The violin case lived at the back of Émile's closet, behind the winter coat he never wore and a shoebox of programs he'd stopped adding to years ago. He pulled it out on a Tuesday morning, before rehearsal, when the apartment was empty and Raphaël was at a fitting in the Marais. He hadn't opened it in eleven months. He knew what he'd find: the velvet lining gone bald at the chin rest, the varnish worn to bare wood along the ribs, the crack above the f-hole his mother had glued herself with hide glue she'd warmed on the stove.
His mother had played it in the orchestra of a provincial opera house for twenty-six years. She'd taught him his first scales on a half-size instrument, then this one when he was thirteen. It was the only thing she'd left him that he'd kept.
He sat on the floor with the case across his knees and did the math in his head. He'd done it in his head for three weeks, because putting it on paper made it real. Forty-one thousand euros of debt. The bulk of it from the acting school he'd left halfway through, the rest from a bad year of rent he'd covered with a loan at nineteen percent. He'd been paying it down for six years, and the balance had barely moved.
The theatre's ticket sales had fallen to nineteen a day. The grant from the ministry was contingent on attendance figures from the autumn season. Beaumont's committee decided those figures in January.
The violin was worth maybe fifty, fifty-five thousand. His mother had refused to have it appraised, said it was bad luck to price a thing you loved.
Émile called the shop on the rue de Rome instead of thinking about it longer. He'd walked past it a hundred times. A man with glasses and a bad shoulder answered on the second ring.
"You appraise?" Émile asked.
"We appraise, we consign, we buy," the man said. "Bring it in."
"I want a number on the phone."
"I don't do numbers on the phone."
"It's a Guadagnini. Back and ribs, table's not original. Crack above the f-hole repaired with hide glue. I want a range."
A pause. "Bring it in and I'll give you eighty percent of a range on the spot."
Émile wrapped the violin in a sweater and put it in the case and took the metro to rue de Rome. The shop was narrow, the walls hung with instruments, and the smell of rosin and old wood hit him at the door like a room he'd grown up in. The man with the glasses took the violin onto a felt pad and turned it over twice. He tapped the back. He looked through the f-holes. He held it up to the window light and held it a long time.
"Nineteen fifty," he said finally. "Milan school. Not Guadagnini. But a good one."
"What's it worth?"
"To the right buyer, forty. To me, thirty-two. The table's been replaced, that's the problem. Whoever did the repair was good but they were working with what they had."
Thirty-two thousand. He'd been hoping for more, but he'd known. He'd known when he said Guadagnini out loud that he was trying to make it into something it wasn't. His mother had never lied about the violin. She'd said it was a good instrument that had been made in a city she'd never seen by someone whose name she didn't know.
"I'll take it," Émile said. "Can you do it today?"
"I can do it today. Papers, ID, bank details. You want cash?"
"Transfer."
The man nodded and went into the back. Émile stood among the instruments on the walls, a cello with a chestnut belly, a row of student violins no better than the one he'd learned on, and he counted to sixty and back. Thirty-two thousand covered most of the debt. The rest he could cover with the small savings his agent had been nagging him about, the account he'd ignored for two years because opening it meant looking at the number.
"Sign here," the man said, coming back with a form. "And here. Bank details."
Émile filled in the boxes. His hand was steady, which surprised him. He'd expected it to shake. "How long before it goes?"
"Depends. I have a buyer list. Could be a week, could be three months."
"I'd rather not know when."
"We don't call. That's the rule." The man slid the form across. "You're sure? You don't have to be sure. That's not part of the deal."
"I'm sure."
He left the case on the counter and walked out. It was raining. He stood under the awning of a pharmacy and didn't move for a long time, and when he touched his face it was wet, which he blamed on the rain.
He didn't tell Raphaël. He told himself it was because Raphaël was at the fitting and he didn't want to interrupt, and then he told himself it was because the decision was made and talking about it wouldn't change it, and by the time Raphaël came home that evening and asked how rehearsal had gone, Émile was almost able to believe both.
He slept badly. He dreamed of the violin on the wall of the shop, gathering dust beside the student instruments, and woke at four with his heart going and lay still until the alarm.
The second thought came in the morning. The shop had said consignment, but it might have meant a direct sale to a buyer they already had. He could call. One call, a week early, and know.
He called at ten, before rehearsal.
The man answered with the same bored patience. "Yes?"
"This is Émile Rousseau. I brought you a violin yesterday. The Milan school."
"The one with the replaced table."
"That one. I'd like to know if you've placed it."
"You said you didn't want to know."
"I changed my mind."
The man was quiet for a moment. "It's already sold."
Émile's hand tightened on the phone. "Already. It's been one day."
"It was a standing order. I called a client yesterday afternoon after you left. He came in first thing this morning."
"First thing."
"Nine o'clock. Paid the asking. Didn't even look at the crack."
Émile closed his eyes. There was a buzzing in his ears, low and constant, like a light that wouldn't switch off. "Tell me what he looked like."
"Don't do that."
"I'm asking."
The man exhaled. He sounded tired, not defensive. "Tall. Dark hair, cut close. Good coat. He asked if I'd contact the seller and tell him it was gone, and I told him the rule, and he said he'd tell him himself." A pause. "That's all I'm going to say. I don't like being in the middle."
Émile hadn't said the name out loud, and neither had the man, and there was no need. He knew the coat. He knew the hair. He'd seen the shape of it in a doorway at six in the morning a week ago, and he'd seen it turn in the lobby of the theatre every day since.
He thanked the man and hung up and stood in the middle of his own kitchen.
He put his phone down on the counter and picked it up again. He scrolled to the message thread and read the last line Raphaël had sent the night before — *see you tonight, sleep well* — and then he sat on the floor with his back against the cabinets, the same way he'd sat with the case on his knees yesterday, and tried to decide what he was.
Angry was easy. Angry was available. Raphaël had gone through his things, or he'd seen the receipt, or he'd followed him — any of it was a violation. Angry was a wall he could put his back against.
But under the anger there was the other thing, the one that had no shape yet. Someone had walked into a shop at nine in the morning and paid forty thousand euros for a violin with a replaced table and a crack above the f-hole, a violin no musician would want, which meant it had never been about the violin. It had been about stop. Stop selling it. Stop being the person who has to sell it.
Émile picked up the phone and texted the unknown number. *You asked if I could keep a secret until Monday. I'll need to hear the offer first.*
Then he stood, and washed his face, and took his coat, and left for the theatre, where Raphaël would be waiting — and where he would have to decide, in the next hour, whether to say anything about the violin at all.