The Understudy's Kiss

Chapter 48: The Violin Returns

Raphaël was waiting outside the stage door when Émile came down the alley at half past seven, and he was holding the violin case.

Émile stopped ten feet away. The morning was gray and cold, the kind of Paris morning that smelled like wet stone, and the alley was empty except for a stack of flats from the last production, a broken chair, and Raphaël, who stood with his collar up and the case held in both hands like something he'd been carrying a long way.

"You bought it," Émile said.

"Yes."

"From Vasseur. On rue de Rome. The day I consigned it."

"Yes."

"You knew I was going there."

"I saw the receipt."

Émile felt the words land somewhere behind his ribs. "You went through my things."

Raphaël didn't flinch. "I was worried."

"You were *worried*."

"You'd stopped eating lunch. You were counting on your fingers in the corridor like a man doing sums that don't work. And then one morning there was a receipt on your kitchen table for a violin appraisal, and the case was gone from the top of your wardrobe, and you came to rehearsal with your hands shaking. So yes. I went through your kitchen. I'm not proud of it and I'm not sorry."

Émile's hands were shaking now. He hated that Raphaël could see it. He put them in his coat pockets.

"You can't do things like that," he said.

"I know."

"You can't—" He stopped. He watched the case in Raphaël's hands, the same scuffed leather, the same brass catch he'd oiled himself every winter, the same little gouge near the handle where a chair had fallen on it when he was fourteen and his mother had said, *that's her first scar, now she's really ours.* "I needed the money. That's what the violin was for. It was a thing I owned, and I sold it, and now I have nothing, and you've made it so I have nothing *and* I owe you."

"You don't owe me."

"It was thirty-two thousand. I saw the number on the tag."

"Twenty-nine. Vasseur took a commission. He didn't want to, but I insisted, because a private purchase at full price would have looked like exactly what it was." Raphaël's voice was even. He was good at this. Émile had watched him hold a close-up for eleven seconds without blinking; of course he could stand in a wet alley and say the hardest sentence of the year without a tremor. "You don't owe me a centime, Émile. I bought it because it was yours and I couldn't—"

"You couldn't *what*."

"Watch you sell the last thing your mother gave you to pay for a lie she never asked you to participate in."

The words went through Émile like a draft under a door. He turned and walked a few steps down the alley, turned back. The alley smelled of diesel and rainwater. Somewhere above them a shutter banged.

"You had no right," he said.

"I know."

"You had no right to decide what I get to lose."

"I know."

"Then why did you do it?"

"Because I was standing in your kitchen and I read that receipt and I did the arithmetic, and every version of that arithmetic ended with you having nothing. And I thought—" Raphaël stopped. He looked down at the case, then up at Émile, and his face did the thing it did when he forgot to act, when the perfection dropped away and there was just a man in a coat, thirty-nine years old, standing in an alley holding a violin that didn't belong to him. "I thought, if I can stop one thing, I'll stop one thing. That's all. I wasn't trying to save you. I was trying to stop one thing."

"That's the same thing."

"It isn't."

"It is, Raphaël."

"Then tell me the difference and I'll say it back to you."

Émile opened his mouth. Nothing came. The shutter banged again, and a scooter went by at the mouth of the alley, and Émile looked at the case and felt the anger and the other thing, the thing underneath it, the thing he did not have a word for and did not want to look at directly, the way you don't look directly at a light when you're driving at night.

"You can't afford it," he said at last. "Thirty-two thousand is not nothing. Even for you."

"It's not nothing."

"Then you shouldn't have—"

"I could," Raphaël said. "So I did. That's all it was." He held the case out. "Take it."

Émile didn't move. "I don't want to take it."

"Take it anyway."

"I don't want to be the man who takes it."

"Then be the man who takes it later," Raphaël said, "but the case is heavy and my arm is tired, so be that man now."

Émile laughed. It came out wrong, half a cough, but it was a laugh, and he was furious with himself for it. He stepped forward and took the case. The leather was cold. His fingers closed around the handle and found the familiar gouge, the small rough place, and he felt something in his chest loosen and tighten at the same time, a screw going both directions.

"You should have asked me," he said.

"I know."

"You should have asked me and I would have said no."

"I know."

"And you would have—"

"I don't know what I would have done," Raphaël said. "I honestly don't. That's why I didn't ask. I didn't want to find out what I'd do if you said no."

The wind came up the alley and Émile's eyes stung. He told himself it was the wind. He put the case against his leg and stood there in the gray light and did not look at Raphaël's face.

"There's a broadcast on Monday," he said finally. "Beaumont wants a second guest on the panel. Unnamed. He won't say who until we're on air."

Raphaël was quiet for a beat. "You think it's me."

"I think it's a card he's been holding since the photograph. I think he knows about the violin. He texted me that Sylvie knows where it was appraised. He wants me to ask her before Monday."

"And did you?"

"Not yet."

Raphaël nodded slowly. "Then that's today's problem," he said. "The violin was yesterday's. You have it back. That one's closed."

"It isn't closed. Nothing about it is closed."

"It's closed *enough*," Raphaël said. "Take it home after rehearsal. Put it back on top of the wardrobe where it lives. Then we can argue about who I am to you, and whether I had the right, and what it means that I did it, and I will lose that argument, Émile, I already know I'll lose it, but I'd rather lose it in a warm room than in this alley."

Émile looked at him. The anger was still there, hot and square in his chest. But underneath it, moving, the other thing had a name now, a name he still wasn't going to say. He picked up the case and turned toward the stage door.

"Inside," he said. "It's cold."

Raphaël followed him in. The door swung shut behind them and cut off the alley, and the theatre swallowed them up in its smell of dust and rosin and cold radiators, and Émile was already thinking about Monday, about the second guest, about the fact that he had spent all night typing a message to a man he hated and had gotten no answer yet—when his phone buzzed in his pocket.

He set the case down against the wall and looked at the screen.

An unknown number. No name. Just a single line.

*Mme Laurent-Michel will do nicely, don't you think? I'll have her introduce herself on air.*

Émile read it twice. Then he looked up at Raphaël, who was watching him with his coat still on, who had bought back a violin he had no right to buy, who was standing there waiting to be told what the message said.

Émile turned the phone around and showed him.

"Who's Madame Laurent-Michel?" Raphaël asked.

Émile put the phone back in his pocket. His voice, when it came, was very quiet.

"My mother."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 48: The Violin Returns · The Understudy's Kiss · Lumen Reads