The harbor wind had teeth that morning. Nathan stood at the chain-link gate of the ferry terminal with his coat collar up, watching the gray water chew at the pilings.
The ticket window was shuttered. A laminated sign taped inside the glass read: *M/V Margaret Chase — SUSPENDED. Weather.*
He'd checked the schedule twice before leaving the store. He'd known. He'd come anyway.
A deckhand in an orange jacket was coiling rope on the wharf, the kind of bored that comes from a canceled run. Nathan walked down the ramp toward him.
"Is Ben coming in today?"
The deckhand didn't look up. "Boss is out. Been out."
"Out where?"
"Out." The man spat into the water. "Three days he's been running the trap line with his brother up in Stonington. Boat's laid up anyhow. Should be back tonight, weather permitting."
*Weather permitting.* Nathan looked at the sky. It was ugly, but it wasn't closing.
He walked back up the ramp and sat on the wooden bench outside the terminal, the one that faced the water. He'd sat on this bench once before, years ago, waiting for Daniel to come off the afternoon run with a bag of pastries from the mainland, faces flushed from the wind. Daniel always brought pastries. It was a stupid, tender thing he did.
Nathan had come here two weeks ago and turned around. Twice. He'd read Ben's log entry about it. The one that said Ben had seen him and decided to stop waiting. He still felt the sting of that, low and specific, like a splinter he'd stopped being able to locate.
He took out his phone. The draft text was still there. *Ben, I need to say this in person. Can I—*
He didn't send it. He put the phone back in his pocket and watched the water.
Hour one passed. A gull argued with another gull over something unidentifiable. An old man in a yellow slicker came to the gate, read the sign, swore softly, and left.
Hour two. Nathan's fingers had gone numb. He bought a coffee from a vending machine inside the terminal that took his dollar and gave him something brown that was not coffee. He drank it anyway. He thought about the letter in his coat pocket — the unfinished one for Ben, the one he'd never sent, the one he'd written after reading Daniel's journal and hadn't known how to end. He touched the folded edge of it through the fabric. He didn't take it out.
The ferry was a speck on the horizon by one o'clock. Nathan stood up. He had no good reason to stand up. He stood up anyway.
The boat grew. It was smaller than he'd pictured, or maybe the water had grown larger. It came in slow, the way fishing boats come in, unhurried, indifferent to whether anyone on shore was watching. The deckhand from before walked down with the bowline. Another man was at the wheel. Nathan couldn't tell if it was Ben until the boat turned broadside and the wind caught the light.
It was Ben.
He cut the engine and let the boat drift against the pilings, and for a moment he didn't look at the dock. He had on a navy sweater with a tear in the shoulder, and his hair was longer than Nathan remembered, and his face had that particular weather-beaten set of a man who had been on the water too long by himself. He tied off the stern line, then the bow, then straightened.
He saw Nathan.
Neither of them moved for a beat. The water slapped between the boat and the dock.
Ben picked up a duffel bag and stepped onto the ramp. His boots were heavy. He walked up to within six feet and stopped.
"You waited," he said.
His voice was the same. That was the thing that undid Nathan — the sameness of it, the way Ben's voice had always sat low and easy in his chest. He'd spent years not hearing it and had convinced himself he'd forgotten what it sounded like.
"I didn't know when you'd be back," Nathan said. "The sign said suspended."
"It was. I took the skiff instead." Ben shifted the duffel to his other hand. He wasn't quite looking at Nathan, but he wasn't looking away either. "You left a note. In the log."
"I did."
"And you called."
"I did."
Ben nodded slowly, like he was confirming a fact he'd already checked. "I listened to it three times."
Nathan's throat went tight. "Ben—"
"Don't." Ben held up a hand, the flat of it, not unkind. "I'm not — I don't know what I'm doing here. I got your note and then I sat with it for two days on the water and I still don't know. So if you're about to say something that makes this easier, don't. I don't want it easy."
Nathan let out a breath. The wind took it. "Okay."
Ben looked at him then, really looked, and there was something in his face that had been held down for a long time and was now, slowly, being let up. "You look like hell, Nate."
"Thanks."
"I mean it kindly."
"I know you do." Nathan shoved his hands deeper into his coat. "I came here to apologize. So I'm going to do it, and you can stand there and take it or walk away, and I won't follow you."
Ben didn't move.
"I pushed you away," Nathan said. "After Daniel died. You came to the store and you brought me that — that casserole, the one your mother used to make, and I told you I didn't need anything, and you stood in the doorway and I shut the door on you. I remember your face. I've remembered it every night since, which is a stupid thing to say because I don't know if that's true, but it feels true. I shut the door and I didn't open it again."
Ben's jaw worked. "You had reasons."
"I had excuses. I told myself you'd broken my heart first, years ago, so it was fair. I told myself I didn't need anyone. I told myself I was being loyal to Daniel." Nathan's voice cracked on the name. He let it. "Daniel would have hated that. He would have—" He stopped. He tried again. "I used him as a wall. And you were on the other side of it, and you deserved better than that. That's the apology. I'm sorry, Ben. For all of it."
The gull screamed somewhere behind them. Ben didn't answer for a long time.
When he did, his voice was flatter than before, and it hurt worse. "You know what I did for three days? I ran the trap line with my brother and I told him I was fine, and he didn't believe me, and I didn't care. I kept thinking about that morning at the terminal. Two weeks ago. You came down the road, you got as far as the gate, and you turned around. And I sat up there in the wheelhouse and watched you do it."
"I know," Nathan said. "I read your log."
"I know you did. You wrote in it." Something that might have been almost a smile crossed Ben's face and left. "That's very you, actually. Writing in a book that wasn't yours."
"I'm sorry about that too."
"Don't be. I read it forty times." Ben set the duffel down on the dock, like he'd decided to stay standing there. "I'm not going to pretend this is fine. It's not fine. I don't know if you're here because you want me back, or because you're lonely, or because Daniel left you a letter that told you to do it. And I'm not interested in being a consolation prize."
"That's fair."
"Is it? Because I need you to know it's real. The not-fine part. I'm not —" He stopped, started again. "I'm not going to just pick up where we left off eleven years ago, and I'm not going to be your grief project, and I'm not going to stand in your doorway again waiting for you to decide I'm worth letting in. I did that once. It broke something."
"I know," Nathan said. "I broke something too."
Ben looked at him. The wind moved his hair. He looked tired and young at the same time, the way people do when they've been carrying something alone.
"I don't know what I want this to be," Ben said finally. "But I know I don't want to be standing on this dock three weeks from now wondering if you're going to turn around again."
"Then let's go somewhere," Nathan said. "The store. There's coffee, and there's a chair that doesn't rock, and there's nothing that has to be decided today. Just — come to the store. Talk to me. If it's nothing, it's nothing. But you're not standing on this dock."
Ben was quiet for a moment. Then he bent down and picked up his duffel.
"I'm not promising anything," he said.
"I'm not asking for anything."
They walked up the ramp together. The wind had dropped, a little. Behind them, the ferry rocked patient against the pilings, and neither of them looked back at it.
Then Ben stopped at the top of the ramp, short of the road.
"There's something else," he said. "I found something in the stern locker. I forgot to put it back."
He unzipped the duffel. Inside, on top of a folded sweater, was an envelope. Cream-colored. Old.
Nathan's stomach dropped.
"It's got your address on it," Ben said. "In Daniel's handwriting."