The road up Mount Battie was a slow coil through birch and pine, and Nathan took it in second gear with the window down, the cold sea air cutting through the car and doing nothing to settle him. He had driven from Damariscotta before dawn, the crate and the cigarettes and the unsent letter all locked back in the storage unit behind a door he was already starting to think of as a grave. The urn sat on the passenger seat in its canvas bag, belted in like a child.
Daniel had loved this mountain. Not the view, particularly — Daniel had a contrarian streak about views, he'd say the reward of a climb should be the climb — but the drive, the switchbacks, the way the trees opened at the top and the whole harbor lay there like something spilled. They had come up here the first summer after Nathan's mother died, and Daniel had stood at the railing for a long time without saying anything, and then he'd said, *I want to be somewhere like this when I go. Somewhere that keeps going.*
The summit parking lot was empty at seven in the morning. Nathan took the canvas bag and walked out to the eastern railing, where Camden lay below in cold blue layers — the harbor, the breakwater, the islands stepping out into the light. The wind came off the water with a salt edge that stung his eyes, and he let it.
He'd read the fourth letter three times in the motel room, and it hadn't gotten easier.
*I'm asking you to forgive him. That's the whole thing. That's the ask.*
He opened the urn. Daniel had wanted to be scattered, and Nathan had spent four months unable to do it anywhere, because everywhere had felt like a lie — the bookstore, the apartment, the cove where they'd first said they loved each other. None of it had been Daniel's, exactly. Daniel had wanted *somewhere that keeps going.*
Nathan poured him out into the wind in a slow careful stream, and the ash went sideways and down toward the harbor and was gone. He stood there with the empty urn in his hands for a long time, and then he said, out loud, because there was no one to hear it, "You could have just told me."
The wind didn't answer. He hadn't expected it to.
He sat on the bench by the railing and waited. Ben had said he'd come. Ben had said it in a voice like a man agreeing to something he knew would hurt.
By nine, Nathan had started checking his phone. By ten, he was cold through and had moved to the car to run the heat. By eleven, he was furious — not at Ben, exactly, or not only at Ben, but at the whole arrangement, the whole long joke of it. Daniel writes the script. Daniel casts the parts. Daniel dies and the two of them show up on a mountain to perform it.
At eleven forty, Ben's truck came up the switchbacks and parked two spaces over.
He looked bad. That was the first thing. Ben Riordan generally looked like a man who slept well and didn't think about it; he had that ferryman's calm, weathered and unhurried, and it had always been the thing Nathan found steadying about him even when he'd wanted to hate him. Today he came out of the truck gray-faced, his jacket unzipped, his hair not combed, and he crossed the lot at a walk that was almost a stumble, and he stopped in front of Nathan like a man who'd been told not to move.
"You're late," Nathan said.
"I know."
"Three hours."
"I know. I'm sorry." Ben's voice was scraped down to something raw. "I stopped at the house. I wasn't going to — I was going to come straight. But I had to look for something, and I found it, and I couldn't come up here until I had it in my hands."
Nathan looked at him. There was a page in Ben's hand, a single sheet, folded and unfolded and folded again until it was soft as cloth, and Nathan recognized the paper before he recognized anything else.
"The missing logbook page," Nathan said.
"Yeah."
"You told me you didn't know where it went."
"I didn't. That's true. I didn't know it was missing until you told me." Ben sat down on the other end of the bench, keeping the space between them, and turned the page over in his hands without looking at it. "It was in with his things. The box I kept. I put everything of his in there and I never went through it, I couldn't, and this morning — I don't know. I woke up and I knew I had to."
"You went through it three hours ago."
"I went through it three hours ago."
Nathan made himself breathe. "So read it."
Ben did not read it. He held it out instead, across the space between them, and Nathan took it, and the wind grabbed at the corner and he had to weight it down against his knee.
Daniel's handwriting. Small and slanted, the letters running into each other like they were in a hurry. A logbook page — the ferry's own paper, the date stamped at the top from four years ago, the night in June that Nathan had built his whole grievance on. The night the ferry had turned back in calm water for no reason, twenty minutes from the wharf, and Ben had brought the boat around and taken them home, and Nathan had stood on the dock and said *what the hell was that*, and Ben had said *I just didn't think we should go*, and that had been the end of it.
Except it hadn't been the end. It had been the beginning of eleven years of Nathan holding one small cold stone in his pocket, a stone he'd never shown anyone, a stone labeled *Ben stopped the ferry*.
He read it twice. The first time he didn't understand it. The second time he did.
*Ben —*
*You'll have this in your log and I need it written down so somebody knows. I asked you to turn around tonight. I know what it cost you, I know you'll have to explain it to the office, and I'm writing this so there's a record of why: I asked you. I asked you because I didn't want to be on that boat anymore, and I didn't want Nathan to see it. That's the whole of it. He was sitting up front by himself looking at the water and I knew if I stayed on board one more mile he'd turn around and look at me and see it. I didn't want to be seen that way. Not by him. Not yet.*
*So I asked you. And you did it, and you let me be the reason without ever saying so, and you let Nathan think it was your choice. I know what that makes me. I'm the person who put you in the position of lying for me, and I'm going to keep doing it, because it's the only way I know how to keep him.*
*You're the best man I know. This doesn't say what you think it says. It says I'm sorry.*
*D.*
Nathan read it a third time. His hands were very steady and he didn't know why that was, when everything else in him wasn't.
"He never told me," Nathan said.
"No."
"Four years. You took it for four years."
"I took it." Ben's eyes were on the harbor, and his jaw was working, but his voice stayed quiet. "He asked me the night of, Nathan. On the boat. He came up to the wheelhouse and he was shaking and he asked me to take it back. And I looked at him and I knew, and I took it back, and I never told you why."
"You could have."
"That wasn't mine to give away." Ben finally looked at him. "It was his. He was sick. He was the sick one, and he asked me for one thing that wasn't even really for him, it was for you — he didn't want you to see him break. What was I supposed to do, hand you that? You'd have carried it every day since. He knew that. That's *why* he didn't say it."
Nathan looked out at the water, at Camden going hard and bright in the late morning, and felt the cold stone in his pocket that had been there so long it had worn a shape into him. He'd taken it out on nights when the bookstore was empty and rubbed it and told himself the story: Ben Riordan, who broke his heart once at twenty-three and again at forty, who had stopped the ferry because he was afraid, who had never had the spine to want anything enough.
The page in his hand said otherwise.
"I blamed you for four years," Nathan said.
"I know."
"Every time I looked at you I thought it."
"I know." Ben's voice didn't change. "I'd have thought it too."
The wind came up off the harbor and lifted the corner of the page, and Nathan pressed it flat, and above it, below the letter, in the margin, in a different hand — Daniel's, but looser, later — there was one more line that he hadn't read the first three times because he'd stopped reading.
*P.S. I never made him promise not to tell you. That was his own choice. He's better than both of us. — D.*
Nathan sat with that a moment. The whole mountain was very quiet.
"There's more," Ben said.
Nathan looked at him.
"The locker," Ben said. "The one he gave me the key to. I opened it this morning."