The diner on Tenth Avenue stayed open because the cab drivers needed it and the cab drivers needed it because it stayed open. At two in the morning the booths held four kinds of people: drivers on break, night-shift nurses, a couple of men who'd been drinking since ten and were now sober enough to be sad about it, and Nicolas Ashford, who ordered coffee he didn't drink and unfolded a napkin flat against the formica like it was a document he intended to notarize.
Benjamin sat across from him with his coat still on. His hands hadn't stopped shaking since the call, and he'd decided the coffee was a bad idea for exactly that reason, so he'd ordered it too, and now they had two coffees going cold between them like a peace treaty neither side had signed.
"You start," Nicolas said.
"You start."
"I asked first."
"You didn't." Benjamin looked at him. Under the diner's fluorescent light Nicolas looked younger and worse than he did in the townhouse—no tailoring to hide behind, no room doing the talking. His collar was open. There was a coffee ring on the napkin already, a perfect brown annulus, and he was staring at it like it had said something.
"Fine." Benjamin took a pen out of his inside pocket. He always had one. A conservator's habit, like always knowing where the scalpel was. He flattened a second napkin and wrote, in small neat capitals: `PHOTOGRAPH.`
"Photograph," Nicolas read.
"Photograph," Benjamin said. He drew a line under it. "It's me."
Nicolas didn't move. That was the thing about him—Benjamin had noticed it across four days now—he didn't flinch. He went still, which was worse, because still you could read if you knew how. The pen went down. The napkin sat there between them with four letters on it that Benjamin had never said out loud to another living person, not his mother, not the woman who'd raised him, not anyone, because until eleven days ago there had been no photograph, as far as Benjamin Cole was concerned. The blank had been repaired so well even he couldn't see the seam.
"How old," Nicolas said.
"Six. Maybe seven. It's a school photograph, the kind they take against a gray backdrop with your hands folded. There's a boy in it with a bowl haircut and a scrape on his chin and I know the scrape because I remember falling off a swing." He heard his own voice go flat and clinical. That was what happened when it got close—he went clinical. "The enrollment number on the back is the same typeface as the marginal codes in the ledger. I checked."
"You've had it since—"
"Chapter and verse, I've had nothing. I don't remember Hartsdale. I don't remember a group home. I don't remember a Julian, or a sketchbook, or anyone named Margaret Ellery. I was placed with the Coles as an infant, that's the story. That's always been the story." He tapped the napkin. "Only I'm not an infant in this photograph. Am I."
Nicolas reached for his coffee, remembered it was cold, put it down. "No."
"No."
The waitress came by and they both said nothing and she filled the cups because that was her job and left because that was also her job. Steam came up off both. Neither of them drank.
"Your turn," Benjamin said.
Nicolas turned his napkin over and wrote, in handwriting that was worse than his clothes: `VANCE.`
"Nicholas Vance," he said. "That's the name I was born with. There's a birth certificate in a bank box in Albany with Nicholas Vance on it, and a driver's license that expired in 2016, and a mother in Rhinebeck who thinks I run a gallery."
"And Ashford?"
"Ashford is a man who died in 2011. He had a collection, a bad heart, and no children, and I bought his name the way you'd buy a bookshelf—through a lawyer, in installments, over eighteen months. It cost more than the book." He said it without pride. "You can't collect what I collect under your own name. People remember you. People ask who you are, and then they look you up, and then they find the brother, and then they ask about the brother, and then—" He stopped. Started again, quieter. "Sergei knew me as Vance. That's how he had my number for a year before I ever called it."
Benjamin looked at the two napkins. His said PHOTOGRAPH. Nicolas's said VANCE. Between them, forty thousand dollars' worth of debt and a dead man's name and a boy who fell off a swing thirty years ago and had it taken out of him.
"I don't believe you," Benjamin said.
"I know."
"I'm saying it out loud. I don't believe the Rhinebeck mother or the bank box. I believe the part where you lied to me for four days about how you got the sketchbook, because that part's consistent. You lie about logistics. That's the tell." He turned the pen around in his fingers. "But this is the first conversation we've had where you didn't try to sell me on anything, so."
"Ground rules," Nicolas said.
"Ground rules."
He wrote them on the third napkin. He didn't write slow, but he didn't write fast either, and Benjamin watched the pen move and understood that this man had spent a decade or more being very careful about what got written down where, and that he was doing it now in front of a stranger at two in the morning by choice. Or by something that looked like choice from the outside.
1. No secrets about the book.
2. No lies about who we are.
3. Either can walk.
Benjamin read it. Then he took the pen and added, beneath, in the same small capitals:
4. What we find, we share. Both of us. Before we touch it.
Nicolas read it and looked at him for a long moment. "That's the harder one."
"I know."
"That one's going to be the one we break."
"Probably," Benjamin said. "Sign it anyway."
They didn't laugh. It wasn't that kind of two in the morning. But something shifted at the table, some pressure equalizing, the way a room does when the heat comes on and you hadn't known how cold you'd been. Nicolas picked up the napkin and held it a moment, turning it so the light caught the ink, and Benjamin understood with a sudden unwelcome clarity that Nicolas was filing it. Categorizing it. Deciding where among his ledgers and boxes and buried names this scrap of paper would live, and what it would be worth to him, and for what.
Then he put it down and put his hand out over the salt shaker, palm flat, like a man closing a deal he intended to honor for as long as honoring it cost him nothing.
Benjamin shook it. The hand was colder than the diner.
Neither of them said anything about believing the other would keep the deal, because neither of them did, and they both knew the other knew, and there was a kind of rest in that. The lie would have been in saying it out loud.
"Thursday," Nicolas said, "you said the archivist at the auction house flagged us. Names will be in a log. It's a small world, this world." He let go of Benjamin's hand and sat back. "You should know that whatever we do next, Sergei will hear about the call. He hangs up on people he intends to deal with later. He's patient. It's the worst thing about him."
"He said someone's heart was in it."
Nicolas's face did the still thing again. "He said that?"
"He said it about the book. Right before he hung up."
"Sergei doesn't say things he doesn't mean."
"I got that."
The diner had emptied out while they talked. The two sad men had left. A single cab driver slept upright in the far booth with his cap over his face, and the waitress was counting tips at the register with the unhurried competence of someone for whom 2 a.m. was noon. Outside the window Tenth Avenue was wet and the light on it was the particular yellow of streetlamps that need replacing. Snow, maybe. Not yet.
Benjamin folded the napkin with PHOTOGRAPH on it and put it in his pocket next to the onion-skin page, which was still there, which Nicolas still didn't know about, which meant ground rule number one had already been broken by about six hours and a width of cotton fabric. He told himself he'd tell him tomorrow. He told himself that in the specific tone you use on yourself when you know the bill is coming and you've decided to spend the money anyway.
"You never said why you brought it to me," he said. "The book. Out of every conservator in the city. You had it for a year and you sat on it and then you walked it into my studio, and you knew my name before I said it. That's not in the napkins."
Nicolas stood and put on his coat. He did it slowly, one arm then the other, like a man reassembling himself.
"No," he said. "It isn't."
"Rule one."
"I know."
"Then."
Nicolas looked down at him, and for a second—one second, held up against the fluorescent hum and the smell of old bacon—he looked like he was going to say it. Benjamin saw the shape of the sentence come up in him. Saw it sit there, fully formed, with a weight to it. Waited.
"When I tell you that," Nicolas said, "you're going to wish I hadn't. So let me spend a little while longer as the man who hired you."
He put money on the table, too much, and walked out into the cold without looking back, and the bell over the door told the whole diner he'd gone.
Benjamin sat with the two cold coffees and the salt shaker and the sleeping cab driver, and after a while the waitress came over and cleared the cups, and he ordered a third that he also didn't drink, because staying in the warm lit room where he hadn't had to be anyone yet was, for the next twenty minutes, the only thing he could think to do.