Saturday morning came in grey and stayed there. Louis had the market stall up by half six — folding table, chalkboard, two trays of buns under cling film, a hand-painted sign that said ASHWORTH BUN: THE ORIGINAL. He had painted it at midnight and regretted the word original before the paint was dry. Harry's stall was four pitches down, past the cheese man and the woman who sold pickles out of a wheelbarrow. Louis could see the top of his sign from here. He made himself stop looking at it.
The blogger arrived at ten, which Louis knew because she announced herself.
"Talia Ncube, Manc Eats. Fourteen thousand followers." She had a phone on a gimbal and a tote bag with three different notebooks in it. "So. You two. The bun wars. I want to do a blind tasting. Both buns, two trays, the public decides. I'll film it, I'll post it tonight, and you both get the exposure. If you say yes now I can have it up on the website by one."
"No," said Louis.
"Yes," said Harry, who had walked over without Louis noticing, and was standing at the end of the table with his hands in his apron pockets like he'd been invited.
Louis turned on him. "You don't get to answer for me."
"I'm not answering for you. I'm answering for me." Harry looked at Talia. "I'm in. He's going to say no because he thinks a taste test is a legal proceeding and he can win on paperwork."
"I said no."
"Then it's not a bake-off, it's a statement," said Talia, phone already up, red light on. "That's fine. I'll write the other piece instead. The one about the trademark. Is that what you want?"
Louis counted to three. Somewhere behind him a woman was buying three buns with a five-pound note and asking her kid which one he wanted.
"Fine," he said. "Blind tasting. Both trays. Nothing on the packaging either way."
"Nothing on the packaging either way," Harry agreed, and went back to his stall.
They put the buns out at eleven on two identical boards, turned so the labels faced away, and Talia went through the queue with her gimbal asking people to point at the one they'd buy again. Louis stood with his arms folded and watched strangers chew his mother's recipe.
At noon, Harry said, "They're the same bread."
Louis had been about to say it himself for twenty minutes and hadn't, because saying it to Harry felt like handing something over.
They weren't identical. They were a hair apart — Louis's glaze went on hotter and set with a shellac shine, Harry's crumb was a shade more open, like the dough had been left ten minutes longer and never apologised for it. But underneath the two buns was one bun. The same sweetness, the same citrus in the back of it, the same faint bitterness that Louis had never been able to place in eighteen years of making it. He had assumed it was his mother. Family hand, family quirk. Something she picked up from her mother and never wrote down.
"What's in yours," Louis said. Not a question.
"Milk. Butter. Orange zest, but only a little, because too much and you've ruined it."
Louis's chest did something cold. "There's lemon in mine."
"There's lemon in mine," Harry said. "There's lemon in mine, I just don't advertise it, because when you put lemon on the card people think it's a lemon bun and it's not a bloody lemon bun."
"How long have you been making it."
"Nine years."
Louis had made it for fourteen. Neither number meant anything on its own. Together they meant something and Louis did not want to know what.
"Who taught you," he said.
Harry looked at him properly for the first time that morning. "Why."
"Because I'm asking."
"She ran a bakery course out of a church hall in Chorlton. Six Saturdays. I was eighteen and I was shit at it and she kept me back after the fifth one and told me the lemon was the whole trick and I wasn't to tell anybody." Harry stopped. His face had gone still in a way Louis hadn't seen on him — on him it looked like damage, not anger.
"Mrs. Okonkwo," Louis said.
Harry didn't answer for a long moment. Then: "You."
"Three years later. The church hall. Same six Saturdays, same bench by the window, same —" Louis laughed, once, and it came out wrong. "She told me the same thing. She made me swear."
"She's got a nerve," Harry said, with no force in it at all. "All these years. She's been handing the same recipe to every sad eighteen-year-old in South Manchester."
"She'd say it's not the same recipe. She'd say it's a method."
"I don't care what she'd say." Harry's voice had gone flat. "This isn't about her. It's about the two of us selling the same bun forty metres apart and both of us thinking it's ours."
"Because we were both told it was ours."
"Yes."
Talia was back, phone first. "Okay, that was exciting, that was very exciting, people are genuinely divided, I'm calling it a draw on taste and a win for the audience — can I get a picture? Just you two, at the boards. Look at each other."
"No," said Louis.
"Just make it quick," said Harry.
They stood at the two boards with the two trays, and Talia said look at each other, and Louis looked at Harry because the alternative was looking at the camera, and Harry looked back at him, and neither of them arranged their face into anything.
"Perfect," said Talia. "That's the shot. Grumpy versus sunshine, the bun wars, I love it. Hang on, one more, the light's gone — hold that."
She held it for nine seconds. Louis counted. He could hear the cheese man laughing at something and a kid asking his mother which tray was which, and the whole time Harry just looked at him, steady, with that stillness on him like a closed door.
Then Talia said done and walked off and Harry turned back to his stall without a word, and Louis put his hands in his apron and found them shaking slightly, which was ridiculous, because he had won nothing and lost nothing and it was only bread.
At three, the market wound down. Louis sold out; so had Harry, which he knew because he checked, which he told himself was logistics.
At ten past four Harry came round the end of the pitch with his till box under his arm and said, "She keeps a shop front in Chorlton. Not the hall anymore. Off Beech Road. She'll be in Tuesday to Friday and she doesn't like being phoned."
"I didn't ask."
"You were going to get her address off the internet and go on a Sunday when she's shut, and you'd stand outside like a saddo and go home." Harry shifted the box. "You're welcome."
"Why are you telling me?"
"Because she's eighty-one and someone should tell her what her recipe's doing to the neighbourhood." Harry started walking. Over his shoulder, without turning: "And because if you go, I want to hear it from you what she says. Not from Instagram."
He was gone past the pickle woman before Louis thought of a reply.
Louis got the bus back up Oldham Road with the empty trays stacked on his knees. The photo was up before he got home — Manc Eats, 4:41pm, two men over two identical buns, caption reading THE BUN WARS: a draw, and neither of them looks happy about it. Eight hundred likes by the time he opened his own door.
He put the trays in the sink and stood in the kitchen not moving, and then his phone went.
**Dad:** Coming to see the new place Sunday. Bringing someone.
Louis read it four times. Sunday. That was tomorrow. Reg had said Saturday and Louis had planned Saturday and survived Saturday, and now the plan was gone and there was a someone, and Reg had never once in Louis's life brought a someone anywhere.
He typed what do you mean bringing someone and deleted it. He typed who and deleted it. He typed great see you at 11 and sent it, and then he sat down on the floor of his own kitchen, back against the cupboard under the sink, where the blue pot was, and started trying to work out what a widower of five years might mean by *someone* — and whether he was expected to be pleased, and whether he had anything in the flat to feed three people, and whether the someone had ever been told he existed at all.