Letters from the Coast

Chapter 19: The Fourth Letter

The storage unit door rolled down with a sound like a throat clearing. Nathan turned the keys over in his palm twice before pocketing them, and then he just stood there in the gravel lot, breathing the cold that came off the river.

Ben hadn't left. He was leaning against the hood of his truck forty feet away, arms crossed, not looking at Nathan, not looking away either. Waiting. The way he always waited.

Nathan walked past him to his own car, got in, and drove south with the radio off.

He made it eleven miles before he pulled into a rest area and killed the engine and sat with his hands on the wheel, shaking. Not crying. Shaking, which was worse, because it had no bottom to it. He reached over to the passenger seat and picked up the coffee-shop box, which he'd carried out of the unit along with the journals, and set it on his lap.

He had not catalogued it. He had told himself there was no time. The truth was simpler: he had been afraid of it since Damariscotta.

There were three letters inside. He had read the first one in the café in February, the second in a motel in Rockland, the third out loud in a parking lot while Ben watched him. Daniel had numbered them on the backs of the envelopes — one, two, three — in that slanted hand of his, the same hand that had written *milk* on the grocery list and *I love you* on the last birthday card, the hand that was now only a shape on paper.

He sorted them. And there it was. Four.

Nathan hadn't seen it because he hadn't looked. It had been tucked inside the flap of the first envelope all along, a smaller square of paper folded twice, sealed with a strip of tape. He peeled the tape with his thumbnail and read it in the dome light.

*Nathan.*

*I'm not going to make this easy on you. I never did.*

*Go to Camden. The east side of the harbor, the bench at the end of the public landing, the one with the broken slat. Sit there at seven in the morning, when the boats go out. Then do what the fifth letter says — no, I'm joking, there is no fifth letter, I ran out of time and out of nerve. The rest you'll have to do without me.*

*Here is the thing I want. I want you to forgive Ben.*

*Not for him. I know what you're thinking. You're thinking I have no right, and you're right, I have no right. I spent eleven years arranging you both like furniture in a room you didn't know I was building. I told myself it was love. Some of it was. Some of it was fear, because I knew what was coming and I couldn't stand the idea of you alone in that store with the bell over the door and no one coming in.*

*Ben drove to Kennebunkport. I know he told you. He turned around at the bridge and came home and never said a word to you, and I sat across from him at the Anchor and watched him not say it, and I said nothing, and that is the worst thing I have ever done and I have done some things.*

*So. Camden. Sit on the bench. Watch the boats. And when he comes — he'll come, he's never once not come — try to see him. Not as what I left behind for you. As what he is.*

*I'm sorry I couldn't say this to your face. I was a coward at the end. I was a coward for most of it.*

*D.*

Nathan read it twice. The dome light clicked off on its timer and he sat in the dark with the paper between his fingers.

He got out his phone.

Ben picked up on the second ring. There was engine noise behind him — the low diesel thrum of the *Margaret Rose*, the ferry he'd run for nineteen years, the boat that had carried Nathan and Daniel out to Monhegan the summer they met.

"You're on the water," Nathan said.

"Ten o'clock run. I picked up Dougie's shift." A pause. "You okay?"

"No." Nathan looked at the letter. "Camden. Tomorrow. Seven in the morning, the public landing, the bench with the broken slat. He wants me there."

Silence. The engine noise went on.

"Ben."

"I heard you." Ben's voice had gone careful, the way it did when he was holding something. "I know the bench."

"Of course you do."

"That's not —" Ben stopped. Started again. "I'll be there. It's a forty-minute run in the morning, I can take the skiff over, I'll be there by six-thirty."

"Fine."

"Nathan." The engine noise dropped as he throttled back, and now Nathan could hear the wind on his end, the slap of water. "What did the letter say."

Nathan looked at the words *try to see him* until they stopped meaning anything.

"It said go to Camden," he said. "That's all."

He hung up.

He slept three hours in the car in a Walmart lot in Brunswick, and woke before five with his neck stiff and the fourth letter creased in his fist. He drove the rest of the way up the coast in the dark, Route 1 empty except for one logging truck, the sky going gray over the water on his left.

He got there at six-forty. The public landing was quiet — a few trucks with boat trailers, a man hosing blood off the pier, gulls arguing over something in the gutter. The bench was where Daniel said. Third slat from the left, split down the middle, a rusted bolt holding the two halves apart.

Nathan sat. The wind came off the harbor sharp and salt-cold. A dragger chugged out past the breakwater, running lights still on, and he watched it until it was a smudge.

He took out the letters and laid them on his knee.

One, two, three, four.

And then, because his hands needed something to do, he picked up the first one again — the one he'd read in the café in February, the one that had started all of this — and read it slowly, all the way to the bottom, the way you read a thing the second time when you know what it costs.

It was the same letter he remembered. *Go north. Start where we started.* The list of towns. The instructions about the box, the key, the locker.

But there was more at the bottom than he remembered. Under the signature, in smaller writing, cramped into the margin the way Daniel wrote when he was running out of room:

*P.S. — When you get to the Portland Head logbook, ask someone about the missing page. Page 47. I took it. I'm sorry. You'll understand when you find it. — D.*

Nathan sat very still.

Page 47. He had held that logbook in his hands in March. He had turned to January 1954 and found the gap — the neat razor line where a page had been cut out, the stubs still in the binding. He had asked the volunteer at the desk about it and she had told him it had been missing for years, before her time, and he had written it in his notebook and moved on.

He had thought it was a coincidence.

He had thought it was part of the Ellis thing, the drowned brother, the family erasure, some fifty-year-old secret that had nothing to do with him.

*I took it.*

Daniel had been in that archive. Daniel had stood at that desk with a razor blade or a pocketknife and cut page 47 out of a historical society logbook and walked out with it in his coat.

Ben had known. That was what Nathan had understood in the storage unit — that Ben had been carrying Daniel's secrets, that Ben knew who had torn the page. He had assumed Ben knew because Daniel told him the Ellis story.

But Daniel had written the postscript to *Nathan*. In the first letter. In February. Before any of this. He had left a trail of breadcrumbs pointing at his own crime and trusted Nathan to follow it, and Nathan had walked right past it and filed it under *old family history* and never looked back.

He had been so sure he knew what the journey was about.

He turned the envelope over. The postmark was December 12th. Six days before Daniel died. The letter had been in the box the whole time, under the mug, under the notebook, waiting.

A boat horn sounded somewhere out past the breakwater. Nathan looked up and saw a skiff coming around the point, small and dark against the water, and a man in it standing at the tiller with one hand on the outboard, and he knew it was Ben before he could see the face.

He folded the letter and put it in his pocket. Seven forty-seven. Ben was late.

That was when he noticed the man walking up the pier toward him — not Ben, someone older, in a canvas jacket, carrying a cardboard folder under his arm and looking at Nathan the way people look at someone they've been told to find.

"Mr. Cole?" the man said.

Nathan stood up.

"I'm from the Portland Head Light archive," the man said. He held out the folder. "Somebody dropped this off last night. No name. Said you'd be here."

The folder was heavy. There was a single page inside. Old paper, ruled, with a column of weather observations in faded ink — wind, swell, visibility — and along the bottom, in a hand Nathan knew as well as his own, a paragraph of blue ballpoint that did not belong to 1954 at all.

He looked up. Ben's skiff was still two hundred yards out.

"What did he look like?" Nathan said.

"Who?"

"The man who dropped it off."

The archivist frowned at the water, thinking. "Older. Maybe seventy. Bad limp. Said he was a friend of the family."

Nathan looked down at the page in his hands, at Daniel's handwriting scrawled across the bottom of it, and read the first line.

*I killed my brother.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.