he didn't like, then called the number himself twice and said nothing about what he got. "Unless you'd rather talk about who it floated to."
The laugh came then, one syllable, dry as a hinge. "You Americans. You think a question is a leash." Another pause. On the other end, a chair creaked. "Fine. I bought that sketchbook. Estate sale in eighty-nine, out of a storage lot in Yonkers. Box of children's things, nothing worth the gas. I kept it in a drawer eleven years. A man came to my shop in the city and paid cash. Took it off me for more than it was worth, which told me what I already knew."
"What did you already know?"
"That someone's heart was in it."
Benjamin put his palm flat on the counter. The refrigerator hummed. He could hear his own pulse behind it. "The man who bought it. Was it Ashford? N. Ashford."
"Mr. Ashford." The name came out of him slow, as though he were tasting it to see who owned it now. "Yes. He came alone. He paid in new bills, banded, and he did not ask for a receipt, which I found interesting. A man who does not want a receipt either has too much money or too much to hide."
"Or both."
"Or both," Sergei agreed, and for the first time the laugh almost reached him. "You are not a fool. I am sorry for that."
Benjamin said, "I'm looking for a boy named Julian. Eleven years old, 1994. He disappeared from a group home. The sketchbook was his."
The breathing on the line changed. Not a gasp—nothing so legible—but the rhythm thinned, went careful, the way a man goes careful when he has just decided not to say something. Benjamin heard it and knew he'd been right to say the name.
"Mr. Cole," Sergei said, and the gravel was gone, the voice was flat and empty. "Do not call this number again."
"Wait—"
The line clicked dead.
Nicolas had been standing at the window the whole time, one shoulder against the sash, sleeve pushed up, not moving. He didn't ask. He watched Benjamin set the phone face-down.
"Julian," Benjamin said. "I said Julian. He hung up."
Nicolas closed his eyes for a second. When he opened them, his face had gone still in a way Benjamin had stopped trusting and started reading. "Give me the card."
"You can't call him. He'll do the same thing."
"That card is mine. I never told you the name so you'd cold-call him."
"You never told me anything." Benjamin slid the card across the counter, and Nicolas picked it up and didn't look at it. "You knew Vannier. You knew the name and you fed me the Ellery lead like a bone so you wouldn't have to be the one holding it. So what was it? You buy the sketchbook from him, then the ledgers turn up burned, then you find me—"
"I didn't buy it from him."
The fridge hummed. Benjamin waited.
"I couldn't. I didn't have it." Nicolas turned the card over once, corner to corner, then laid it back down, aligning it with the edge of the counter like it had to sit straight. "He had the book, and he had a number for it that I couldn't meet. So I borrowed the money."
"From whom?"
"From him." Nicolas's mouth did something that wasn't a smile. "Forty thousand. New bills, banded, exactly the way he told you Ashford paid. I bought the sketchbook out of his own drawer with his own cash and paid him interest to hold the debt while I found out what I was actually holding. He liked that. That's the part that should frighten you—he liked it. He said it was the most interesting thing anyone had done to him in a decade."
Benjamin moved to the sink and turned on the water, then turned it off. "You still owe him."
"Yes."
"How much?"
"The principal and about a year of his patience, which is worse." Nicolas looked up, and for once there was nothing arranged in his face. "He's not a lender, Benjamin. He's a collector of people who owe him."