Letters from the Coast

Chapter 38: The Cigarette Truth

The store smelled like paper and rain. Nathan stood in the back room with the drawer open, the last letter sitting on top of the stack like it had been waiting for him to stop being a coward.

He didn't open it yet.

Instead he pulled out Daniel's journals. The old ones, from before the diagnosis, from the years when Nathan still flinched every time Daniel stepped onto the porch with a cigarette. He'd kept them all, even the ones Nathan had told him to throw away.

He sat down at the desk—the same desk where he'd found the missing page yesterday—and opened the third journal. The spine cracked. Daniel's handwriting, small and slanted, filled the pages.

*The doctor says I should quit. Nathan says I should quit. Everyone says I should quit. What they mean is they want me to be someone else. What they mean is they want me to live forever so they don't have to feel what they're feeling.*

Nathan stopped. He hadn't read this one. Daniel had kept it hidden under a floorboard in the back room—a spot Nathan had only discovered when he was looking for the missing logbook page yesterday.

He kept reading.

*I know he hates it. I see it in the way he turns his head when I light up on the porch. The little cough he does—not real, just a signal. I know I should care more. But it's the one thing that's still mine. The one thing I didn't have to give up when everything else got taken.*

*He thinks I'm killing myself. He's not wrong. But he doesn't understand that some people need a little death to get through the day.*

Nathan closed the journal. His hands were shaking.

That was it. That was the whole thing. They'd fought about it for seventeen years—not the big fights, not the ones that leave bruises on the walls, but the ones that leave bruises on the inside. The little ones. The ones you carry around like a stone in your shoe.

He'd asked Daniel to quit. Begged him. Once, in the hospital, when the scans came back, he'd said, *you did this to yourself,* and Daniel had just looked at him with those tired eyes and said, *maybe I did it to both of us.*

Nathan had never apologized for that. Daniel had never asked him to.

He stood up. Walked to the kitchen. The broken chipmunk mug sat on the counter where he'd left it—the handle cracked, the face still smiling. He picked it up. Ran his thumb over the chip.

Daniel had bought it at a yard sale in Bar Harbor. The first summer they'd come up here. *It's my mug now,* he'd said. *It's ugly and I love it.*

Nathan set it down. He went to the drawer where he kept the stationery. The good stuff—cotton paper, cream-colored, the kind you'd use for a wedding invitation or a eulogy. He took out two sheets. Sat back down.

For a long time, he didn't write anything.

Then he picked up the pen.

*Daniel,*

*I'm sorry I told you that you did this to yourself.*

*I was terrified. I was so goddamn terrified that I made it your fault. Like if you were the one who made the choice, then I could be angry at you instead of at the world. Instead of at God. Instead of at myself for not being able to save you.*

*I hated the smoking. I hated the way it made you smell and the way it made you cough and the way it made you leave the room every hour. But more than that, I hated that you didn't need me for it. You had this thing that was yours, and I couldn't follow you into it. I couldn't protect you from it.*

*You were right. It wasn't just killing you. It was killing me too. It was killing us.*

*I kept the mug. The chipmunk one. It's cracked and it's ugly and I love it.*

*I forgive you. For all of it. For the secret letters and the plotting and the way you thought you could run my life from beyond the grave. I know you did it because you loved me. I know you did it because you were afraid I'd be alone. And I am. I am alone. But that's not your fault.*

*I forgive you for leaving.*

*I even forgive you for thinking you could orchestrate my life like one of your paintings.*

*I don't forgive you for being right about Ben.*

*But I'm working on that.*

*I love you. I'll always love you. That's the part we never had to fight about.*

*—Nathan*

He folded the letter. Put it in an envelope. Didn't seal it.

Then he took the second sheet.

*Ben,*

*I saw the logbook.*

*I saw what you wrote. I saw that you waited. I saw that you stopped.*

*I don't know if you'll get this. I don't know if you'll read it. I don't even know if you're still on that ferry or if you've docked somewhere and walked away from all of it.*

*But I need you to know something.*

*Daniel wrote me twelve letters. I've read eleven of them. The twelfth is still in the drawer. I'm not ready for it. But I've read enough to know that he told you to come find me. He told you to wait. He told you he was dying.*

*He told you a lot of things he never told me.*

*I'm angry at him. I'm angry at you. I'm angry at myself. It's a lot of anger and I don't know where to put it.*

*But underneath all of that, I remember.*

*I remember the way you used to laugh. The way you'd put your hand on my shoulder and leave it there a second too long. The way you'd show up at my door with two coffees and no explanation.*

*I remember you.*

*I don't know what that means yet. I don't know if it means anything at all. But I wanted you to know that I remember.*

*Don't write back. Not yet. I'm not ready.*

*But don't disappear either.*

*—Nathan*

He stared at the two letters. One for the dead. One for the living. He folded Ben's letter and put it in his pocket. He'd carry it around until he figured out what to do with it. That was what he did with things he couldn't send.

The rain had stopped.

He walked to the front of the store. The window was dark. The street was empty. The ferry schedule was still tacked to the corkboard by the register—he'd checked it three times since yesterday, like the times might change if he looked hard enough.

Ben's ferry was due at seven.

Nathan pulled the letter from his pocket. Unfolded it. Read it again.

*Don't write back. Not yet.*

He read it a third time.

Then he folded it and put it back in his pocket.

He went to the back room. Picked up the second letter—the one to Daniel—and carried it to the drawer where he kept Daniel's things. The journals. The paintbrushes. The stupid chipmunk mug.

He set the letter on top. Closed the drawer.

He thought about Daniel. About the smoking. About all the nights he'd lain awake listening to Daniel cough on the porch, and how every single time, he'd wanted to go out there and sit with him. Just sit. Not ask him to quit. Not make him feel like a child. Just sit.

He'd never done that.

He'd never just sat.

That was the thing he had to forgive himself for. Not the anger. Not the fight in the hospital. Not the way he'd pulled away at the end, when Daniel needed him to stay.

He hadn't sat.

He sat now. In the chair behind the register. The store was empty and dark and quiet, and he sat with it.

His phone buzzed. He looked at it.

A text from an unknown number. *This is Ben. I'm back. I saw the logbook.*

Nathan's heart stopped.

Then: *Can we talk?*

He stared at the screen for a long time. He thought about the letter in his pocket. About the one in the drawer. About all the things he hadn't said yet and all the things he wasn't ready to hear.

He typed back. *Tomorrow. 10 a.m. The store.*

He hit send before he could change his mind.

Then he sat back in the chair. The chipmunk mug smiled at him from the counter. The rain had stopped. The town was quiet. And for the first time since Daniel died, Nathan didn't feel alone.

He felt terrified.

But that was something.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 38: The Cigarette Truth · Letters from the Coast · Lumen Reads