Claire arrived first, which surprised him. She was fifteen minutes early and stood outside the window in a gray wool coat with her hands in her pockets, reading the handwritten sign he'd taped to the glass — GRIEF & LOSS, TUESDAYS, 6:30. She read it the way people read menus they've already decided against, then came in anyway.
"You're Nathan," she said.
"I am."
"I saw the notice in the laundromat. Is it just you?"
"It's new. We had three last week." He came around the counter. "Coffee? It's from this morning. I can't promise anything."
"Black is fine."
She was somewhere in her early fifties, no ring, good boots, the kind of haircut that suggested she'd stopped pretending about a lot of things. She took the chair nearest the window, not the one nearest him. He filed that away.
Walter came in at twenty after with a box of donuts neither of them needed, and Dot followed at the half hour, and that was the whole support group: four people in mismatched chairs in the back of a bookstore that smelled like dust and old paper and, faintly, the coffee going cold on the hot plate. Nathan had moved the poetry section to make room. He wasn't sure yet whether he'd move it back.
"I don't have a program," he said. "I didn't go to school for this. I run a bookstore. My — " He stopped. Started again. "I lost my partner in August. Nine months. Some days it's a year, some days it's yesterday. I thought maybe other people might want somewhere to sit with it."
Dot talked about her husband, dead eleven years, how she still set two cups out some mornings and had stopped trying to fix it. Walter talked about his brother, an accident, a phone call he'd taken standing in a grocery store aisle and had never been able to walk down since. Claire listened with her coffee balanced on her knee and didn't say anything at all, and when the hour was nearly up Nathan looked at her and she looked back at him evenly.
"You want the short version or the real one," she said.
"Whichever you've got."
"Short version. I was married for nineteen years. It was fine. It was — he was a decent man, we had a house, we had a dog, we had nothing to say to each other for the last six of it. He died at forty-eight. Heart. And I spent two years after that being the widow, doing everything right, and then I woke up one morning at fifty and realized I'd been grieving a marriage that had already died before he did, and that I'd never once, in nineteen years, been honest with another human being about what I actually wanted."
The room was quiet. Walter studied his donut. Dot's glasses had fogged.
"So what did you do," Nathan said.
"I called the woman I was in love with when I was twenty-two." Claire took a sip of coffee. "That's it. Big story. Twenty-nine years late, one phone call, and she was — she'd just gotten divorced, and she was living in Portland, and she thought I'd died. She was polite about it. She said she was glad I was alive." She set the cup down. "And then we talked for two hours. And then three hours the next night. And that was four years ago and I'm picking her up from the airport on Thursday."
"Wait," Dot said, delighted, sitting up. "You got her back."
"I got her back. Nine months after I made the call. She wasn't going to hand me anything. Why should she? I'd been gone." Claire shrugged. "It took a year to earn the second night. It took longer to earn her trust. Worth every minute, and I'd have said the same if she'd told me no."
Nathan had been standing. He only noticed because his feet ached.
"Why waste the time," Claire said, watching him. "That's what nobody tells you. When you finally get honest, you think you're saving the other person the trouble. You're not. You're just hoarding it to yourself, like it's a thing you can hold." Her eyes moved to the counter and stopped. "What happened to the mug?"
Nathan looked. The broken chipmunk mug sat on the corner of the register where he'd left it two weeks ago, hairline crack down the handle, paperweight now. He hadn't been able to throw it out and hadn't been able to glue it.
"My partner broke it the week before he died," Nathan said. "He ordered it in a fit of — I don't know. He thought it was funny. The chipmunk. He broke it and he hid it in the back of the cabinet so I wouldn't know, and I found it after." He heard himself say this and thought: I have not told anyone this. "It was in the cabinet. Like it hadn't happened."
"Like it hadn't happened," Claire repeated.
"It happened."
"Then put it back together."
"It doesn't hold coffee."
"So put a plant in it." She gave him a look as flat and clean as a knife. "You're treating the whole man like that mug. All the pieces in the cabinet. The letters, the — you said letters?"
Nathan stood very still.
"How'd you know about the letters?"
"Walter said something before you came out." She stood up and buttoned her coat. Her coffee was untouched past the first sip. "I'm not trying to tell you your business, Nathan. I'll see you next week."
"You're leaving?"
"I said forty-five minutes. I've got to meet someone." At the door she paused and looked back at the three of them, the half-lit shop, the empty chairs. "One more thing and then I'm gone. The man I love doesn't know I'm picking her up Thursday. I haven't told her. I have a whole speech prepared, and if I stand here much longer I'll talk myself out of the airport, and then I'll be fifty-four and still telling a dead man what I should have said to the living." She pulled the door open. "Why waste the time."
The bell over the door swung and settled. Cold air hung in the room a moment. Dot blew her nose. Walter said, "Huh," which was, for Walter, quite a lot.
Nathan didn't sit down. He walked to the counter and picked up the chipmunk mug and turned it in his hands. Then he set it back down and went to the back room and stood in front of the desk, where the drawer held the letter from Daniel he still hadn't opened and the one he'd written that he still hadn't sent. He put his hand on the drawer and did not open it.
In his pocket, folded twice, was the unfinished letter to Ben. He pulled it out and read the last line he'd written and then the blank space underneath, and his own question mark at the bottom, the one that meant he hadn't known how to finish.
He knew how to finish it now.
Not that he was writing the ending. That wasn't it. But the part about himself — the part that had said, I can't do this, I pushed you away, you deserve someone with the grace to help you carry what I made you carry and I can't even carry myself — that part he could end. That part he could set down.
He folded the letter and put it back in his pocket, folded differently, the blank side out, and went and switched off the hot plate and turned the sign to CLOSED and stood in the window a moment. Across the street, past the wharf roofs, the harbor road ran dark toward the terminal. He didn't know when Ben's ferry got in. He didn't know if Ben was on it. He didn't know if Ben would even speak to him — the deck log had been clear about that, that Ben had decided to stop waiting, and three days of silence from the terminal had not exactly suggested otherwise.
He took out his phone. The unsent draft was still there, eighteen words he'd never finished, and he deleted it. He didn't need it. He was going to do this with his own mouth or not at all.
He turned off the lights and locked the door and stood on the sidewalk in the cold, and then he started to walk the other way — up the hill, toward the harbor road, past the terminal if he had to, all the way to wherever Ben actually slept when he wasn't on the water, because he'd spent nine months opening other people's letters and never once answering the one Ben had left in his hand.
Halfway up the hill he stopped, because the thought had arrived all at once and cold, the way the important ones do.
Claire had said it: twenty-nine years late. She had been standing at the door about to walk away from the airport.
And Nathan had been to the terminal twice already and turned back, and Ben had seen him both times and written it down, and tomorrow morning at ten Ben was coming to the store because Nathan had asked. He'd said yes. Of everything, he had said yes.
Which meant if Nathan went to Ben tonight he would be doing it in the dark, without a single word prepared, and Ben would read it exactly the way he'd read Nathan turning away twice on the pier: like a man who couldn't decide.
Nathan stood on the hill above the harbor with the lights of the terminal winking below him and made himself choose. He turned around. He went home.
Tomorrow, ten o'clock. Whatever was in the drawer, whatever was in the envelope, whatever Ben had decided — he would say it to Ben's face, in daylight, in the shop where it had begun.
It was the longest night he'd had in nine months.