The Understudy's Kiss

Chapter 40: The Lighter's Story

The lighter sat on Émile's kitchen table between them, next to two glasses of red that neither of them had touched. Raphaël had set it down there himself, unasked, when they got back from the shop — the shop with its empty window and its little hand-written sign.

"Tell me," Émile said.

Raphaël turned the lighter over. Brass, worn smooth at the corners, a scratched-out monogram on the base. Not expensive. The kind you buy at a tabac and keep for fifteen years.

"I was twenty-four," Raphaël said. "No. Twenty-three. I'd just finished my second film and everyone was telling me I was going to be huge, and I believed them, and I was —" He stopped, looked for the word. "Unbearable. I was unbearable and I was terrified, and every night I went somewhere no one could see me, because if anyone saw me being the person I actually was, it was over. That's what I thought. It was over."

"You were closeted."

"I was a locked room. I wasn't even closeted, I was — entombed." He laughed, one syllable, no humor in it. "My agent at the time had a list. Things I couldn't do in public. One of them was go to small theatre in the eleventh. Because small theatre is where people *watch* you. They notice who you brought."

Émile kept still. He had learned, in the past days, that stillness was the only honest thing he could offer.

"I went anyway," Raphaël said. "Once. I picked a night when the listing said the house was small and the cast was unknown. Genet. *Les Paravents*. It had been in the paper because the director was some woman nobody had heard of who was doing it in a basement with nine actors and no budget. That was you."

"That was me," Émile said. His voice came out flat. He remembered the basement. He remembered the smell of it — damp, then dust, then bodies. It seated about forty if you squeezed. He remembered his costume had been dyed in a bathtub.

"You were the third soldier," Raphaël said. "You came in from the back of the house, from between the audience, and you walked through them like they weren't there. And when you spoke, no one in that room was breathing. I was sitting in the second row, wearing a hat and a scarf in March, like an idiot, and I didn't move for two hours."

"It was a bad production."

"It was a great production." Raphaël's thumb moved over the brass. "I didn't understand half of it. The play's enormous. But I understood you. That's the thing. I don't even know how to say it — I understood that you were doing something that cost you something. That you had put everything you had into a basement on a Tuesday because there was nowhere else to put it. And I sat there in my scarf and I thought: *that's what it is. That's what it's supposed to be.*"

Émile watched the lighter. He could not look at Raphaël's face while Raphaël said this; it was too much, like staring into a lamp.

"So I came back the next night," Raphaël said. "And the night after. Four times, over the run. I never spoke to anyone. I sat in the back for the last two."

"Four times."

"I could have come back a fifth. I didn't." He set the lighter down. "The last night, I stayed after. Everyone left. The actors were in the back, drinking. I stood in the empty house for a long time, and I put this on the seat where I'd been sitting, and I left."

Émile picked it up. It was lighter than he remembered. He turned it to the base. The monogram had been scratched out with something sharp — long ago, before he found it.

"Why the base?"

"Because you'd never look at my face. You'd look at the object. If someone found it, it was nothing. If *you* found it, it was —" Raphaël shrugged. "It was a secret tribute. I told myself it was for you. It wasn't. It was for me. It was me saying to an empty room, *here is a thing I actually felt, and I'm putting it somewhere, and I'm not going to ask for anything back.*"

The ceiling light buzzed faintly. Somewhere below, a motorcycle went down the street. Émile turned the lighter over and over, and the room seemed to have moved, quietly, an inch to the left.

"I found it two days later," he said.

"I know. I read about it."

"*Read* about it?"

"There was a blog." Raphaël almost smiled. "Some student. He wrote that on the last night of *Les Paravents*, at Le Trou, an actor had stood in the empty house for twenty minutes holding a lighter he'd found on a seat, and that it was the most actor thing he had ever seen. I read it eleven times. I saved it. It's still in my phone."

Émile put the lighter down. Then he got up and walked to the window and stood there with his back to the room. Outside, the street was ordinary. A woman was taking out the recycling. The world had no idea any of this had happened.

"Why didn't you come back," he said to the glass.

"To the theatre?"

"To me. After that night. If you understood —" He turned. "You were there four times. You said you understood what I was doing. And then you *left*, and you didn't come back for ten years, and the next time I saw you, you were on the poster of the Passerelle looking at me like we'd never met."

"I was scared."

"You were famous."

"I was scared *because* I was famous." Raphaël stood up too. He didn't come closer; he stayed on his side of the table, and Émile understood that this was deliberate, that Raphaël was giving him the room. "You have to understand what it was like then. I was one bad photograph away from losing a career that everybody was building for me. And that night in the basement — I sat there and I thought, *if I talk to this person, I will not be able to lie anymore.* And I wasn't ready to stop lying. So I left. And the lighter was — it was the part of me that *was* ready, and I sent that part of me in alone, because I couldn't go with it."

Émile picked up his wine. He drank, finally, a long swallow, and it tasted of nothing.

"You could have told me on the poster," he said.

"I thought about it every day of rehearsal. I told myself you wouldn't remember."

"I *didn't* remember. That's what you were hoping for."

"Yes."

"And you were in my dressing room. You sat on my sofa and pretended to be a stranger."

"I wasn't pretending. I was —" Raphaël's jaw worked. "I couldn't be both things. I couldn't be the man who was there and also be the man on the poster in the lobby. So I only brought the poster. It's the same thing you do. Don't look at me like that, Émile, it's exactly the same thing you do. You don't have a violin and a father in Lisbon and a building that's being sold. You have a version of yourself that everyone gets, and everything else you carry to the door and leave outside."

Émile set the glass down hard.

"Don't do that."

"I'm not doing anything. I'm answering your question."

"You're making it even."

"No," Raphaël said. "I'm not. There's nothing even about this. I walked into your life holding a lie and you walked into mine holding a different one, and the two of us have been standing here for six weeks pretending we're professionals."

The word landed. *Six weeks.* The contract. The run. The thing with an end date printed on it, which was now shorter than the lie had been long.

"Monday," Émile said.

"Monday," Raphaël said.

"He'll be there. Beaumont. With my father's violin on a table next to him, and a microphone, and he'll —" Émile stopped.

"And he'll what?"

"I don't know. He collects things. That's what he does. He collected Le Trou, once, for about a season. He put money into it and then he came to the last performance and afterward he wanted to buy the space. My father said no." He was telling it plainly, as if reading a document. "He bought the building six months later through a company and kicked us out. That's why the theatre ended. That's why my father left. Beaumont has spent his whole life buying the things he could never make."

Raphaël went very still.

"You never told me that."

"I never told you anything."

"You told me about Le Trou. About Antoine. You didn't tell me about him."

"I forgot to." Émile heard how it sounded. "I didn't forget. I decided not to. It's the same as everything else tonight. I decided not to, and then I sat in this kitchen and let you say the true thing first, because evidently I only know how to be found out."

Raphaël crossed the room. He did it slowly, one hand half-raised, and stopped an arm's length away, which was as close as the room allowed.

"Monday," he said. "Beaumont will be on the other side of the table from us. The violin will be on that table. And Sylvie has told Radio France that we'll answer, live, whether we're together."

"Yes."

"So before Monday, I need to know one thing from you, Émile, and I need it to be true. When you walked into that basement in 2015, and when you stood in the empty house holding that lighter, and when you walked onto the Passerelle stage in front of a full house —" He took a breath. "Was any of it ever for you? Or was it all for the room?"

Émile looked down at the lighter on the table, scratched-out monogram, fourteen years of brass.

"Ask me again on Monday," he said. "In front of the microphone."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 40: The Lighter's Story · The Understudy's Kiss · Lumen Reads