The Understudy's Kiss

Chapter 80: The Real First Date

The waiter brought the second carafe without being asked, and Raphaël poured for both of them before Émile could reach for it.

"You're a terrible pourer," Émile said.

"I'm an excellent pourer."

"You've been holding the bottle at the wrong angle all night."

Raphaël set the carafe down and looked at him with an expression of genuine offense. "The wrong angle."

"The neck should be over the glass, not beside it. You've been splashing the tablecloth since the first glass."

Raphaël looked down at the tablecloth. There was, in fact, a small dark constellation of wine stains around his place setting. He looked back up at Émile. "That was the first carafe. I've improved."

"You have not improved."

"I've improved emotionally."

Émile laughed — a real one, low and quick — and it startled him, because he'd been counting how many times he'd laughed like that in the last hour and it was more than he'd laughed in the last year. The bistro had emptied around them without him noticing. The corner table had become theirs in the way a room becomes yours when you forget the door exists.

He'd asked the first real question before the wine arrived. Where did you want to be when you were nine. And Raphaël had answered without hedging, the way he answered everything now, as if the performance of himself had been left in the dressing room along with the costume.

A house by the sea that belonged to a painter nobody in his family could name. He'd spent two summers there as a child, and there had been a room with a north-facing window, and he'd wanted to be the person who made the light in that room permanent.

"Painter," Émile said. "You've never said that."

"I've never been asked that." Raphaël turned his glass slowly. "I was good. Not great. But I wanted it — I wanted it the way you want things when you're nine and nobody's told you yet that wanting isn't enough. Then my mother put me in front of a camera, and there was a different kind of window, and the light was already made for me. I stopped painting around fourteen. I couldn't hold both."

"Do you still have any of them?"

"Two. In a drawer in my apartment. Both bad." He smiled at the tablecloth. "I look at them sometimes when I can't sleep. They're proof I was someone before I was this."

Émile turned his glass and didn't say anything, because there was a thing in his chest that didn't have words yet, only weight.

"Your turn," Raphaël said. "The first real question. What were you afraid of when you were nine?"

"Everything."

"Be specific."

Émile considered lying. The habit was old and deep and it took a second to notice it had risen. He set it down.

"Being forgotten," he said. "Not — being unloved. Being forgotten. My grandmother was sick for a long time when I was small, and my mother stopped saying my name. Not because she didn't love me. Because she didn't have the room in her head. But I remember standing in the kitchen doorway waiting to be seen, and it went on for months. I learned that if I didn't perform — if I didn't do something worth watching — I would disappear. That I could disappear. That no one would notice."

Raphaël's hand had stopped turning the glass. He was very still.

"That's why you're so good on stage," he said.

"That's why I'm so good on stage."

"Do you know that's the first time you've told me something true without dressing it up?"

Émile looked at him. "Is it?"

"The first night we met, in the rehearsal room, you told me your whole biography and none of it was true. Every time I've asked you something since, you've answered with a performance of an answer. Tonight is the first night you've been in the room." Raphaël said it without hurt in it. Just as a fact he'd observed and kept.

"You're one to talk."

"I know. I'm the same. That's my point." Raphaël leaned back. "Two people who have been performing their whole lives sitting at a table after the show is closed, and neither of us knows how to stop. So we keep doing it, but we do it at each other now. It's —" He searched for the word. "Unsustainable."

"Your publicist said you only speak in absolutes."

"My publicist has never been right about anything." Raphaël drained the last of the wine. "What do you want, Émile. Not what do you want tomorrow. I mean when it's quiet. What do you want."

And Émile opened his mouth to give a clean, competent answer — and instead said, "I write."

Raphaël blinked. "Write what."

"Poetry. Since I was fifteen. I've never —" Émile's throat went dry. He hadn't told anyone. Not his mother, not his oldest friend at the Company, not a single person alive. "No one knows. I have notebooks. Twelve of them. They're not good. They're not for anybody. They're for me to stay in the room."

Raphaël didn't move. He didn't reach across the table, didn't make a sound. He just looked at Émile with an entirely open face — no performance, no edit — and said, "I want to hear one."

"No."

"When you're ready."

"Never."

"When you're ready," Raphaël repeated, easily, and that was worse. That was worse than if he'd been teasing, because he'd let Émile keep the room and still left the light on.

They argued about the bill for six minutes.

Émile took out his card first. Raphaël's hand came down on it.

"I paid at the theatre. Tonight is mine."

"You paid for rehearsal space in September and you still haven't let me split it."

"September is a different life. That man is dead."

"Pay for September and I'll pay tonight."

"You can't negotiate retroactively. It's against the rules."

"There are no rules. There's just a waiter who wants to go home."

The waiter, who had been standing near the bar with the patience of a man who had seen this exact scene many times before, eventually took Émile's card — because Raphaël, in the middle of arguing about a bottle of wine, had looked directly at Émile for slightly too long, and Émile had used that half second to hand the card over. Raphaël noticed, opened his mouth, and then closed it and laughed.

"You cheated."

"You performed. I moved. That's the whole difference between us."

"Fine. Then coffee is mine tomorrow."

"Tomorrow."

"Tomorrow," Raphaël said. And nothing in the way he said it sounded like the plan they'd deferred all night. It sounded like a fact. It sounded like a door he'd already walked through.

They stayed another forty minutes without ordering anything. The bistro dimmed its lights above the bar. Émile learned that Raphaël was afraid of silence at three in the morning, and that he couldn't sleep on his left side, and that he'd once broken his own thumb slamming a trailer door, and that he had never, in twenty-six years of public life, admitted to anyone that he'd been lonely as a child. Raphaël learned that Émile's father had died when he was eleven and left no recording of his voice, and that Émile could not remember what his father sounded like but could perfectly remember the way he hummed, and that he still hummed it while walking to the theatre, alone, only when no one was near.

The waiter put the chairs up on the tables near the door. The night had thickened outside. Somewhere past the glass, Paris kept going without them.

"Walk me home," Raphaël said.

"It's the other direction."

"I know. Walk me home anyway."

Émile stood. He picked up his coat from the back of the chair and put it on, and Raphaël watched him do it — all of it, the slow ordinary business of a man putting on his coat — and Émile felt it, and didn't mind being seen.

They stepped outside into the cold. The street ran one way toward the river. Without saying a word, both of them turned the way that would take longer.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 80: The Real First Date · The Understudy's Kiss · Lumen Reads